Haven't read yet, why is the rating so low?

Stoopid July 17, 2023 8:16 am

Haven't read yet, why is the rating so low?

Responses
    Madeforbreaking July 19, 2023 1:24 am

    I think it’s because of the niche art style. It’s not the absolute best thing ever but certainly deserves a higher rating.

    Spammy July 19, 2023 2:56 am

    This author’s work is usually an acquired taste that’s pretty polarizing for a lot of readers. Story wise, her stuff tends to fall on a very seinen end of the spectrum, with a lot of plots and characters that are atypical for yaoi. Her art is also really unique too, and people usually love it or hate it, with little in between.

    Mahk971 July 19, 2023 6:38 pm
    This author’s work is usually an acquired taste that’s pretty polarizing for a lot of readers. Story wise, her stuff tends to fall on a very seinen end of the spectrum, with a lot of plots and characters th... Spammy

    Exactly ! Takahashi sensei started of as a shounen artist, then shifted to seinen for quite some time and it’s only in 2017 that she decided to try BL.
    Her stories are more drama focused than pure romance, they’re heavily influenced by seinen genre and lastly her art style is very unique. She doesn’t draw bishounen or hikemen characters. It’s either you love her manga or you hate it. In my case I LOVE IT !

    Spammy July 19, 2023 8:30 pm
    Exactly ! Takahashi sensei started of as a shounen artist, then shifted to seinen for quite some time and it’s only in 2017 that she decided to try BL. Her stories are more drama focused than pure romance, th... Mahk971

    Same!! I literally am obsessed with everything she makes. Yuki to Matsu and Stigmata just blow me away, I reread them all the time. So good.

    Mahk971 July 19, 2023 8:46 pm
    Same!! I literally am obsessed with everything she makes. Yuki to Matsu and Stigmata just blow me away, I reread them all the time. So good. Spammy

    Same, I love both Stigmata and Yuki to Matsu but YtM is on another level. I cried buckets after reading it and I never cry ! It’s one of my fave manga

    Spammy July 19, 2023 8:57 pm
    Same, I love both Stigmata and Yuki to Matsu but YtM is on another level. I cried buckets after reading it and I never cry ! It’s one of my fave manga Mahk971

    Totally agree. I sob like a baby every time, that story just shatters my heart every time

    purplesmutbitch September 12, 2023 1:19 pm

    It doesn’t have rape or it’s not toxic enough. Can never go by ratings on here.

    Beau September 12, 2023 5:54 pm
    Exactly ! Takahashi sensei started of as a shounen artist, then shifted to seinen for quite some time and it’s only in 2017 that she decided to try BL. Her stories are more drama focused than pure romance, th... Mahk971

    One of my favorite BL mangakas both art- and storywise! Some of her works are on mangaplanet and honestly, I just wish These'd be published physically as well. I'm not a big physical collector, but I'd buy her mangas immediately!

    Mahk971 September 12, 2023 7:29 pm
    One of my favorite BL mangakas both art- and storywise! Some of her works are on mangaplanet and honestly, I just wish These'd be published physically as well. I'm not a big physical collector, but I'd buy her ... Beau

    Yes and I’m sincerely glad that despite being super niche, her manga are still being published outside of Japan. Currently Manga Planet / Futekiya has released all her BL manga except for this one (which is still ongoing) and the cat story.
    It’d be sick to see the art style of Yuki To Matsu and especially Stigmata on paper

    Beau September 13, 2023 4:30 pm
    Yes and I’m sincerely glad that despite being super niche, her manga are still being published outside of Japan. Currently Manga Planet / Futekiya has released all her BL manga except for this one (which is s... Mahk971

    If you like seinen written and drawn by a female mangaka, then you might want to check out Tonari no Hyakkai Kenbunroku written/drawn by WATANUKI Yoshiko. It's a mixture of top-notch horror/mystery story with a tint of seinen. The first volume has been published and I can promise you it's a fantastic story both visually and storywise. Also, the younger male lead is super hot. :P

    Mahk971 September 13, 2023 6:51 pm
    If you like seinen written and drawn by a female mangaka, then you might want to check out Tonari no Hyakkai Kenbunroku written/drawn by WATANUKI Yoshiko. It's a mixture of top-notch horror/mystery story with a... Beau

    Thanks for the reco, I checked it out but there seems to be no official translation or fantrad ?

    Beau September 14, 2023 4:28 pm
    Thanks for the reco, I checked it out but there seems to be no official translation or fantrad ? Mahk971

    There's no either official translation or fantranslation unfortunately. :(