rai's Topics (87)

What was the first 2 wishes? I only understood that for the last one he ask for the song.. The other two i dont get.. Is naming the two boy that change identity is part of the wish?

I'm not 100% sure but I'm guessing it meant something along the lines of spoil me, or coddle me... something like that anyway.

i didn't really understand why he wanted to know their names, but i guess he wanted her to name their military unit, which is where "The Shade" came in

I think he ask the knight past name, before he named them

the first wish was him asking her to forgive him if he does something rude in the future

Must be the reason why he blushed when she agreed. But for me, that first wish still vague (≧▽≦)

First wish, he asked her to indulge him (I don't really get it but the reply above says "indulge= to spoil him")
Second wish, he wants her to name his group of knights, now that he is the crown prince. She gave it the name "The Shade". And no, naming the 2 knights is not part of the wish.

Ohhhh. Thanks! I'm hoping he's thinking of kissing her as the "something rude" (≧▽≦)

Thank you everyone


ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~

I think the dad doesn't know how to express himself in front of his daughter

I know, but why be interested in her now? Where was he when she was lonely before? Like not even showing up during her birthdays and stuff

I think hes ignoring her on purpose so that the emperor doesn’t target her to get to him

I don't remember very well but there was a reason for him not attending her debutante. I think the emperor called him to protect him and he couldn't refuse it?

well we don't know what happened before she arrived but im guessing the world she's living in is different from the book she read? (〜￣△￣)〜

It seems to be his weird way of protecting her since the Emperor uses her as his weakness to keep him in place. He's apparently always loved and cared about her, but just has a hard time showing it towards her in person. Some men are strange ┑(￣Д ￣)┍

The thing is in her previous life she must’ve over thought the weapon her father gave have her, and why Maximillian was there.

The way I see it even in the past the father cared for her but couldn’t show it because of the current emperor, this is just a theory but I believe that what Maximmilian said in the Shadow Prison to the guard was just a lie and excuse to enter and protect Jubelian in order to not cause any suspicion from the emperor’s side.

It’s a theory but maybe after her death, as you can see, they do have the plan to overthrow the current scum emperor, but because of the fathers weakness (Jubellian) they waited for the right time and chance for her to not be held as blackmail by the emperor.

And her death was the breaking point of all these he had nothing to loose, so I think after that part in the previous life we’ll see a desperate, loss, and broken father finally overthrowing the emperor but loss what he loved most, and that was his daughter.


I can’t really explain everything going through my head, but in the last life it’s not that the father didn’t care for his daughter, it was just that he was holding back because of that damned emperor.

As you can see from the recent chapter, he’s had enough and I think he’s finally planning to just let it go and not care about showing his weakness (Jubellian) and decided to openly show his affection and doesn’t give a damn about the emperors warnings and blackmailing.

Let’s not go on another hate bandwagon lmao, and the weapon from the last life (the one her father gave her before she entered the shadow prison) it must’ve either be a hidden messag for the crown prince to know it has his daughter or as a form of safety mechanism.

But the previous jubellian misunderstood it as her father giving up on her, and it was an indirect way for her to kill herself.

And the thing the past Maximmilian said to the guard, he probably did not mean that and instead it was a way to not cause suspicion on his true goal (which was probably to protect jubellian as his teacher’s daughter) (also the father may have asked Maximillian to do that) and you can see when Jubellian killed herself the prince was shocked and tried to stop her. (She misunderstood everything he said because she believed that nobody cared for her in these world, and shocked by the fact that even her father has lost faith in her, she probably did not have the right mind to think properly on the situation)

Everything I’ve said is just a theory I haven’t read the novels or the raws, but I think I’m kinda right in the most part since it’s a common plot-twist in reincarnation historical novels.

In short, it’s just one big cluster-fuck of misunderstandings

It was honestly stupid on both Max and the father's parts. Even if the father was unaware that she'd misunderstand, having "the princess's brother" go in to "torture" her when she doesn't even know he's her father's disciple? No SHIT she's gonna kill herself to avoid torture. Like, both of them are 100% aware of Max's reputation, but they think it's a good idea to give her a knife and have him talk about how he's gonna kill her while she's ten feet away? They didn't think this through well lmao.

This is the best explanation I've read and I agree with you. (〜￣△￣)〜

I kind of get it now, I think. Thank you everyone for your insights!

EXACTLY, the lack of communication is killing me. Like why cant he carve something on the knife like “You’ll be safe” or something or put a small note just so that she knows the reason why he’s giving her that knife. The message he’s trying to give is too ambiguous and I totally understand why the mc did that..I totally agree with flamingcunt10’s theory and I just think that it’s so freaking sad if you think about it.......FUCK I’M ALL DEPRESSED NOW AHHAHA

My dad loves me more than anything, and if he gave me a knife in that situation, I'd probably interpret it as, "I love you, but all I can do is give you this so you don't have to suffer through torture."

EXACTLYYYY HAHAHAHA

Dw prince is very good ヾ(☆▽☆)

Is he tho?? It’s very sus..

Same for me! I DO get lots of notifications about fake updates though! ╮(￣▽￣)╭