New Question (AU): What if Asami Were a Police Officer?

Anoni Grrl December 7, 2015 12:08 am

This pure hypothetical for fun (and because I am interested in how people think). Pretend there was an AU where the personalities were the same, but Asami was part of an elite law enforcement task force tasked with bringing down organized crime (sort of an Elliot Ness of Tokyo). Assume Asami and Aki got together because of their jobs (albeit in a less rapey way--more the way cops warn intrepid civilians to back off and end up romantically involved with them in other stories). Assume Asami had a similar history with Fei because Asami was working undercover for some reason. Suppose Fei and other organized crime bosses target Aki in order to get to Asami. Asami would still have to go to save Aki, and Aki would still be a target all the time more because of Asami's job than because of Aki's own work. Would people want Asami to give up this job to protect Aki? Does anyone think Aki should give up Aki's career to make himself less of a target?

Responses
    MaouSama December 7, 2015 7:00 pm

    Sounds interesting!

    But for me Asami is just THE incarnation of a sexy, evil gangster boss ... ヾ(☆▽☆) he can't be anything else ε=ε=(ノ≧∇≦)ノ

    Romanceisdead69 December 7, 2015 7:51 pm

    In terms on Akihito, oh boy - I really feel like Mitarai and Asami are correct in saying that he is really not suited to his criminal photography job. He's still a little immature in the way he needlessly pus himself in danger to get the scoop (and the rush) that comes from what he does. I'm sure that wouldn't change no matter the AU lol and I really think both Asami and Akihito live for the thrill and excitement and maybe in a way that comes partly from their jobs - which is why they keep at it despite the constant barrage of shite from people after Akihito's ass. (Can't really blame them, it is a fantastic bottom...)

    But if either of them gave it up and did something less dangerous, that manga would be as dull as RL ( ̄∇ ̄")

    Anoni Grrl December 8, 2015 6:08 pm
    Sounds interesting!But for me Asami is just THE incarnation of a sexy, evil gangster boss ... ヾ(☆▽☆) he can't be anything else ε=ε=(ノ≧∇≦)ノ MaouSama

    That's cool too. Would it help if I made him a lead agent to invades privacy without warrants and beats up informants and suspects? That's got to be as evil as a crime lord, right?

    Anoni Grrl December 8, 2015 6:09 pm
    In terms on Akihito, oh boy - I really feel like Mitarai and Asami are correct in saying that he is really not suited to his criminal photography job. He's still a little immature in the way he needlessly pus h... Romanceisdead69

    There is that. :)

    J Unleashed December 8, 2015 7:11 pm
    That's cool too. Would it help if I made him a lead agent to invades privacy without warrants and beats up informants and suspects? That's got to be as evil as a crime lord, right? Anoni Grrl

    Yeah, he'd still have to have dark underside. More like lawful on the surface but deadly vigilante underneath?

    I know that trope's been done to death, but I still like it.

    MaouSama December 8, 2015 8:38 pm
    That's cool too. Would it help if I made him a lead agent to invades privacy without warrants and beats up informants and suspects? That's got to be as evil as a crime lord, right? Anoni Grrl

    Hmm... in that situation... I don't think either of them would give up there job for the reason of not being a target or protecting the other. They would only do a job they really love in the first place, so they wouldn't stop for any reason, but I think they would do everything to stop being a hindrance for each other resp. protect the other one :P they would maybe train or (worst case scenario) maybe go hide for some time or so, but neber stop their job or run away from their problems by e.g. chsnging their identities and go to another country ^^

    Anoni Grrl December 8, 2015 9:57 pm
    Hmm... in that situation... I don't think either of them would give up there job for the reason of not being a target or protecting the other. They would only do a job they really love in the first place, so t... MaouSama

    I tend to agree. I think they would find a way for both to keep being who they are. :)

    Anoni Grrl December 8, 2015 9:59 pm
    Yeah, he'd still have to have dark underside. More like lawful on the surface but deadly vigilante underneath?I know that trope's been done to death, but I still like it. J Unleashed

    Like Batman? :)

    Asami is a wolf. Wolves do as they do--unless they are distracted by a fluffy bunny with a really nice ass).

    Anonymous December 8, 2015 11:13 pm
    Hmm... in that situation... I don't think either of them would give up there job for the reason of not being a target or protecting the other. They would only do a job they really love in the first place, so t... MaouSama

    Does Asami love his "job"? I don't get that sense. That he is driven to do it by some compulsion that has never been made clear, yes. But love? No. Akihito may love his job but he sucks at it.

    Anoni Grrl December 9, 2015 12:09 am
    Does Asami love his "job"? I don't get that sense. That he is driven to do it by some compulsion that has never been made clear, yes. But love? No. Akihito may love his job but he sucks at it. @Anonymous

    Asami is dedicated to something--whether it is his job or some other thing that he does his job for (e.g. a clan or some kind of long game), I do not know. But somethings has been driving Asami all long.

    Anonymous December 9, 2015 12:20 am
    Asami is dedicated to something--whether it is his job or some other thing that he does his job for (e.g. a clan or some kind of long game), I do not know. But somethings has been driving Asami all long. Anoni Grrl

    Right, we don't know why he is dedicated but I don't see love, not in the terms being discussed here, like an overwhelming passion that drives a true vocation. That's what I think of when someone talks about loving a job so much they would not give it up for a person they love. That's not what Asami's drive looks like.

    Anoni Grrl December 9, 2015 3:50 am
    Right, we don't know why he is dedicated but I don't see love, not in the terms being discussed here, like an overwhelming passion that drives a true vocation. That's what I think of when someone talks about lo... @Anonymous

    Our jobs are a part of who we are--especially if we dedicated a large part of our life to them. Asami picked his job for some reason. I could see making a sacrifice if your loved one had to leave the country for some reason and you chose to give it all up and go with him or her, or if the lover got terminal cancer and you wanted to spend the remaining focused on him other. If your job is just a way to pay the rent, then that is one thing. However, giving up your chosen career is a sacrifice and it should not be taken lightly. I would question any relationship that asked you to change who you are.

    Anoni Grrl December 9, 2015 3:53 am
    Our jobs are a part of who we are--especially if we dedicated a large part of our life to them. Asami picked his job for some reason. I could see making a sacrifice if your loved one had to leave the country fo... Anoni Grrl

    Thinking about it, if I am really honest, personally I'd give up my job in a heartbeat if I had another way to pay the bills--but I am not at Asami's level.

    MaouSama December 9, 2015 11:42 am
    Does Asami love his "job"? I don't get that sense. That he is driven to do it by some compulsion that has never been made clear, yes. But love? No. Akihito may love his job but he sucks at it. @Anonymous

    Maybe love was the wrong word, but he is dedicated to it. I don't believe anyone could bring Asami to do sth he doesn't want to :P

    Anonymous December 9, 2015 1:42 pm
    Thinking about it, if I am really honest, personally I'd give up my job in a heartbeat if I had another way to pay the bills--but I am not at Asami's level. Anoni Grrl

    For one thing, Asami doesn't need to worry about paying the bills at this point. He could buy his own country. Again, I don't see love for the job. I don't see it as his vocation. But what we do have is Word of God that he has risked his life for his subordinates and would die for them without question. So he values the lives of others above his own life and hence, his work, it's not a stretch to believe that he would value love for another above his work.

    Anonymous December 9, 2015 1:42 pm
    Maybe love was the wrong word, but he is dedicated to it. I don't believe anyone could bring Asami to do sth he doesn't want to :P MaouSama

    Dedication is different than love. Many people are dedicated to jobs that they cheerfully walk away from when it's time.

    Anonymous December 9, 2015 1:43 pm
    Maybe love was the wrong word, but he is dedicated to it. I don't believe anyone could bring Asami to do sth he doesn't want to :P MaouSama

    And the idea that quitting is something he doesn't want to do is not something we absolutely know to be true.

    MaouSama December 9, 2015 2:23 pm
    And the idea that quitting is something he doesn't want to do is not something we absolutely know to be true. @Anonymous

    I also never said that I know from any source that he wouldn't stop his job, it's more like a qut feeling ;)

    Anoni Grrl December 9, 2015 4:25 pm
    For one thing, Asami doesn't need to worry about paying the bills at this point. He could buy his own country. Again, I don't see love for the job. I don't see it as his vocation. But what we do have is Word of... @Anonymous

    Maybe what he values is the group and loyalties people have to each other. Maybe he enjoys the long game in his cool Asami way. I think true leadership of any kind is a vocation. If being president can be a calling, so can being president of a company or clan with underground business.

    Asami is a leader. It may not matter what he leads so much as how he leads. The "calling" may be to lead--meaning that in time he would be in charge of whatever group he started off in. So in that sense, it doesn't matter if he is a criminal or a cop--so long as he is in charge.

    Anoni Grrl December 9, 2015 4:29 pm
    Dedication is different than love. Many people are dedicated to jobs that they cheerfully walk away from when it's time. @Anonymous

    This is true--but then I guess the next question is what makes it time? A better job? Retirement when you are old? Maybe something like that would be compelling. But leaving it for "love" would only make sense if the lover had a real imminent and extreme need for you to leave (e.g. he's dying and only has 3 months to live). Otherwise it seems more like "love" is asking you to be something other than what you are, and that doesn't sound like love to me.