Agathe's manga / #want more!!!(220)

23 There’s only one flaw : why does the MC has that evil disease ? How come shr think of the people as novels protagonists, when she has no reason to believe she lives in a novel ?? Did that bad disease spread so wildly that now even « non reader MC » can have it ?!? It’s sad as none of it make sense, and she would be much more wonderful without any of that crap ? In the same manner, is there any need to be reborn from our time ? Is there any point to it ? Or is it for business purposes (another thing we could obviously do without, even more when she makes investments without a penny to her name) It’s interesting as far as moral values goes, but it’s burdensome otherwise. How would a previous life have more influence in your thought process than your current life ? It’s plain nonsensical On top of that, she could also have the same moral virtues from her own life experiences. She had to take responsibility very young, she might be sensitive to the conditions of the poorest, and genuinely care for kids. Outside of these painful background tropes, i truly enjoyed the very poised and down to earth principled lady. The variation on the equation of the step mother is refreshing (she has no children to care for, the son is older than her, married with kids !) It has potential if it stray away from the reincarnator garbage ?

29 Some compla8ns how mundane she turns but i like it very much . She didn’t turn her surrounding into a tale, she doesn’t interact with people like they are « characters «  , she’s not some deus ex machina and what she can do for real is little. Meeting people, becoming friends, helping out with small means even as a grown up, it can be so challenging … it’s kind of slow, but fun and soft too. It’s certainly not too complicated either but it’s fine as a light read ?

50

28

37 The child feels like a child, not like an adult in a child suit and this is refreshing The sisters are great, they are very different and all are independent women The rest, meh, dukes and emperors, battle crazed men, bleh But overall cuteness is overloaded and it is nice it feels well written, with a lot of characters who actually do make sense.

26- Very well written brothers story (and siblings stories) Very delicate portrait of grief, damaged relationships between siblings, healing (there is a long way) and understanding Plus a toxic world of stardom Add a hidden murderer and a boy with bad reputation chasing him alone and your in for a roller coaster

40 i just love it For once, there’s nothing like romantic war, it’s depicted as the tragedy it truly is. When personal history comes in light,, very obvious that tragedies are never forgotten, wounds are deep and they can never go. The unfairness and the evil of conscription, hierarchy, the desperate situation that men have no choice but to endure, the broken bodies and the broken minds are the true picture that should be passed on I understand we like to praise our departed with heroic stories, but that’s just tales. The truth lies in mud , pain fear and misery, and for the family, in loss, grief and struggle. I enjoyed the vivid interactions of the many villagers. It does feel like a community of people caring for each others. There’s a strong sense of solidarity and belonging. I love how they share opinions about the bad nobles, how they hide secrets collectively. Art wise the eye exchanges and understanding grins made me feel immersed in a community : they are not a mere background The MC is lovely, she’s got a good and brave hard and is very straightforward. Her self confidence shines, but she also feels very real, down to earth when she talks about marriage, ambitious when she wants to be the village chief , caring when she picks up feed and gives work lost soldiers, daring when she goes to save her sister, cautious when she calls for help … She's strong, but like a true person, not like most characters, being OP or having impossible backgrounds . She’s just a plain village girl, not a beauty, not a lost princess. I hope the writer has the intelligence to keep it this way, she would become miserable as a queen Something makes little sense : after a war, there are usually more women, but at least it is said that the village opened to broken soldiers. Having no emotions means being impossible to make decisions - it is a biological fact, made obvious after brain injuries. It also has been demonstrated in economical behaviorism, what triggers decisions is emotions , Hume theories were right and Decartes has it all wrong. Wathever we tell ourselves as reason, comes after the decision process has happened ! So basically, a quasi functional individual must have some emos left. But well there are mages and dragon bone, and the story is too nice to bother I would hope the story keeps track where the prince becomes a villager and settles down. That would be a great and original variation. I must say i am worried main streams pushes in the other direction, so i can only hope the compomise will make sense I don’t want another cinderella story, that’s for sure sure.

40

30 Fun, great mc, wonderful family Yet somewhat angsty ?

19