Haoruchan October 3, 2023 2:51 pm

My heart literally breaks when i saw his smile. Like that's a genuine smile if i ever see one. I adore the artist to be able to convey his complex yet simple feelings towards Rosen just by a single panel. He's happy that she won't be tied down anymore. He's happy that she's finally free. Nothing else matters as long as she's released from the burden of the world. That's a true love if i ever see one. Most romance portray possessive and obsessive love as this sort of a highest form of love. But i beg to differ, THIS is what i nominate.

To be honest, from the start of the story until now, the plot could be seen as a quite simple one. It's literally about a woman escaped from a ship set sailed to an island. But still, the way the author explored all of the intricacies of life in this seemingly small plot is just so amazing. Other stories may have explored love through multiple settings and plots but this author's portrayal of love will never be outdone.

Ugh this is truly a very fitting ending for both of them.i truly enjoy this read. Can't wait until someday somehow i forgot about this and will relive this extraordinary read again

    Gojo's lower half October 8, 2023 6:17 pm

    So true, ian put Rosen's happiness first before any if his desires.
    He really loved her and wanted her to be happy even if it's not with him
    UGH I LOVE HIM SO MUCH

Haoruchan October 2, 2023 4:56 pm

Good riddance. Finally someone portrayed that kind of disgusting behavior perfectly. I'm tired of portrayal of this behavior romanticized. It's creepy af

Haoruchan September 29, 2023 4:53 pm

For an old series, this one had a potential in its time. I felt like the main focus on this story was Loki and Nakaba even though it was portrayed as this classic cringy shoujo romance story (which is quite a refreshing read honestly). Also, even when i had known that there will be twists in the end, i was still shocked lmao.

Yes the ending is a bit rushed and i do felt like the author wanted to just end it quick but it did feel like the ending was planned as the author said. From the beginning of the story, other aspects of the story was also rushed including the romance between Caesar and Nakaba, except for the story plots between Loki and Nakaba.

Casting the weird incest elements aside, honestly Loki and Nakaba is really something, like i'm not saying it in the way i see them in a romantic way like Nakaba and Caesar, but like they have an inseparable bond. They have this kind of bond that transcends beyond physical form of love, they truly care for each other....

Overall, is this like some kind of a innovative one-of-a-kind manga? No. Honestly i wouldn't really recommend this one either. I don't have any gained new insights from this. The author handled every kind of conflicts kind of lightly. But would i want more stories like this? Absolutely yes. As i said, this is like a decade ago. Time's changing and we've seen how progressive stories have become. However, some of the ones i've read nowadays felt more brain dead than this. So i would really appreciate if future mangakas could take the good sides of this manga and implement it into their stories.

Haoruchan September 26, 2023 5:38 pm

I need spoilers please!

Haoruchan September 25, 2023 5:26 pm

Ugh Platinum's so self centered. He clearly doesn't know who pink diamond is and only like the ideas of her. For example, if there's any incongruity like how obsidian could cook while his image of her was that she couldn't cook, he panicked and i know he def lost his feelings a bit there. What if obsidian is truly pink diamond? People can change, cooking is something you can learn in due time...things like romance novels too, you can grow to like different kinds of book in your life....

There's still pretty much unknown about Alex, so he's okayyy for now.

Granet is so cute tho. I can literally picture a big typical muscle brained guy behind his cute fake appearance lololol. I do feel regret but also grateful that he's not going to be involved in between Obsidian, Platinum, and Alex. He's pretty much a safe green flag guy so i like him best out of three. But yeah, since i don't really have a positive view of the "love triangle", i'm glad he stayed out of the mess

Pearl is my girl!!! She's an icon, she's a legend. She is what suit the "oh so perfect pink diamond" vibes the best. I'm pretty surprised Platinum is not even sparing a glance at her

Amethyst is alright, she's just like an average noble lady. So far she's harmless so yeah i'll support whatever she does rn. Go little amethyst!! Go chase Granet

Obisidan is......well.....As people had said, the premise is full of plot holes so i don't even want to point them out one by one because it's endless. She is just...lacking character development rn...Like i would rather go through the most painful awkward phase of her adjusting to her new role and slowly transitions into becoming a more confident person. Like yeah sometimes she can act well, sometimes she....yeahhhh....

So far i'm still going to read this....but idk for how long we'll see

    ひわまり September 28, 2023 12:53 pm

    Took the words right out of my mouth fr

Haoruchan September 22, 2023 7:05 am

I adore her so much oml, maybe we should have more old people getting isekai'ed to have such brilliant FLs!

Haoruchan September 4, 2023 7:52 pm

I did not sympathize with that woman but i wanna tell if any of y'all resonate with what she's going thru rn, then i'm sure you know that it's not going to end well if u place value on others' approval. Start by noticing more on things you genuinely like (that is not sourced by others' approval). Even if it's that small wild flower you found on the side of a street, or when the rain's earthy smell that accompanied your nap yesterday. By collecting more on things that you genuinely like, some day you'll manage to recollect your own sense of self

Haoruchan September 4, 2023 5:13 pm

Wait i'm kinda confused. Girlie turned straws into gold so how come no one cares about her "invention"? Like if i was one of the alchemist there, i would be dying to know and replicate that invention as well.

Haoruchan September 1, 2023 5:48 pm

The story is good albeit the shota aspect ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭so for most parts i just focus on more their codependency since it's not necessarily portrayed romantically but also as family.

Can anyone recommend me any story that has this kind of dynamic tho?

Haoruchan August 29, 2023 12:03 am

My 2nd ML syndrome is flaring for Brother Diati and i'm in pain. Diati is very much my type so seeing him getting treated like this in the story is breaking my heart. ╥﹏╥

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.