mahoutofu's Topics (106)

Basic? Girl, we must be reading very different types of romance/rofan if so. She's done pretty much a lot for the ml, his family and the herself too. I mean there's only so much she can do And the romance, maybe perhaps because I enjoy reading slow burns I'm actually loving it.

Yeah she's definitely capable!! I meant basic in terms of personality?? She just doesn't really captivate me enough to catch my interest

ugh sorry i meant to dislike

calling perry basic? seeing your list, perry is much more better than your cringe ass fav female mcs

Whaaaat??? if you're calling FLs like Melissa, Deborah, and Florentia cringe then I guess that explains why you're so ride or die for Perry I guess??? You do you bro lol tbh I've already read like 10?? other manwhas/mangas since this comment and I've pretty much forgotten about this manwha lol so I can't argue

as if they' aren't cringe? they're defo cringe, if you already read those stories then might as well keep your eyes open, don't act like melissa isn't cringe most of the time LMFAO melissa is fun, but she does have a lot of over-the-top moments that can feel cringey, especially since she’s dealing with a bunch of immature characters. her whole "badass rebel" vibe is entertaining, but sometimes it's too CRINGE. (p.s. the ending of your fav story with melissa as fmc was hella cringe)

perry on the other hand, is way more composed and strategic. she just handles things with intelligence and grace, which makes her feel more mature. so, calling perry "basic" is kind of ridiculous, considering she brings a level of depth unlike your melissa and the others who's still a bunch of kids.

well, since melissa is alr an adult (but her behavior can sometimes feel immature or over-the-top) it's still fair to call her cringe LMFAO

I guess so?? Lol you didn't mention Firentia or Deborah do you not know who they are? I really recc them if you don't bc they're definitely NOT "a bunch of kids"???? Tbh tho idk where you got the idea that my manwha list is just my favorites those are all just manwhas I've read and rated/written a review about that's about it fam

Btw Melissa is cringe bc it's comedy it's not a story meant to be taken with 100% seriousness obviously lol the tones between this manwha and Melissa's is completely different i don't think it's a good comparison tbh also the ending??? If you mean her ending up with Nine I heavily disagree lol

+ I don't like Melissa bc she's "elegant" or "strategic" or whatever at the end of it, I like a FL based off of how much I enjoy reading about them and their story. Melissa has a lot of charisma imo she's the type of character you can't help but like and enjoy reading about and root for. (Or at least that's how she appeared to me) and it's the same with Deborah, Firentia, and Aria as well I really enjoy watching them grow and thrive

With Perry I said she felt bland to me as in like idc about her story and idc about watching her getting together with the ML lol even the romance just doesn't do it for me tbh but I did enjoy the family hence why I stayed. Not saying that it's bad just not for me. She's "mature" yeah and "graceful" sure but in the end she just didn't appeal to me lol she felt like vanilla as in i still enjoy it and I'll still eat it but it's not an ice cream flavor i would say is my favorite.

ofc i know Deborah, that's why i said they're still a bunch of 'kids' LMFAO you're just proving my point that they're cringe

tf? u already know that melissa is cringe yet u still set her as an example? tf are u on?

so you’re really out here acting like firentia and deborah aren’t just kids when one literally still goes to school? LMAO. and now you're backpedaling, trying to justify melissa’s cringe with “it’s comedy so it’s not meant to be taken seriously” like that somehow excuses how painfully obnoxious she is. just say you prefer loud, over-the-top fls and go.

also, calling perry “vanilla” while hyping up deborah and melissa is wild, af. not every fl needs to be a walking meme or constantly screaming to have presence. perry carries herself with elegance and quiet strength, something your meh charac could never

An example of a good charismatic character?? Yeah?? honestly idk what ur beef is with Melissa she's fine??? if you want an example of a character i like that is more "mature and elegant and composed" or whatever ill give you Navier lol

Bro you just b yapping at this point it's fine if you don't know Firentia and Deborah and Aria lol once again really reccoment their manwhas also idk what your beef is with Melissa I get that she's not for you. Move on fam there's 100 other transmigration/reincarnation/regression manwhas to read at this point tbh I'm sure you'll find someone out there

Deborah isn't a walking meme??? She doesn't scream ??? Lolol

+ I never said Melissa isn't any of those things (loud and meme-ish) once again I know Melissa isn't "poised and elegant and mature" or whatever she's just fun to read and care about lol like THATS IT it was never that deep.

Idc if my "meh character" doesn't "carry themselves with elegance and quiet strength" what does that even mean tho every FL in this genre is some sort of aristocrat lol they all "carry themselves with elegance and quiet strength" in fact it's rare when they DON'T and actually act against the status quo

+ i tried going back and rereading the novel but I can't find anything about Deborah's age fam so tbh you might be right on that front (i thought she was a college student or office worker bc it mentioned her doing architecture??) i stand by firentia and Aria not being children even if they are in a child's body tho

and that was the point of my comment? u keep on going circles denying that they aren't a bunch of kids when the truth is they truly are grammatically f

But like Aria and firentia are in the body of a child but they have an adult mind so their personality is already locked in?? Like they already have goals and a purpose i wouldn't call them kids lol bc imagining them having a crush on a kid like other FLs gives me the creeps. These are technically adult women in my head

then here u are calling perry ‘go girl, give us nothing’ while hyping up your bunch of kids? truly ironic since you prefer cringe fmc over a ‘basic’ FL

bro isn’t even sticking to their own argument. you brought up melissa, and now you’re suddenly talking about navier? you mentioned melissa because I called you out for calling perry ‘basic’, which is funny considering the cringe stories you hype up. so, in comparison, melissa is cringe next to perry. now you’re dragging anothr character into this to prove what exactly? dtick to your topic.

so frentia is an ‘adult woman’ because she regressed… yet she still grows up physically as a child and develops naturally alongside perez? if you’re going to argue she’s an adult, then shouldn’t her romance with perez be problematic to you too? you’re contradicting yourself maem, either she’s a kid growing up again, or you’re saying she’s an adult in a child’s body but somehow fine with her ending up with perez. pock a stance

She didnt grow up alongside perez tho?? She saw him like twice when he was a kid? Once when he was a teenager? And then a fourth time all grown up which is when she even BEGAN looking at him in any sort of romantic light. So i think its fine tbh a little on the gray but not TOO much for it to be a deal breaker for me.

Tbh I think i do prefer a good comedy over 100 chapters of miscommunication lol say what you will fam in my eyes Perry's character gets overshadowed by literally every one of her in-laws

I'm bringing up FLs I like and consider favorites fam I have way too many brought up Navier bc you said Melissa is "cringe" and you seem to have personal beef with her so I wanted to bring up someone else that was more "elegant and graceful"

I'm bringing up FLs I like and consider favorites fam I have way too many brought up Navier bc you said Melissa is "cringe" and you seem to have personal beef with her so I wanted to bring up someone else that was more "elegant and graceful"

??? so now the argument is that firentia didn’t grow up alongside perez, meaning she wasn’t shaping him or seeing him romantically until he was an adult? that still contradicts your earlier stance. at first, you called firentia an 'adult woman' in a child's body, implying that her mindset was fixed from the start. now, you’re arguing that she barely interacted with perez as a child and only saw him romantically once he was grown, essentially backtracking on your own point. you keep shifting your stance, either her mindset matters and makes it weird, or it doesn’t and the relationship is fine. which is it????

so you’re saying you’d rather have shallow comedy than an actually well-developed plot? no wonder perry feels ‘overshadowed’ to you, you’re too busy looking for cheap laughs instead of paying attention to her character depth. but hey, if you prefer 100 chapters of characters running in circles over a protagonist with actual agency, that’s on you.

u literally set melissa as an example in comparison to perry, and now that I called her 'cringe,' you’re suddenly bringing up navier? If melissa was your choice to contrast perry in the first place, then stick with it, fam

don’t switch characters mid-argument just because your point isn’t holding up

Girl by mindset i meant goals like her head is in the game and shes girl-bossing her way to it ill always kudos FL that want to become/become head of their family idk i just like FL that are ambitious or have high goals. Tbh my mindset is that as long as they dont lovebomb and groom them its fine lol none of that "why am i blushing bc of an eight year old!?!!" Or smthin

But its not shallow tho? Tbh if you are seriously genuinely 100% believing that the manwha Melissa is in is nothing more than "shallow comedy" i think you're too far gone tbh lol as for her character depth i get it tbh she's just not my type of character lol you can understand a character and still feel "meh" about them.

I also brought up Deborah and Firentia??? im still with Melissa bc thats the one you insulted the most and then glossed over Deborah (which i get why) and Firenria (which i dont get?? Tbh Firentia is such a girl boss idk why you dislike her )

so now ‘mindset’ just means ambition? that’s not what you originally implied when you said she has an ‘adult mind’ in a child’s body. If you meant she’s just focused and goal-driven, that’s completely different from saying she’s mentally an adult. u can’t switch definitions mid-argument to make it fit.

and let’s be real, if the problem is love-bombing and grooming, then why did you frame firentia’s situation as weird in the first place? u literally said she has an 'adult mind' (because she regressed), yet now you’re downplaying that. u’re moving the goalposts again

My exact words were "their personality is already locked in?? Like they already have goals and a purpose' which is true lol. That is what i meant when i said they have an adult personality???

What do you mean??? I didnt frame it as weird??? I said "I wouldn't call them kids lol bc imagining them having a crush on a kid like other FLs gives me the creeps" which is true?? Firentia didnt have a crush on pereza as a child?? fam not you trying to gaslight me you were the one saying it was weird

Anyways fam this is getting way too long imma keep letting this marinate and when its over and I binge it all over again I may change my mind i may not idk have a good day/night and go read "Saving my Sweetheart" or "Please Marry Me Again, Husband" if you haven't already they're really good

u literally said 'adult mind' here fam, u said firentia had an adult mind and 'wasn’t a kid' because crushing on a child would be creepy. now you’re acting like you only meant she had goals? if she was mentally an adult from the start, then any dynamic with perez as a child should feel weird to you—whether they met twice or ten times. u’re contradicting yourself

Goodness, this is the longest argument I've seen here (≧∀≦)

I think you clearly enjoy more exciting and stories that appeal to the general public more, the girl boss troupe. Perry is girlboss but not in a way that is very overwhelming she's very chill and mature and she feels much more realistic. medea and etc other fls they're more crazy and reckless because they have some op stuff going on but this manhwa is much more real so the characters have to think for themselves. Me personally I prefer the mature realistic stories but to each and their own!! Fantasy isn't bad, just because they're all historicals doesn't mean they're all the same

tbs she's not gonna do a complete 180 over night.

I mean she couldn’t really talk back to her supervisor when she was in her grown ass woman self so its not totally unexpected to be scared less in her child form. She did say her child form also sort of influenced her emotions and stuff.

Fair enough but like on one hand she's blackmailing her abusive ex-boss' children and fighting them and shii and the next she's crying and acting insecure like the world is out to get her like...idk it feels very off-balanced lmao also I can't stress enough how dumb the adoption drama is lol like girl speak up??? This is such a non-issue

I guess that makes sense but like she flip flops too much is my problem I think like ur courageous enough to make a business proposal to the head of the family but not enough to say u dont wanna get adopted by an abusive pos ???? There is literally proof that he was mean to her when he forced her to kneel only for megane brother to step up and stop it. Megane could be her witness???

Honestly i get what chu mean like its 24 chaps already but this adoption drama hasnt end yet. But dealing with the kids is not the same as the abuser himself. mc is probably traumatized and too scared to speak up her mind. Even when she told herself she wont be a pushover anymore, facing someone who legit killed u in past life is definitely not an easy task.

True but it is frustrating like she has the HEAD OF THE FAMILY WRAPPED AROUND HER FINGER???? LIKE GIRL USE HIM???? she's doing business and hopping around without a care like if she's that scared be more self aware?? Lol also idk if it is just me but some scenes in this manwha reminds me a lot of "in this life ill be the matriarch" so i cant help but compare this MC just falls short in everything

I also think she fell short compare to mc from in this life life ill be matriarch. Still, doing business that she is an expect at ( handling paperwork like in last life) and the adoption process arent the same. She seems like she cant also trust other people to trust her without solid evidence( maybe she think that Jeff guy isnt really trust by grandpa) so she resolve to the book? Honestly i totally agree with the process not balancing between adoption and business. The plot is not advancing that much *smh*

True i guess idk i cant bring myself to feel bad for her whole crisis when an obvious solutions exists lol...she does have room to grow as a character tho I just hope it happens soon and she doesn't stay like this

I think it might ends soon since she already got the book but still who knows? The title is legit saying the family will be something she didn’t expected sooo maybe it will still be in far far future?

do u know more chpaters of this? novel or anything I need moreee huhu