
Hmmmm while i love the story it always bothers me when in these kind of stories the FL almost always expects her child to be the same one that she had in her past life, i mean that child was born between her and the former husband, so if the father is different wouldn't it make sense that the child would be different as well, well i guess in this case one of the humunculli may be Luca but we'll see about that, but i have to wonder if a random FL gave birth to a child and it's not the same one she had would she be dissapointed that it's not the same child, would she still love that child or would she still be stuck in the past searching for her first child and possibly neglect her current one, i think a manhwa with a plot like that would be kinda interesting, well i can't wait to see how this story will unfold ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

you should read:
https://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/my_dear_aster/
it's about a mom who wants her daughter back...

I 100% understand and agree it always rubbed me the wrong way in stories like these. There's actually a manhwa similar to what you described but it was a little different. If I remember correctly both the ml and fl got sent back in time and fixed there relationship. They had one child and loved them, but when they had their second child it turned out the be the reincarnation/same child from their precious life. And they even said they love their family but it felt a little special having their first child back and it ends with the three of them hugging. It just left a bad taste in my mouth, but I wish I remember the named of the manhwa.

I really have to wonder how their reproduction works, like if one partner had an aquarium for a head and the other a candle what would their child look like, would there be complicatons with the child cause they have opposite elements, or maybe they are searching for a partner that has similar traits to their own to avoid that, and we know that the mummy guy is half human but it makes you wonder how many of half humans exsist in their world, and if a half human has a child with another human would their child be fully human, or keep some of the aberrant head traits ?╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

I have to wonder if purity is so important to them why are they allowing the saintesses to marry, i kmow it's probably done to elevate someones status, but you know the most important thing is producing an heir, so how are they gonna do that of they don't do the deed, do they have a concubine to concive the child with, bit at the same time how stable would the child position be cause there would deffinetly be people who complain that a child from a concubine is a possible heir to the throne, so that part dpesn't make much sense ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

So they are saying that the FL and her brother look alike, but she can't be the duke's daughter cause she doesn't have silver hair, by that logic the brother also isn't his child cause he as well doesn't have silver hair (i know that the members of the family can contract spirits, but if he wasn't capable of doing it would they be saying the same thing to him), and am i the only one remembering things wrong but didn't she have contact with an ice spirit when she was in the cave what happened with that ?

In the cave they did talk abt the ice elemental but she was never chosen, but i think they were implying that she will be chosen by the ice elemental. In my review of this manhwa i actually pointed out how i was annoyed they never revisited that plotline so i’m glad they’re finally coming back to it

Nope, she never contracted the ice spirit, the only entity she's ever contacted so far is the librarian blonde goddess of Fate. Even though it was somewhat foreshadowed that she might get chosen by the ice spirit, it hasn't happened yet: she didn't make a contact with any spirit at that cave, at all... Moreover, the ice spirit still has the "reputation" of having been an ancient evil and human-hating, female spirit, whose present-day whereabouts are still unknown (because she was allegedly sealed long ago, to keep her from trying to harm humans). So I suppose they'd need to clean that spirit's "reputation" first of all, if that's goingto happen. I remember that very well because I too was waiting for something like that to happen, but sadly it didn't. (Maybe the ice spirit isn't in the cave, to begin with?)
As for the pink hair debate, I thought the same about the bro: stupid people thinking they know everything about genetics. Talk about starting some idiotic hoax and forcing busy people to give it attention... Next time, they'll force everyone to hold a meeting because someone said the FL was part amphibian (cue sarcasm).

I have to wonder do the brothers know the reason why their parents divorced, cause they mostly blame the FL for it, maybe the parents didn't wanna tell them to avoid conflict between ether parent, or maybe they knew the reason but still blame FL for helping their mom to divorce?

I believe no one knows? From what I understood of the spoilers others have given, the only one who kinda knew but is just as much in the dark was the blond hair brother. The black hair brother believes that she did it to destroy their family. It wasn't until the mother slapped him and told him from her mouth did he FINALLY believe that their father was the root cause of their family breaking apart. As for the youngest, his head is in cloud 9 and has no idea what's going.
Wait is this the end ? Σ(  ̄□ ̄||)
Nope, tbc
Sadly, they're right! Chapter 16 is the last chapter and this is the last volume. The Manga was discontinued :(
Awww man that's such i shame ╥﹏╥