
I haven't read this in a while. I stopped after getting vibes that the shitty father might be getting redeemed or he might get forgiven by the FL. Is that still the case? Can anyone just spoil me of that? Is she all mushy with her shitty father now?

I will just tell you how he was redeemed and you judge if you want to continue reading.turns out he was manipulated by a demon ( he still doesn't know about it) so his actions were results of this manipulation and now he changed the way he treats the fl and ended up supporting her going against the blonde girl(the demon)..... she still not close to him but doesn't hate him either

Not gonna lie, Celphi's mom was right about some stuff. Like Peri didn't think about what would happen if she got pregnant (in the future cause she is the Dutchess now and their relations is real), she could very likely die. I kinda wish she would think more about the possibility of the curse harming her. I don't know, it feels like she isn't worried about it anymore when it's still a very huge possibility. I would actually like Celphi's mom to not turn into a villain. Even though I would like Peri to be Celphi's new mom, it's such an obvious twist. Let her be an actual nuanced character and not another villain.
Also Theo is back in his non-communicating era. Just fucking tell Peri things, I feel so frustrated when he hides things or just stays silent. If it was just once or twice it would have been fine. But he always never ever communicates. If Celphi's mom is actually bad then Theo should tell this to Peri at least or I don't know reveal some stuff. I also think the two should talk about their relationship a bit more? Like at least more on what will be the future like. Cause even though they are together now, their relationship still to me sometimes seems undefined or ambiguous. Considering what their positions are, I think it's not good. Like talk more that's all I am asking of you both but especially of the always silent man Theo.

Oh i like him better. He is so cute. Completely forgot about ML when the 2nd ML and MC were together. They look good together n so cute as well. Also I liked the detail where Morgan's palms are colored lighter than his overall color. Cause in reality tan or dark-skinned people have lighter palms and soles and this artist actually portrayed them. It's so simple but I am blown by this cause i don't see this happen at all in Manhwas or frankly a lot of the works here.

The characters are so so pretty. I am just completely in awe. Also I am so happy that Luke's d*ck is big as well. Most of the Bl authors like portraying the bottom character's peepee small as hell (not an issue but sometimes it's hilariously small in comparison to the top character).
Also I kinda want them to be switch. They are so so hot together. Absolutely mindblown by this BL.

I liked it but it was kinda hard to slog through the chapters at times (more times than necessary). Regardless of everything else (the non-con), I don't understand why the author made MC do the chasing when it should be the other way around. Why was he being so miserable and shit when the ML was the one in the wrong?
I think most of us feel satisfied when the one in the wrong does the redemption arc, here the victim is doing the redemption arc. But why? What did he even do that was so wrong that he had to be miserable for so many chapters while ML had a relatively better life? MC lost weight n shit. The read wasn't really that satisfying to be honest. The art is gorgeous, the story could have been better, and their dynamic is good at times tho. It's wholesome now but I still can't get over how the author could have made the ML have the redemption arc but chose to push it on MC instead. Like man whats the use. Also his personality really did a 180. Like I want the fiesty thing back. It's his first love sure but like I didn't see how he could even fall in love with ML n then all of this seem just weird. If there was a better development then him being like this wouldn't have been this weird.
It's kinda obvious that the Duke isn't the murderer. I don't how the MC isn't aware of the fact cause it is a bit obvious. Maybe not to her cause she can't see the Duke's POV like we can. I think if the author wanted us to suspect the Duke more, they shouldn't have let us know his POV.
Also, the MC is smartishhhh but I feel like she isn't Sherlock smart. I wish one of these days we would actually see an MC (in this genre) who is genuinely smart and can trick people or think three steps ahead of people. U know with the whole mind games. Was expecting her to be smarter as she is supposed to be based on Sherlock in this but oh well.