
I feel somehow relieved that Athy is sort of a simpleton cuz if I were her, I would've felt depressed being treated that way by someone whom I love..

Well I guessed it could be that originally she doesn't think that she is the real athy ? Like she think she just transfer into the novel so in a way it's like she know how originally claude treated previous athy.Thus, she is more accustom to it?. But at least things seems to be more smooth sailing now... ╥﹏╥

Imo, even tho she is aware that she's not the "real athy", as someone who has spent most of her life time in that world since she was an infant, it's only normal for her to grow some feelings toward claude who is her father. Especially if that father figure was previously very unapproachable to her that she had to put lots of efforts to build a good relationship which thankfully bore some fruits. I mean, though it took some time, claude really acted and treated his daughter athy as if she were the most pecious jewel in the world. So, how could athy not grow attached to him?

I think I didn't make myself clear, that's my bad. But what I intended to convey was that since from the start she she knew how athy was treated in the novel, it at least made her know that claude can act like this. So it's not so sudden that claude started treating her like trash, I am not saying that the whole situation was not sudden but at least it did I guessed in a sense help her prepare better. As let's say that had she not know the novel's plot and their relationship continues in this path and one day this happened, it would have definitely struck her worse than now. Obviously I am not saying she is not that affected at all nor I am denying the fact that she grown attached to claude but simply giving my opinion that this could have been a factor to help her remain strong rather than just being a simpleton as she is more emotionally prepared. I mean ya know what I'm trying to say?

Could you all hold your horses before getting hateful at Yoonseol? It's just, why do I feel like Yoonseol is being a jerk on purpose? I have a feeling he's doing it intentionally to rile up our ML's emotion so that he can be more honest with his emotions and finally be free from the chain of thought that he has to always be perfect. I mean, even Yoonseol said it himself, right? That he would get anything that he wanted if he really wanted it. In my opinion, if Yoonseol really wanted to take our MC from our ML, he would've done so forcibly when he was seducing him earlier, but he did not. Instead, he let him go quite easily and just wondered by himself about how interesting it was for him to see our ML acting possessive about something (or rather someone in this case) for (maybe) ths first time. Also, looking back at Yoonseol's past self through our ML's flashback so far, it doesn't seem like Yoonseol ever really did something so blunt to hurt our ML because he hates him. Well, maybe he hates our ML for being a goody two shoes, but you know what I mean, right? He just doesn't really seem like that pure evil antagonist character who hates the protagonist.
However, I also admit there's also a possibility that I might be too positive, completely wrong, and that Yoonseol might be a bad guy for real, but it just hasn't been showed very clearly due to the plot development that's still on its early stage. In short, I think we should hold our horses for now and see how things go on and what kind of a person that Yoonseol guy is.

I came here from this sensei's other story which also has a random disturbing story on its ch5... Is it like this sensei's hobby? Or maybe sensei's style? Slipping in a random story that has completely different vibes from the main one is so not okay. Even if the sensei really had to add another story, it could've been something that's around the same or similar genre, I think >:(

WHY THE FUCK WOULD YOU LUMP CHAPTER 5 TOGETHER IN THIS BEUTIFUL STORY?!?!!! Istg I would've given this a 9 or more rating if there were no ch5 T_T I mean, if you really had to slip in another story, you could've just added something around similar genre, you know? So why ch5... It's such a shame T_T
People are talking about the extras and I'm here like "WHERE ARE THE EXTRAS?!?!!!"
You can find the extras here ( https://exiledrebelsscanlations.com/nomi-x-shiba/) but you have to create an account first to view the chapters.