katevv's Topics (454)

the author better give us something to hate her TTTT

The thing is, that the other girl (my interpretation by looking at the raws), might not be Atanasia sister, rather her cousin.


[spoiler]


Because the other girl's mother was sleeping with the Emperor's older brother, so she has royal blood (thus those blue excentric eyes) but she is not the daughter of the current Emperor.

Even more, it seems that the Emperor's older brother is alive, but has different hair color, he appeared on chapter 40/41 in the raws.


By looking at it, it seems that the guy with grey hair has some hidden plans, cause it seems too strange for him to assume that the other girl was the current Emperor's daughter, and marry her to his son, even though her mother was with someone else from the royal family.

And his reactions around Atanasia, especially when they are in the royal ball to introduce her to society, are strange, it seems that he could not understand the Emperor's actions towards Atanasia.


Well, maybe its a different story, that so far, it seemed to fit with what I've seen.
And I don't hate the other girl. I think that the adults in this world are to blame.

The current Emperor that killed so many people, that past one that maybe did something for his younger brother to react the way he did, the grey hair boy's father, except Atanasia's mother, she deserved better. Overall, the kids are the only ones innocent.



Gomen for intruding ⁄(⁄ ⁄·⁄ω⁄·⁄ ⁄)⁄

Holy moly i think you're right! ^^

Thanks. ⁄(⁄ ⁄·⁄ω⁄·⁄ ⁄)⁄

But thinking now, I was wondering if the black-haired man (older brother) that was talking with that grey-haired guy know about the other girl not being the current Emperor's daughter. Σ(っ°Д °;)っ

And what if they both banded together to make Claude kill his own daughter, knowing his personality, and accepting the other girl. Because if you remember, in the book, someone tried to poison the "fake daughter", and they pinned the blame onto Atanasia, resulting in her execution. (╯°Д °)╯╧╧

But if that's the case, what was the purpose?


I have sooooo many questions. I'm looking forward to understanding the story. And late happy new year!!

Really! Tell me it was all acting..spoil a little plz

It’s all an act don’t worry and as usual they will get back to them

Tg!! i wasn't completely convinced that it was all an act.

I hope we can see them too im anxious...

I have a theory that both he tian and Jian Yi has the same father but different mothers

they're definitely not related though. someone wrote this a bit ago which helps to understand. http://www.mangago.zone/home/mangatopic/3620952/

I think both he tian and Jian yi has same father but different mothers because in chapter 105 the father appeared in that dream after he tian appears in the series and 136 they were the same guy... Somehow the father does look like he tian and he Cheng.. and sometime jiang Yu has expressions like that of he tian when he is being evil or something like in chapter 100.. so there might be a little possibility that jiang yi is the half brother of he tian and he Cheng and that the both brothers know about this.
I mean this is just a theory I made up in my mind while I was reading it, and I'm still curious about how the story would turn out when their fathers are going to be revealed.
After reading the link it made me more curious about the father thing and that they are not half brothers would be true, I was also thinking of that possibility as well, it was just 50-50 percent possibility of anything ( being half brothers or not ), we just have to wait and watch how the story is going to unfold and all.

Interesting theory.. I agree that it could be that they’re really brothers or related even i mean they could just have taken their mother’s last name that’s why they have different last names who knows, but base on the latest chaps my guess is He tian father work to Jian Yi’s father he could be his right man or something until he passed the position to He Tian’s brother, and the reason that Jian Yi’s father left him is because his dad made a promised to his mom that he wouldn’t involved their son to their business but since Jian Yi’s had been kidnapped they have no choice now.

okay but the father appearing in a dream after he tian appears in the story literally doesn't have anything to do with him and there is no valid connection between that. its not like jian yi had a dream/flashback with he tian and his father both in it to connect them somehow. those are two separate things and he tian appearing in a chapter beforehand in a chapter before has no connection to it. plus its not like it was he tian's first appearance.

also the father has light silver/grey hair and we have yet to have seen his face. he cheng and he tian have black hair so I don't see any resemblance between jian yi's father and their looks. and having similar facial expressions expressing emotions doesn't prove anything either, that would be like me saying 'he tian grinned here but so did xi so they must be related, it was similar expressions'. so far these mostly just seem to be reaches. I'm not trying to bash you by the way, I hope it doesn't come across this way lol -- I feel the need to clarify because sometimes I feel like tones can get lost on the internet. I'm just discussing and explaining to you why this theory is 99% unlikely.

not to mention the many other reasons listed in the other linked post. I'm curious to see how the fathers would be revealed too ... we probably won't see jian yi's father until he gets kidnapped and its hard to know when we might seen he tian's dad. or actually any of the fathers.. as in fully revealed. old xian seems to love not showing the fathers either at all like zhan zheng xi's and he tian's, or just their faces like jian yi's and mo's. like you said, its a waiting game when it comes to this story.

I think your theory, the theory that jian yi's father and he tian's father have their own separate mafia groups [as they both seem to be bosses] that have a certain respect towards one another, which leads to he tian's father loaning he cheng to jian yi's father as a underling/righthand man years later the most likely theory. i don't think they necessarily work together on plans and shizz but the groups certainly know of each other and have a connection through he cheng which leads me to believe that they at least respect one another in a business like way. it makes the most sense out of everything tbh. cause it's clear he cheng used to work for their own father as seen from he tian's flashbacks from when he was young.

Im wondering if He Tian and his brother have different mothers too..

Its going to be a long wait for us (⊙…⊙ )

Ikr? Like know how there are mean bitch villains and there are also "kind" sugar tongued villains? Like what if Beatrice suddenly pops up in the end and fucks everything up in the end cuz she's "kind". Honestly I wanna see that.

True.. I’m kinda on the edge of my sit since this will make the story more complicated like the fact that in the original story Noah fell in love with Beatrice and now i guess it’s safe to say that he will also fall in love Realiana i wonder which side will he choose when the time comes cuz I’m pretty sure he will get confused and such however I’m rooting for him tho he seem like a smart guy so i hope he will make a good choice and not like some other dumb cliche protagonists.

Agreed

Lol or shes become the main girl amd that other girl is now the side person.

I thought there was no lead girl?

There is as far as I remember she said that in the story of the book the friend of the main lead died bec of her fiancée and she was that friend so the main lead starts to investigate and stuff

That's what I remember too, but I don't think there was any hint that the main lead was female. I assumed it may be some detective dude.