Chumi's Topics (375)

My eyes hurt now (⊙.⊙)

I loved this story so much and the characters and the not creepy and lack of cliché ! but yeah my poor eyes hurt coz of quality well it's still great to be able to read it but I hope someone will update with better quality scan?

yeah i hope so too !

But there's something about his story that makes it okay~ Maybe it's the leopard print fundoshi and cavalier attitude :P

I agree it was very beautiful indeed same just when you think that the main pair won't end up together , they do I very much injoyed reading this I wish it continued but sadly it's over :(

yeah very sadly, & so true i love when the story has darkness and a bit of sadness but it still ends happily <3

yes I was very pleased with that sooo very happy i was sooo very over joyed I felt like as if i was there & they were my best friends & i was trying so hard to get them together ( i know sounds wired . Right ? As i have being in this postion heaps of times ;/ :/ ) im glad that they keept there promise they both walked out of the gate togther even thow he walked out frist he still came back for him & then walked out together it was just the best & then them living togther & then them practicing a wedding ceremony omg that really throw me i was like ヾ(☆▽☆) if only a prist was there do do it then they would be really getting married then they mad Love like omg hot !!! like gezz in a wedding gown omg can it get any better then that i just wanted more & more it was like a drug for me i was so very addied to it so very fascinated & touched with the hole lot ;P :P ;)

yayy so happy you liked it as much as i did >.<

SAME and I'm pretty open minded so I tried but all I could think was "but that's your nephew/uncle tho"

same here

I liked the story and all... but I agree, the story would b much better if they were at least not blood related.... ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Then why did you read it when you have a clear summary? Are you an M? ._.

they're are a lot of yaoi mangas that say incest but they mean that the someone is adopted or not actually related to the other person . ^_^ thanx for the thought

You do realize that they are NOT ACTUALLY related... they are FICTIONAL CHARACTERS!!
Until modern medical science and genetics determined that certain birth defects were caused by close blood relations siring offspring, "incest" was considered necessary to ensure that a family's bloodline remained pure (some cultures still do, to this day). Therefore, until two males (or females) can copulate and produce offspring, sex between blood related males (or females) is a moot point to use to argue against incest. Since, in this case, it is a "societal" prejudice that shuns incest, how is it that homosexuality is okay - since it is also a societal prejudice? Do we pick and choose our prejudices like they are dinner at a Chinese restaurant - a little from column A and a little from column B? Or maybe it's easier to tolerate things that are considered "cool" to some.
I, truly, have nothing against YOUR opinion. I do, however, have issue with a society's baseless prejudice and scorn.
I beg your pardon if I have offended.

:| That's relatives at the 3rd degree. LOL

It was nowhere implied that he was adopted.

well that's the thing, it's not usually implied.

is it cool then if you have sex with your brothersister?
& is it okay like in this story if you sleep with your uncle ?!!!

If one has sex with a close (sibling, parent, blood aunt/uncle, first cousin) blood relative of the OPPOSITE sex, where there is a risk of producing a child that will live their lives suffering from birth defects (minor or major), would be considered very irresponsible and uncaring for the welfare of the child. However, right or wrong; cool or uncool; is not for me or anyone to judge. If no children can be born, and thus affected/harmed by the relationship, no one has ANY right to tell another person who they can and cannot love or have sex with. Even the laws in the US regarding incest will only be pursued if the parent or guardian of a minor (under the age of consent**) files a complaint, or if an adult victim files a complaint. Cases with empirical evidence even find prosecuting incest difficult, unless one party (or the parent/guardian) claims to be a "victim". There is also a "statute of limitations", or time limit, of 5 years after the FIRST time incest occurs, to file charges. So, basically, the government (law) won't get involved in citizens' sex lives unless a crime is committed.
**The "age of consent" varies widely by state, from as young as 12, to as old as 16.**

So, in answer to your question... UNLESS the relationship with a blood relative will cause PHYSICAL HARM to an innocent person, only the people IN THE RELATIONSHIP have a right to determine if it is right or wrong, cool or uncool.

Please note that, except for the statements regarding US laws, this is entirely and solely MY PERSONAL OPINION ... and opinions are like assholes - everybody has one and they all stink. LOL (⌒▽⌒)

Because he isn't adopted. I don't see your issue with this ._.

exactly everyone has his own opinion for me i can never tolerate incest in real life, since this is a fictional story i proceeded reading it but if we're talking about real life then for me i can't understand how brother/sisters... can be attracted to each other, i won't judge if i see a couple just like i won't judge if i see gay couples but i'm saying that for me it's totally unacceptable, i also care about it religiously if god said no then it's a no for ME.

just drop it already, i didn't love it & that's my opinion, life goes on.

I respect your opinion even if we don't share the same views. I appreciate that we had this wonderful opportunity to share and discuss our ideas... I hope that we can do it again sometime. Thank you for an interesting debate. I had fun. I hope you did too.

Great, then leave instead of stating the obvious as through you DIDN'T read it :)

wow..i'm totally done with you 7th grader .

actually thank you for the lovely way of speaking, most people like to force their opinions on others and it's very rare to come across people like you,even though we have completely different views i'm glad we didn't kill each other over it & it's always fun talking to educated people like you, i hope we get to do it again too ^^

I believe that people's opinions are based on their experiences, the more they experience the more their opinions evolve. A good experience will create a positive opinion, in contrast a bad experience creates a negative opinion. If we were to "fight" or "kill" each other over our ideas, it would cause us both to have a negative opinion of each other and our ideas. I'd much rather hear what you have to say, because it may help my opinions to evolve.
Anytime you'd like to debate or even just talk, I would enjoy listening to what you have to say.

I'm a 7th grader for pointing out your stupidity of reading a manga of something you clearly don't like? Snobbish much? O.o

you're absolutely right, same goes for you
you're more than welcome to talk with me about anything.

i already clarified that i did not know they were related & i guess even if i knew i would've tried reading it anyway to know how i feel about this kind of genre since it is my first time reading a story of blood related couple, now who's stupid for not comprehending anything i said so far !

Well, I guess incest sort of makes sense to me. I mean, you're with your brother/sister for most of your life and if you're very close to them, you can see them as one of you best friends. And if the friendship develops into something more, is that so wrong? And an uncle is only half related to you technically. And they're not going to have kids, so I think it would be fine. This is all my personal opinion though, just sayin'