Frosche79's manga / #Magic(148)

It's cute and adorable alright. But it's just not good. There's something wrong with the pacing with her having her birthday in one chapter and then having a second birthday after less than ten chapters, I think? It also has a lot of plotholes, which justifies its low ratings.

This is so adorable. I cannot believe I never knew of this until now! I have no words, no complaints, it's perfect as a slice of life romcom! I really love the FL and ML's characters. They're both so humble and so down to earth! So rare as the main leads of a shoujo manga. I really hated most of the nobles. Seriously, are your ears for decoration!? If I were the main leads I would've grabbed them and shook them up till they hear all the words coming out of my mouth. Who the heck falls for that idiotic prince anyway! They really looked at him with rose tinted glasses and he's the narcissistic one who thinks he's all everyone wants. I'mma sucker punch him if it were me! Dude, the patience! I wish for more! I want more!!!! I really fell in love with the story and with the main leads. Can't wait for more ️️️️

I dislike this kind of relationship between the FL and ML. You know, the type where their relationship is not tied up by love but something more complicated. The FL says she's interested in the ML. She says she's curious about him more than any theory or hypothesis, which is a big deal for someone who years for more knowledge like her. She also mentions that even if the ML cuts her off from his life she'll never give up and come back in whatever status or situation, insinuating that even in the next loop she'll go back to him. Which us cute but, the real question is, beyond all that, WHY? Why is she saying all that? Like, what is her deal? What's her angle? What does she wish to gain from that? Why is she doing this? Like, is she in love with him or something? Cause she sure as hell not saying or even thinking about it! The ML is quiet and expressionless. Which is not unusual as the ML, being cool and mysterious is just part of their personalities. That's fine by me. What irks me here is that the first time they properly met, he told the FL he fell for her and then proceeds to propose to her. It's fine. But then he goes to go through the indifferent route. He shows his affections here and there, albeit subtly, but that's not the kind of attitude you'd expect from a guy who brought a woman from another kingdom and declared he's in love with her, when he's clearly not showing or behaving like it. He shouldn't have said he fell for her and just say he's interested in her. Also, I would've understood it if they had an agreement or a professional relationship in a contractually agreed engagement, but NO. Are they in love with each other? NO. So what's with them? This is why I hate these kinds of relationships. There's no label (technically there is on paper but emotionally, no) and their relationship is far more complicated and far more complex that the definition of LOVE. Which just annoys the hell out of me. I'm here to read something along those lines, not something that's almost philosophical at this point. I can't be interpreting and assuming everything that's going on between the characters based on just how they act. They have to say it too for me to confirm my assumptions. In any case, those are just my complaints. So far the art is good, the character designs are absolutely stunning. The concept is interesting, not uncommon but interesting nonetheless. And the story flow and pacing is just right, though any slower and it won't be long for me to feel old. I really appreciate the story despite my complaints. Those are just my complaints and comments, you can just disregard them because I don't actually want to change the story. It's good as it is. Anyways, I'm wanting more! Hoping for more!

It's good and it's fun. The art is stunningly good and the action scenes,

It was certainly interesting at first. The art is good and the designs are good. What irks me is that it's not delivered well. Also, it's weird that the FL kept saying she'll get her revenge and she's had her memories since she was reincarnated, but she never showed that she was prepared for anything. Most would've made the foundation for their revenge and have been preparing for it from the start but it's clear that the FL here hasn't been prepared at all. She kept being played in the hands of the villainess and it sucks that she can't do anything about it when she's had 16 years to harness her strength. If you ask me she's a bad FL of a revenge story. I'm tired of watching her act like she's a teen when she grew up as a royal and became a queen in the past life. She should've been smart enough to defeat her half-sister but instead she's being played with. Anyway, I just think this is made by a teenager in terms of the story's perspective. It's not well-written and it's sad that it is. Buhbye.

It's a good story that started very sadly. I mean, to be slowly abandoned by your parents at 5 just because your skill was too weak. Then you find out your father was ordered to kill you for it, I mean, what kind of a dirty scumbag does that to his own child! Just because her skills are weak doesn't mean she's got no survival skills. She managed to move from village to village earning her own money from hunting while her siblings are sheltered at home earning nothing. You can clearly tell who's stronger here. It's really admiring how she managed to protect herself and earned her own circle or people. I almost cried when there were a lot of people ready to help her. Although, she never told anyone about her starless skill, at the very least they appreciate her hard work and effort. Especially with no guardians around. I love the character designs, the art is beautiful, and the concept is tearjerking I wanna go through the screen and protect her myself. The pacing is good too. I love the part with the rare and weak slime she picked up and raised could turn out to be the strongest one. It's reflecting on her as someone who is starless, she could grow to be someone specially strong. I hope this isn't dropped or something. The part they ended at was so good too I want more updates! I want more!

I stopped at Chap. 67 coz I got bored of the concept. It's good, just got tired of it. I'mma come back for sure just not now.

Okay, so this is a fist for me to say; I actually enjoyed the Anime more than the Manga itself. At first I was weirded out and surprised at the part in the Anime where Lulu Lucy got pregnant with the MC's child. I mean, there weren't any indications of them having a relationship at all. Just them saying he's her husband and all that. Not even a nickname or any romantic skinships happening. I realized after reading the Manga, it's because he's not just involved with a single female, but most of the women in his village is involved with him, romantically and most probably physically. I was enjoying his farming and the development of his village, I was actually hoping there's no harem in this story but it seems that's too good to be true. I stopped reading the Manga and gave it a lower rating than the Anime. I just didn't enjoy the harem part. I'd like it if he only has a wife or two but no more than that please. They should've changed the title to "Farming with my Wives in Another World" instead of the original title because that totally makes more sense! I wish they could've erased the harem part and focused more on the farming and the village's development. I enjoyed that better and at this point I don't get why they're trying to insert the harem genre when it seems out of place as they progressed through the manga.

Still unfinished . I'mma let it marinate for now. I want to read it continuously because the climax is just up ahead.