Lotus December 27, 2023 11:09 am

Hmmmm... this is another manhwa I have mixed feelings about. This isn't about which male lead is going to win (not that far into it but its kind of obvious who it is). The characters feel very stereotypical, especially the main character. I know that's the point since theyre in a novel, but it's hard to get attached to them especially if the characters are supposed to be developed beyond the surface level story the main character read. I can see why people like it though. There are two love interests and the family stuff is sweet. I wasnt interested in the cooking but I could see that being a draw for some people. There also just aren't a lot of translated shounen ai transmigration stories so at least this one was.

    Layla December 29, 2023 5:32 am

    100% agreed. And for me this grown man who is the mc acting like a preteen in love is just a major turn off. Didn't even have the guts to pay off the entire debt for his lover
    #-.-)

    Lotus December 29, 2023 7:28 am
    100% agreed. And for me this grown man who is the mc acting like a preteen in love is just a major turn off. Didn't even have the guts to pay off the entire debt for his lover #-.-) Layla

    Yeah, I can definitely see what you mean! It feels like I could find this character in a highschool romance just as well. There's no maturity to him I guess, which is fine if someone likes characters like that ( the sweet nice mc who's indecisive ) but it's not really interesting to read since this type of character is exactly as you see on the surface. Transmigration stories become more fun when you see new sides to seemingly cliche characters. I read anything but I tend to prefer confident and mature mcs in romance (I find them more endearing and theyre less wishy washy).

    Layla December 29, 2023 7:39 am
    Yeah, I can definitely see what you mean! It feels like I could find this character in a highschool romance just as well. There's no maturity to him I guess, which is fine if someone likes characters like that ... Lotus

    Yeah ikr! But you'll see many takers in the comment section. All his wifely activities seem to be popular (⊙…⊙ )

Lotus December 27, 2023 10:23 am

Its always funny to see Sejin and Moondae on the same wavelength even though their exteriors and responses are so different. In terms of the teams, yeah... how much screentime and how far a trainee goes is usually based on which teams they end up on. Can't wait to see Moondae interact more with the others!

Lotus December 1, 2023 6:05 am

Most accurate portrayal of idol fandom culture and survival shows I've ever seen and that's even with the other idol webnovels. This is seen as THE idol webnovel in Korea so it's great that it was finally adapted. The narration, overdramatic reactions, forced storylines, forced product placements, and even the cutesy fanaccounts that assign animals to their selected member and gush over them is all there. The author's been asked if they've worked as part of management but they said they wanted to keep that a mystery as the focus should be on the story. Tbh, they know a lot so I wouldn't be surprised if they were one or if they worked as a fansite or were a super fan. I like that when they promoted the webtoon on twitter, they treated it like a kpop group debuting which was funny and unique. I love all the characters and they all have interesting personalities. I think Moondae stands out in the sense that he's logical and analytical in an industry that usually has more enthisiatic and passionate character types. It was so fun seeing him trying to determine what his image would be in the broadcast. The pacing is really good and you can see Moondae become more invested in his performances on a personal level. The artist did a great job and they were accurate (even w/ the fans fanart being chibis lol). The moment when Ha Iljoon hugged Moondae was so sweet and gave me tons of flashbacks to a lot of earnest and hardworking trainees who were eliminated during their time on a show. I hope they're doing well. This is definitely an amazing manhwa and I can't wait until the rest of the novel is adapted and Moondae bonds with the characters more.

    Dani December 1, 2023 12:38 pm

    What's their Twitter I'd??? I mean the author

    Lotus December 2, 2023 2:42 am
    What's their Twitter I'd??? I mean the author Dani

    The author doesn't have a twitter account, the previews and promotion of the manhwa were tweeted on @/idolinc_
    The webtoon artist is @/SOHEUN_ and the novel illustrator is @/clumsyoranges

Lotus November 30, 2023 4:20 pm

Hmmm.... this is one of those I have kind of mixed feelings about. The concepts interesting but I haven't really gotten attached to any of the characters. It feels a bit slow at times. I think the art is nice and fits the story well. I do think the characters and their personalities are refreshing considering the setting is a fantasy world so I can understand why people like it. Its also nice that it does have stuff outside of the romance. The translations are odd so it really takes me out of the manga sometimes. Maybe I'll check out the novel and it'll be different.

Lotus November 29, 2023 3:57 pm

I liked it, I thought it was cute and funny. There's not a lot of tension, but I don't think there's really supposed to be. I like that the main character is like a grown adult babysitting some of the other students at times. The other professors are interesting and I think their relationship with the mc is funny. I'll definitely continue reading.

    Lotus November 30, 2023 4:24 pm

    Reminds me of iruma kun now that I think of it at times

    Rinsama_ December 1, 2023 4:27 pm

    Same here!!

Lotus November 29, 2023 6:37 am

Hmmmm... it reminds me more of solo leveling than orv. Pure power fantasy with good art. His nickname made cringe the first time actually though and there's no way other people wouldn't have either. I like that the brothers taller than him. That was cute and I like that theres a lot of scenes devoted to their sibling relationship. I thought the 3rd round with them chasing after the representative made like no sense. There's almost no benefits and you could've spent time on monsters instead. Like there was no reason for it to be coveted at all because the next rep would just be chased by other players again. Mc sorted as a nice guy by others was kind of weird because it only took like one sentence from him for that to happen even though he hasn't really helped people all that much. I like that the Mc isn't perpetually stoic too. I'll keep reading probably.

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.