Hyouka Yui's Topics (184)

So youre saying that ml has a memory from past too?

I really want to know too

From spoiler thread yeah he remember everything that’s why he always change in this life like let the FL touch they child while in past life he didn’t even present in ducal house because he have a duty at other place in past life and you know he wear matches colour clothe as her and say it coincidence and also say to her in ball at chapter 19 “I will not force you to do anything “..

Ohhh that sounds cute. Finally another time travel where both ml and fl remembers. Does that mean that ml can prevent the ass father to intervene with them?

Unfortunately no the ML still a person easily manipulate even if he came back from the past(⊙…⊙ )that’s why I said this ML is pretty coward than any other ML but you know everything faults here they say at threads is father in law but to get manipulated by that man for two life is (〜￣△￣)〜 only FL do change in this life the ML is no

Ughh thats just... stupid ml

WHATTTT WILL THE BABY COME BACk. Technically it’s near to impossible unless u know the exact order but :(

So THAT baby is GONE!????? Noooooo he’s not coming back i know about the biological way of making a baby but.. but.. in a story i want the original son to be born againnnnnnnnnnnnn huwaaaaaa ╥﹏╥

Well at the ending of novel the author only mention about the birth of a princess after that second birth is a prince there is no other clarifying that Prince Ian reincarnated again...

Well I disappointed to see CP as ML because it’s same as Abandoned Empress situation

Ah... abandoned empress ml all over again...
out of so many ml in there, the author choose the prince..
I guess it’s the same here too... :’)
Thank you for the spoiler btw ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~ I was raging too much I forgot to thanked you XD

But the difference is that this CP is actually much okay than the CP in the Abandoned Empress.
.
Whereas at the Abandoned Empress, the ML is actually a real piece of sh*t, the CP here was actually love FL even in first life. Although I do say the glare is a bit over the top. After FL died, ML raised Ian and always told him about FL (how kind and beautiful was his mother).

Doesn't the crown prince love cecilla?

apparently not I think

Well these both ML a coward and easy to get manipulated if FL not get reincarnated the ML will be the same character who is coward and tyrant and also you know man who can’t even protect what he love is just useless manヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~We know these are fantasy’s story but they situation really not make sense

Well he only use cecilia to control the palace but unfortunately she died because of Duke and ML love FL after the first empress died and you know he accuse FL till she died

I think he was acting according to some other ppl's spoilers and that he did that because he thought FL would be protected but it backfired I think? anyways if your upset with these plots you can just drop it ╮(￣▽￣)╭

I seriously hoped that the prince wasn’t the ML

All authors for romance fantasy remind me that they are more cruel than Isayama... kno I prefer shrunken or story like Solo Leveling more.. this plot and concept like soap cheap opera not make sense anymore

I mean I get that she liked the crown prince and all that but he always neglected you in your past life. What is the reason to make them fall in love and drive the whole concept of this story -that is taking revenge astray.

I don’t know all this plot will include about less miscommunication, misunderstanding, manipulation, poison, FL became a saint to help his husband that kill her in past life

Yeah just like The abandoned empress :(

Are they going to end up together?

Yup they end up together because MC got pregnant after have one night stand with Lucius because at that time MC kinda Broken heart after her fiancée betray her and Lucius will have one daughter from other concubine while one son from MC

i dont think you understand the hardships that goes along with being popular. just revealing that information alone could've ruined the fl's career ┑(￣Д ￣)┍

The MC more popular than her and also her popularity begin because he help FL when in trouble you know like Damsell in Distress but after got more popularity from public she want to break up situations but also when MC almost die at the tunnel she goes and saying to media again yes he my boyfriend （￣へ￣）

bro even with the difference in popularity, the fl just started her career and when you get into a relationship with someone, it could damage the fl's fanbase. That's how industries usually work, just having dating rumors really could end her career but the fl chose to reveal her relationship with ml because she cared about ml more than her reputation. Well it doesn't really matter anymore because it looks like fl's career wasn't ruined at the new chapter, instead it actually helped. ╮(￣▽￣)╭

i mean you can think whatever you want, just try to understand the fl's side too

I think I understand what this comment wanted to point up.. The FL seems to get the easiest way-out everytime. She became an actress by ML's help yet decided to dump him hurriedly because of popularity.
She was supposed to feel bad about it, the breaking up things.. Yet after a long long chapters without her, when the ML suddenly hurt in that accident while still saving others, without batting an eyelid she choose to proclaim their relationship like he was always the most important in her life..
From outsider's pov, she would look like a gold digger or popularity digger.

It's not a bad thing. I think the author-nim just unconsciously takes this problem too lightly..
It was like: "okay so let's create a make-up scene by making the ML dying and the FL'd be so worried and ended to choose him over her popularity.."
I understand this hype. After all it was a cliche troupe. It's just I also can't lie about it being too rushed and reckless imho..

Wow you understand me I like you even more(≧∀≦)

I also don't like this kind of Novels but we should appriciate the artists so giving one star would be disrespectful

Hold up, Abandoned empress the dude was poisoned to act like that. It was stated so many times! like chill for a second that wasn't his actual personality. Second she stoppped poeple from spreading lies and warping the young prince early on about her. BECAUSE everyone constantly compared him to her. like the poeple did thst intentialy and she stopped that. PRince dude is a good normal character. yall need to read better. Peace

yo yo the 2nd ML in abandonad empress is wayyy worse I assure you, plus I heard the ML in this story makes up for it

I still think he’s a piece of shit

hence why carsein should have been the one （￣へ￣）

yea my heart broke :(

only man w no baggage, at least not w her. but sadly, guys w no baggage are never male leads (￣∇￣")

so the empress remembers the past too?

wow i hope the romance aint as crappy as abandoned empress at least.
anyway I get what you are saying but I think that Ruve is a different person in the new timeline, but hes disgusting to me even in the new one as he is a coward, selfish and their relationship is toxic as their is no Communication between the two leads and THATS what caused the hell of her past life. Their relationship was based on her still being obsessed with him to call a few nice things hes done being "showered with love".
On this new manwa, mc still remembers her life and thinks of it as any normal person would (even draws a picture of her child), to the point she wants revenge. I really doubt sweet, sugar coated words is gonna make her fine with being with the prince again. Have you even finished this story to say the ship is gonna be as trash as it is in the abandoned empress. I really hope the prince has character growth with mc where theres an actual bond and no forced kissing or romance.
AGAIN i do agree with you, but abandoned empress was in a lead of its own when it comes to trash couples, this manwa is very aware of the pain mc went through

Nahh because of this spoiler. Imma drop this

yeah me too

They didn't explain it well and was very biased when writing it. In the spoiler I read


















The Crown Prince loved and knew that she wasn't the real duke daughter and because someone was targeting him, he tried to distance himself (Common troupe but there might be more to this than just distance to protect. I don't know the exact details. But this isn't the reason why I like this story. The next part is).

When he found out that his love died, he took care of Ian and raised him up and told him stories about his real mother.

I personally think it's sweet that the Crown Prince and Ian bonded unlike in abandoned empress where the kid was killed and all the ML had going for him was that he didn't have control over himself.

And I think this author knows what they are doing (based on the real feelings of grief for a lost child, and creating mildly realistic situations) so I don't think they will ruin the story like in AE.

Personally, when I read the spoiler I didn't think it was anything like AE. This story seems so much more well written and I am looking forward to it

To even compare this to AE.... smh. AE is the worst mistake out of mistakes.

i know, like comparing this to that manwa is kinda weird to me. Ruve is a disgusting in terms of a male led, no good qualities and manipulates/guilt trips mc multiple times as well as force her to kiss him for their first kiss. It felt disgusting how the mc felt like she was still obsessed with him, as he sometimes did something a decent human being would do, and she comments on it like its the most courageous thing to do.
To compare these characters with the ones in abandoned empress feels awful. Especially after at least seeing that this prince actually is starting to care for her health, even if they are just strangers to each other. Ruve just couldnt give a damn about Tias health until she was being physically stabbed, but didnt care when she was having a panic attack in front of him when first meeting or when she had got poisoned.
Anyway your points are very true and cant wait to see a healthy relationship, and i def want to see a father and son scene, cause i mean damn that spoiler hit me hard(▰˘◡˘▰)

Well you know I compare them because both ML suck, Ruve don’t remember past life, coward, and hurt Tia and Jieun both unborn child while this crown prince same as Ruve didn’t even remember past life, know that Ellen is not Veronica in past life but made her life miserable till she got killed by Duke and Real Veronica like what a useless emperor husband you got there(⌒▽⌒) after that Ellen or MC just forgive him because love like what? Same like Ruve right Tia forgive him because she didn’t care her miserable Past life same like Ellen in present life he help that shitty husband to get commoner support rather than novel and even get approved from empress dowager to marry her step son... psst Empress dowager in past life always mistreated MC because ML at that time have empress while MC just a Queen because of Veronica status as Duke child٩(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)۶ yeay happy ending

Empress in this life didn’t remember anything just Ellen act as Veronica became a Queen in the palace remember everything