Is anyone else confused with their popularity? They still haven't debuted yet, right? Even suspending my belief by a lot, it's crazy to think they're already doing so well before their debut? Cause the collab release of "Something" doesn't count as a debut, right? I've never seen an idol story go this way, so I'm sorry if this is actually a common-ish thing irl!!!
And in a more general way, the pacing is kinda weird? There's big gaps in time and the characters just seem too comfortable around the MC already? I'm just nitpicky about how characters develop though, so maybe this is just a me problem.
yeah and the plot feels like a Mary Sue lololol so many idol stories like this, maybe that's why debut or die is my favorite
Yea this does feel very Mary/Gary Sue-like but not in the way I thought??? MC doesn't rlly use his apparent power a lot, but rather it just looks like everything is going his way *way* too easily...like collabing with an apparently popular sunbae while you're still un-debuted is crazy??? And now we get the lore drop of his dad being an ex-famous person? It felt too sudden and amateur-ly included.
fair pointt and suddenly he knows how to compose a song in one day is actually crazy!! they didn't even explain about the whole superpower thingy works
Probably it was the premise of what the detective told him on the 1st chapter.
exactly! if it had even been in the top 100s on the chart, it would have been a bit more believable. but a group that hasn't debuted yet, making it to no.1 - even with it being a collab with an established artist - on the charts feels too much of a stretch to me.
not to mention, being able to learn anything by watching it once is too OP, how are we going to have a meaningful conflict in the story if we know our all powerful and mighty mc can plow through them with his OP cheat ability?
the art is really so freaking good here, i'm so pleased. 5/5 art and waiting on the rest of the chapters to rate the story itself :]
I'm surprised at how normally and politely DID was treated n written here! I'm not part of a system, so mind my words, but I thought this was really cute! I'm sad this just seems to be a oneshot though, I think this cld've easily been a 5 chapter BL volume! I'd like to have gotten to know the other alters, but oh well :(
The story in this one was really a step up from the previous one!! It's especially sweet and heartwarming, and the emotional beats and dialogues are super good!! The characters are very mature and our headstrong protagonist made sure to Talk Things Out ASAP which was so refreshing and nice <3
me and my brothers in commenting when we cry and sob over the flashbacks cause they're SOOOOOO unnecessary like T_T dude....not during important and/or sexy moments !!!!!
THIS MANGA IS LITERALLY SO CUTE AND THE ML IS SUCH A GREEN FLAG AND LEGIT NICE GUY this has easily become a fave BL bc of how....*real* it is with its dialogue. and that could be a turn-off for some! but I find it super endearing and lovely. the characters' thought processes and actions are also SO cute and realistic too. sometimes you don't know things about yrself until things happen!! and that's okay!!
i will say that the lack of flashback indication is annoying But it's something I can look past. 500000/5 rating, this was genuinely so freaking cute and good and warm.
The less-than-9 stars rating is so surprising to me?! This manga ended up Way cuter, funnier, and sexily stupider than I thought it'd be. I thought the sex would be more frequent and wild at first, tbh, since it's 2 creators "practicing" together to get their best out there, but ???? no, this manga is actually So cute and the characters were wonderful. For a second I thought there'd be some homophobia but there is none! It's just a wonderfully cute story of 2 people falling in love! It really is cute and funny, so it's a good read!
totally 5/5 stars