AstroBoi's Topics (246)

stuff actually happens in the chapters, and there's not much filler. Plus the characters are really well made, so that probably helps a lot

facts

Had this exact thought too actually

Yes tes definitely and the smut is inserted tastefully

i understand ur pov, but still they could have chosen a different punishment. he was still useful in that tiny society of their.

Sorry to burst your bubble but they literally blindfolded everyone when they arrived to the village, they did the same to teach and guwan said it was a mandatory thing. So they literally could've blindfolded the old guy, driven him far and then dumped him somewhere else. Bro still wouldn't know where the village is. That's just not an excuse

okay. question to everyone. what punishment would be best? one that wouldn’t breed resentment, but would be harsh enough to deter others from committing the same crime in the future,

A quick death, gun shot wound straight to the head, how is this being debated?!
Also my previous reply would probably also be the most humane. In my opinion.

i think that’s fair. would i go so far as to saying that’s not an excuse? no. because everyone knew what the punishment was, from the chapter it was clear that everyone understood what would happen at and after the trial. again, if i’m putting my life on the line, life or death, in maintaining a safe society… i’m not taking ANY chances for someone to put that in jeopardy. blindfolds definitely lessen that chance significantly, but don’t eliminate it entirely.

Well now I know what side your are on in the apocalypse

Nah dude death as punishment??? That’s going too far. Punishment should definitely b in order. Something serious like imprisonment, no food no water for like 3 days. That should be good enough

they’re living in an apocalypse…for me, i’m not wasting a good bullet or the life of a gun on a rule breaker. every. single. thing they use is precious. to meet you halfway though they could’ve used a knife to slit his throat. but part of me wonders where the beating idea started…. idk just me.

no food or water for 3 days… that’s it??? i would steal the medicine 10 times over. light work

If you really want to preserve resources, just blindfold him and drop him off somewhere bruh, and you've also got a knife like you said. Why we still discussing this when you know what's morally right and just.

duh….? did you not read my original post or what.

bruh, you commented on MY post about MY opinion. if you don’t agree with me that’s cool. but then go away? smh

Yeah, you said you'd rather not take any risks. Implying you'd probably find yourself in a point where you feel the need to do the bad for the good. Degrading your mentality further until there is no moral judgment. I've read my post apocalyptic books, I know how these things go. It's not bad but it sure is ignorant

Why are being so angry, I'm literally just answering you cause you keep replying

i’m not “being angry” i’m literally just stating what i think. and if you think differently like i said, cool. but why are you being arrogant? saying things such as “when you know what is morally right and just” as if i’m supposed to automatically agree with you. people react differently to different situations. which is again, why i said, i’ll just off myself because it’s not worth having to deal with situations like the one we’re discussing. and i’m replying because AGAIN, it’s my post.

I would suggest that the father now has to become a ‘hound’ and now has to replace the medicine that he stole. Or, find something of equal or greater value. And he would have no privileges until he fulfilled his duty.
Of course, I’d also blindfold him before sending him out because he’s proven to be untrustworthy.

There’s still a risk with this, of him running away and trying to come back with people to get his son. It wouldn’t matter if he didn’t know the exact location. Just the rumor of a place like this existing is a MAJOR threat.

Another negative is that it would take away time and energy guarding him etc. that could be spent elsewhere.

and i’ve minored in psychology, does that make me an experiment on human behavior? no. neither does you reading works of fiction (〜￣△￣)〜

Yeah if you make a post expect replies, that's just media in general. Also I wasn't trying to be rude, if you go back I'm just being more factual replying to your replies. I like to say that EVERYONE at least has some moral judgment which is why I said you would know what is just and right. Unless you're mentally challenged which I hope your not. Anyways I've already moved on, I'm not dissing you about your opinion I'm just being factual from what's given to us

Psychoanalyst here buddy lol

this is a good suggestion though, but yeah it is a HUGE risk, and taking away that time and energy that could be spent elsewhere is crucial. it would be a coin toss for sure

A bullet in a zombie apocalypse is worth more than gold.
And if you’re judging by morality. There is no ‘humane’ way to execute someone because the act itself is inhumane.

then why talk about you reading works of fiction?? that’s just a weird way to assert your knowledge

okokok it depends on the crime, but death by getting BEAT by a bat??? TWD style??? You’d vote for that??? One thing’s for sure, I’m staying the hell away from society if there was an apocalypse. Lmao I rather die than live to turn into a monster

okay. i went back to your comments, but you didn’t. the very first thing you said was “sorry to burst your bubble” you’re a psychoanalyst. what do you think when someone starts a sentence off in that way. then you go on to say “how is this being debated ” which is ironic to you saying if i post then i should expect replies… then you lovely put in how i’m ignorant. so. what now?

yeah a bat is pretty brutal i confess, like i said ill just off myself before it even gets to that point ╮(￣▽￣)╭

If you go to my bio, I like to add my skill in reading, also since I'm reading I'm also just being a reader lol, but why be offended, what offended you?

Same... I'd just live in seclusion and migrate if I saw a group enter my terf

i legit just told you. with examples. here’s an fyi though. you can’t off the rip be rude, then back down by saying “i wasn’t being rude” after doing rude stuff, then go “what offended you” after i laid out exactly what you did, the gaslighting is peak.

Dude, in this thread alone you’ve implied that people that don’t agree with you lack moral judgment, are ignorant, and mentally challenged.
I think you need to relearn what constitutes ‘dissing’ someone.

I'm pretty sure if you know what the moral right and choose to ignore it for self interest, it IS being ignorant. The moral right would be to just blindfold him and leave him somewhere far away for the maggots to deal with. Far enough they wouldn't know where to go and Like others have said, there are better ways than just bludgening someone to death lol like using a knife. How is that being rude?

Also you took my words out of context I never implied anyone was mentally challenged I said I hoped your weren't mentally challenged, cause that's a bad place to be in lol, been there before. And I'm still being factual in my responses?

Call it gaslighting if you want but when hit with facts and reason people tend to feel offended

you’re missing the whole point. and at this stage there is no way you’re a psychoanalyst because if you were you would know that the basis of morality has footholds in both relativity and universalism depending on a myriad of factors. even if you were to argue that the do no harm portion of it is strong, to imply that it’s higher than situation based moral implications is strongly biased and not factual in the slightest. furthermore, to desgods point, i fear that you not seeing your words, the ones i quoted from you, were not rude is… a problem in and of itself.

Well I did say to ignore your moral judgment is ignorant but I also said it wasn't bad, if you go back to my reply it's says there. I say it wasn't bad because everyone has an experience that shapes them to be what they are. It's true that by ignoring your morality you decend further down which is why I'm pressing the issue that morality is important in these situations. No one can say "if the circumstances were this way..." you need to have a moral judgment when the apocalypse comes, it keeps your humanity which is extremely important on a universal scale affecting not only you but your decisions, actions, and peers. Your outlook, I wasn't dissing you in the beginning, I was simply telling you that despite all avenues, there are better ways of handling such situations.

Sorry I can’t debate you if you don’t know the meaning of ‘mentally challenged’, ‘imply’, and the difference between facts and opinions.
Lastly, the basic fact the morality is highly subjective and nuanced.

Enforcing such brutality will instead cause distrust, fear, and rash unpredictable decision making

I'm not gonna try and reason with you if you're just gonna take my words out of context and not look deeper into what I'm trying to say. So agree to disagree

“it’s true that ignoring your morality you descend further down”. no it’s not. all those words are completely subjective. you would first have to define each persons morality and what that means to them, and you would also need to define what “further down” means by their OWN perception, not yours. on top of that would need to define the actions of ignoring. again. none of this is factual in the slightest. you’re taking your own world view and assuming it as the basis of everyone else’s. this is how i know you’re not a psychoanalyst, because they literally teach this in psych 101 and as a “psychoanalyst”… that’s your whole job??? “better ways of handling it” again subjective. i told you through all the comments that you can believe what you believe and so can i point blank. even the concept on what humanity is, extremely nuanced. the whole concept on morality that again, basic psych, it can change. so yeah, i’m done commenting because on top of failing to see your rude comments, you are legitimately exercising bad faith bias from the jump. something a real psychoanalyst would never do.

After reading my responses I can conclude I wasn't being as rude as you guys thought. As a reader I was sharing my opinion while expressing said opinion lol, crazy how quick it went quiet tho ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Okay, legit question.
Are you ESL(English second language)? Because you’re literally using MANY words you obviously don’t know the meaning of.
I’m not trying to insult you.
I’m genuinely trying to help you for the future. You’re misusing and misunderstanding a lot of the terms/concepts you’re using.

Please clarify, I may be enlightening (づ￣ ³￣)づ

You don't even know what a psychoanalyst does this is what I got after reading your response. But nevermind, I'm just gonna let you believe what you will. I've already got the gist of your character. Regardless of how you thought of my responses I still wish you a great day tho. I wasn't as rude looking back at my own responses, seems more like you guys were the aggressors or smth but yeah.

I….don’t know how much clearer I can be with my question.

If interested, just list everything that concerns you about my previous statements. I'm in court a lot for disclosed reasons (not me, just people doing evil things) so my language is a bit professional now lol, that were getting into the mind as I like to say. But please list out everything I've said that you believe to be wrong or misused. Also keep in mind that when I was replying previously I was literally reading the comic, so my responses are literally just how a person reading a book would respond, filterless and in discussion mode. I was replying because the main account was replying back, simple as that, but please list out all the thing I got wrong if you're invested, I'll do my best to clarify

…I guess the avoidance of the question is an answer in and of itself. I was genuinely trying to help you but whatever. I really don’t care enough to put anymore brain energy into this.
Pro tip, you shouldn’t let pride or…whatever it is you have going on stop you from growing as a person or gaining knowledge.
Good luck with your ‘professional language’ and ‘psychoanalysis’ of people doing ‘evil things’ in ‘court’.

Alright cool, and no I don't let pride go into anything when it comes to psychoanalysis. From the earlier responses I was responding how someone reading a book on their break time would respond. I didn't curse at anyone nor deflect anything, but for some reason people seem to take a heated angle when debating certain topics. I was having a discussion and without much in return you guys immediately felt offended without giving my statements much thought to the matter. I could go on and on about how the human psyche works ( its something I love) but I don't because this is a fictional story and only people interested would really spare the time to discuss such cool topics. Have a great day or night then, and maybe don't take things so seriously when it comes to someone reading a BL?

I also didn't deflect your question, I answered for you to further clarify what I said because you kept saying how I was missing my terms and even thought I had a language barrier, I would take that as an offense

I can only hope the ones that said they won't touch it again actually stick to their convictions so that the rest of us can enjoy. The story told us exactly what it is from the jump so if they're still here and they don't like it (but let's be honest, they actually do like it if they're still here), that's on them lol

it's YJH

Mc’s companion, Yoo Joonghyuk, the guy we see at the end. He got his sex changed, that’s why we saw the cosllatsion that likes to change sex

thank you T.T