
So i personally don't mind fucked up stories. But i feel like the execution and the reasoning of this story just doesn't land. My favorite bl has to be "A painter behind the curtain" where the ML Raymon is such a detestable man for hurting others (especially Ian the MC) for his own gain. But for some reason... it fucking works. That's why i may hate him but i do love his characterization. His plots and action lead to so much dynamic to the story it was incredible. And the reason why he has to do what he has to do felt so valid coz literally his family was on top but some pesky noble just went and fuck up good people which was Raymon's family. I can't help but somehow emphatize his desperation on seeking vengence more than any other bl character i've ever read.
Enough the glazing, so does the MC's actions justify what has happen to him, his daughter and his actions???? NO... coz:
1) Bro got isekaied, what happened to the villainess shouldnt really emotionally impact him into protecting her coz... THAT'S TECHNICALLY NOT HIS DAUGHTER. Like i dont think u formed a proper bond over what u considered a fictional character when u read about this novel like come on -_-
2) Bruh the real perpetrator in this shinanigans is that stupid ass prince, not the girls. The girl saintess or whatever just happen to be spoil and got the attention of the guy who did the villainess wrong. And from what i heard in spoilers all this bitchass prince get is the shame of picking his girl wrong while the ones who indirectly caused this shit got more shit than this man. Like why doesnt the prince get fucked by dogs or the shit the girls get as well?
3) Why the guy so evil as i mention THIS MAN JUST GOT ISEKAIED. Like bro yes u are part of this shit coz u transmigrated to that fictional character but damn bro its so non-sensical that ur actions are to this extent coz THAT ISNT EVEN YOU. U know what im saying?
Like the fuck up-ness of this story just doesn't equate to the reason why the MC has to defend his daughter. It just leaves an icky feeling in a bad way icky. And yes many of yall say he's evil coz he's evil but man him being a 3rd party in this story just really doesn't make sense why he does that but maybe the original material being a novel into the manga didn't make the story as rich as it should be???? Idk i dont plan to really read the novel to bother if the writing their is better executed than in here ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭
Another story i love which is killing stalking (not bl but bare with me) is just fucked up but in the best way possible imo. The writing, characterization, intentions, are so on point that i see why the Sangwoo, Bum and story is so messed up is sooooo justified and makes so much sense. Unlike this one.
If yall enjoy villain stories coz of the sport of it, then this is def your cup of tea. But as for me... im still gonna read but that's just me to criticize it in silence LMAO. I will just say this is my personal taste ok? That's my 2 cents hope yall enjoy reading this one anyways (=・ω・=)

He did get isekaied at first but then he explained how actually he remembered a past life of his and his memories from baby till now are still his, therefore, whatever that he is rn is still motivated from before he remembers his past life. Hes just using the biggest plot advantage to execute whatever that he has been planning even better albeit differently. This makes sense to me.

He did get isekaied at first but then he explained how actually he remembered a past life of his and his memories from baby till now are still his, therefore, whatever that he is rn is still motivated from before he remembers his past life. Hes just using the biggest plot advantage to execute whatever that he has been planning even better albeit differently. This makes sense to me.

I feel that instead of being isekaid to that point is more like he became aware of the situation. Like, when a mc transmigrates/issekai/possesses a character we notice the difference in personality because the person inside changes... but that doesn't happen to mc because it was him from the start... so his feelings towards his daughter and the others are still the same and that's why I think it's valid for him to do what he does...
I do agree that her "punishment" seems harsher than the princes's. In a way it is and in a way it isn't. I'd like to remind you that the sole reason their country exists peacefully is because of the dragon. So, guess what will happen to the country after mc and his daughter pass away and the dragon leaves? So yeah... in a way that's the princes's punishment, the fall of his country... Again, I do think what her and her family ends in is far worse than the guys and would've liked to see them suffer more... I just don't think she just happened to get their attention... like, no woman make 4 guys, who are friends fall for her at the same time without being manipulative... and remember that even Jorga, father of 2 of them was a romance interest too... I honestly can't defend a woman that approaches a man knowing he has a fiancee.
So yah... I do think the guys punishment should be harsher... but what happened to the girls doesn't really bother me... but reading the book does give a deeper perspective on things... especially the relationship between mc and Jorga.

I don't tolerate the Yuan slander here i will say also hate misunderstandings to the core but in Yuan's case its actually reasonable why he'd let ajusshi go. There previous convos (chap 17 i think) literally have ajusshi say to Yuan he doesn't have anyone he like and Yuan should try dating, and their age gap is not viable implying in his way of saying he doesn't see Yuan as a love prospect. WHAT IS THERE NOT TO MISUNDERSTAND ON THAT!? I just feel like the lighter was the final nail to the coffin that made Yuan really assume that ajusshi will never see Yuan as a lover at all.
And to remind yall this is Yuan first experience of of a sexual relationship and he ended up liking that person. It was very much established they will just be partners and never had plans to move forward with. I might even say for someone with no experience and the information laid out to him, Yuan handled it pretty well. Letting go, getting hurt less from a real rejection and not ending his relationship (in what he assumes) in a messy note with ajusshi is him THINKING THIS THOROUGHLY. Of course as all of yall could say u can communicate and im sure in the future he def will, just let this boy experience and learn ok?? Leave him alone! Also as an insanely non-confrontational person this chap actually resonates to me coz I would do the same with the information laid down to me. I know its a shortcoming of mine but im trying to learn and Yuan will also learn to actually do as the story progress. Well that's my two cents.

I'd say that Yuan is like this because he's not reading enough bl webcomics. Because if he did, he'd get the opinion on so many arm chair experts who has never been on a relationship, so he's communicate all of his frustrations to Ajussi in a blink of an eye.
Btw, your explanation is spot on. I'm just frustrated by these people with their "Oh you can communicate" crap
This was such a cute read (≧∀≦)