not such a fun quote

asjjdhskfjkd May 26, 2025 7:17 am

i know reading bl isn’t exactly halal, and i’m not gonna pretend it’s not a flaw. but using a quote that casually mentions the prophet Muhammed in a mocking way is a whole different level and that’s not just personal struggle, that’s crossing a line with something sacred. i get that fiction isn’t always perfect, but there’s a difference between reading something with flaws and is haram by nature, and seeing something that disrespects your faith straight up. one’s a weakness, the other feels like an insult

i don’t read this manhwa i just saw it on my feed but I wanted to air out my feelings

Responses
    asjjdhskfjkd May 26, 2025 8:39 am
    Normally I’d just scroll past this comment because I’m peaceful, but seeing this argument just drag on annoys me. Sure the quote might’ve felt hurtful to you, but it’s unfair to assume the creator meant... X10287

    the quote was one thing but the way others got loud and defensive the second islam gets mentioned is the real problem
    just come out and say your islamophobic and i'll stop wasting time on this
    (not directed at you)

    asjjdhskfjkd May 26, 2025 8:43 am

    it's not even about the quote anymore, it's just so icky how people are so quick to try defend people that show their hate and double down
    i give 0 fucks if you read this and i'm actually almost 100% sure the author used it innocently, but the real issue is how readers are so quick to get hostile just because someone points out something wrong

    freedom of speech exists please hop off if my opinions don't resonate with yours, i'm not forcing anything at the end of the day

    X10287 May 26, 2025 8:58 am
    it's not even about the quote anymore, it's just so icky how people are so quick to try defend people that show their hate and double downi give 0 fucks if you read this and i'm actually almost 100% sure the au... asjjdhskfjkd

    At the end of the day, we all respond to media based on our different values and beliefs, so disagreements are to be expected when you post a comment. I’m an atheist, so I don’t fully agree with you, but I respect your perspective. It’s just unfortunate that things escalated into insults and attacks instead of a real conversation. I’m tired so I’m going to sleep, but hopefully when I wake up there won’t be any more hateful comments that don’t benefit anyone.

    kuks May 26, 2025 9:11 am
    i'm glad i'm not the only one surprised how much islamophobia gets brought out in people lol ty asjjdhskfjkd

    Imagine bring racist and then commenting about Islamophobia lol...WHERE DID INDIAN CAME FROM...

    kuks May 26, 2025 9:32 am
    it's not even about the quote anymore, it's just so icky how people are so quick to try defend people that show their hate and double downi give 0 fucks if you read this and i'm actually almost 100% sure the au... asjjdhskfjkd

    Freedom of speech exist yeah and being racist is also a choice lol, you keep on saying every Muslim is not a perfect Muslim, homosexualty is sin in Islam and you are doing a sin. You just like those Ramadan people who break off with their bf or gf for a month thinking they will go to heaven. I am so tired of homophobic reading bl as a queer person myself, you guys would be homophobic in real life and fetish gay man on a ILLEGAL WEBSITE ...
    And about the idiom the author doesn't know about that because SK is not Islamic country, according to you Islam idiom shouldn't be used because they goes against your religious teaching BUT you should be allowed to read BL because you are NOT A PERFECT MUSLIM...
    Idk how does that makes sense, I wouldn't have even responded to you if it wasn't you comment laughing about Indians...
    Thank you very much for showing your mentality hope you don't read yaoi anymore because ITS A SIN...

    kuks May 26, 2025 9:43 am
    the quote itself is mocking. the people of makkah asked the prophet muhammed to bring a mountain towards them to prove that hes a prophet, but it did not work. so the prophet himself went over there and people ... asjjdhskfjkd

    Maybe the author search on Google and this idiom pop out, the author maybe doesn't even know real meaning it's my first time seeing such quote. I was like where did Muhammad came from, there was no intention of Islamophobia yeah it doesn't align with your religious teaching. But, then again that's your opinion, if you see it as mocking ...

    asjjdhskfjkd May 26, 2025 9:48 am
    Freedom of speech exist yeah and being racist is also a choice lol, you keep on saying every Muslim is not a perfect Muslim, homosexualty is sin in Islam and you are doing a sin. You just like those Ramadan peo... kuks

    let’s be clear nobody brought up homosexuality, and nothing i said was homophobic. don’t throw around fake accusations to derail the actual point, which was a disrespectful quote on a prophet. intentional or not i have the right to call it out. i spoke on it calmly, didn’t attack anyone, and didn’t name anyone

    you’re bringing up stuff no one even mentioned just to act like some moral cop, while ignoring the real issue that people started going crazy the second i mentioned islam. that’s not holding anyone accountable, that’s just deflecting. all i said was the quote felt disrespectful, and somehow that made people lose their minds and start twisting everything i said. that says way more about y’all than it does about me. the way the islamophobia jumped out just proves my point. you don’t have to agree with me, but don’t twist my words, project your own issues, and try to check me while being casually islamophobic. i said what i said, and i stand by it

    what i read is none of your business, moreover i'm DEFINITELY not gonna get schooled about religion from someone on mangago who keeps projecting their insecurities when i've done nothing but state my thoughts on a matter i've deemed disrespectful

    i'm fr done now bruh goodnight and PLEASE leave me alone i don't wanna see another take against what i've said

    kuks May 26, 2025 10:27 am
    let’s be clear nobody brought up homosexuality, and nothing i said was homophobic. don’t throw around fake accusations to derail the actual point, which was a disrespectful quote on a prophet. intentional o... asjjdhskfjkd

    "i’m not a perfect muslim, and reading yaoi isn’t something i can justify religiously. but it’s fiction, not real life, and sometimes it’s just a way to escape or feel something. i’m aware of the line, and i don’t take it as a lifestyle or belief, it’s just a flawed interest i’m still learning how to deal with"



    But you said it's not your lifestyle or belief means you don't support such things and you justify it as a fiction not real life also you said it's just flawed interest which you are dealing how to learn that means you don't support queer people in real life but will see two guys f#cking each other in fiction...
    Am I right ...
    I don't wanna make it a huge matter but the way you are justify such things makes me think you are just a fetisher...

    kuks May 26, 2025 10:32 am
    let’s be clear nobody brought up homosexuality, and nothing i said was homophobic. don’t throw around fake accusations to derail the actual point, which was a disrespectful quote on a prophet. intentional o... asjjdhskfjkd

    I lived 16 years in Islamic country duh

    asjjdhskfjkd May 26, 2025 10:44 am
    "i’m not a perfect muslim, and reading yaoi isn’t something i can justify religiously. but it’s fiction, not real life, and sometimes it’s just a way to escape or feel something. i’m aware of the line... kuks

    yeah being a gay MAN and having sex with gay MEN isn’t my lifestyle or belief because i’m literally a TEENAGE GIRL like PLEASEEEEEEEE. i’m not discriminating anyone, ESPECIALLY not queer people because I actively read stories that include them. not that it’s ANY of your business, but i’m part of the lgbt too i just don’t perform it for validation. when i said it’s a flawed interest, i meant reading explicit smut in GENERAL, not the genre. i read gl, bl, straight smut all of it. i’m aware it’s not something to be proud of, but let’s not act like we’re not all here doing the same and shame others. a lot of muslims read too, and that’s really none of your concern cause i don’t need someone calling me a sinner just to prove a point. i’ve never ever said a homophobic thing so STOP projecting. being muslim doesn’t make me a bigot so please let’s drop whatever you have against me cause you’re fighting ghosts rn the way you’re pulling words outta thin air

    deadass it's tiring tryna talk back to you when you're just accusing random things when your intentions was never to have a discussion, i'm not interested in entertaining your bs

    asjjdhskfjkd May 26, 2025 10:46 am
    I lived 16 years in Islamic country duh kuks

    same and i'm still actively living in it so why don't you just accept that not all muslims are homophobic and you don't need to accuse any you see online just because of whatever experiences or past you might've had with them

    kuks May 26, 2025 11:23 am
    same and i'm still actively living in it so why don't you just accept that not all muslims are homophobic and you don't need to accuse any you see online just because of whatever experiences or past you might'v... asjjdhskfjkd

    Did I said EVER said every Muslim is homophobic i know many Muslim who are queer people, it's hard for them to come out from their closet and it's against their culture and religious teaching the only thing they can do is to get independent then come out still afraid to go to home. I respect them so much but the way you worded it, it's so wrong ...
    Lifestyle and Belief it doesn't mean copy and paste but it means you respect their life choices not you are like them...
    Flawed interest also could have said smuts in general ...
    I am not shaming Muslims reading bl and bl, Infact I want them I know many Pakistani people who read bl/gl but they gotta hide, it's better to read them and be open minded so you can prevent generational trauma for your kids and understand them better, if they come out ...

    kuks May 26, 2025 11:25 am
    yeah being a gay MAN and having sex with gay MEN isn’t my lifestyle or belief because i’m literally a TEENAGE GIRL like PLEASEEEEEEEE. i’m not discriminating anyone, ESPECIALLY not queer people because I ... asjjdhskfjkd

    I don't wanna fight with you just a normal discussion showcasing your wrong choice of words ...

    kuks May 26, 2025 11:32 am
    same and i'm still actively living in it so why don't you just accept that not all muslims are homophobic and you don't need to accuse any you see online just because of whatever experiences or past you might'v... asjjdhskfjkd

    Omg it's seems like my reply got cut and made you misunderstood I apologize for that but what I said was "I lived for 16 years in Islamic country duh and never had a problem with that, I wore short dresses whenever I wanted to, my mom best friend is Muslim also our maid was Muslim and my mom brought nail paints to gift her but she politely refused and explained us then we brought a suitable gift her for Eid...How can you call someone Islamic phobic when you don't know them, you keep on labeling everyone who argue with you Islamic phobic" ...

    ❦ඩShashaඩ❦ May 26, 2025 12:15 pm

    Oh yeah I forgot to mention that it is the english translation of a korean manhwa so the author may have used a different phrase but it was translated to that

    chopin87 May 26, 2025 12:41 pm

    How is the proverb "mocking" in any way?
    It's a saying that underlines how if you want something done, you should not wait until somebody does it for you, but being proactive and act by yourself. Where is the mockery?

    Fujodanshi May 26, 2025 11:19 pm

    Shut up and get off this site. Don't preach what you don't practice.

    sapphics lover May 27, 2025 4:33 am

    plenty of everyday sayings use Christianity, like when people say jesus! when in shock or frustration, but as soon as it comes to islam, its a problem?
    i just dont get it.

    LUNATIC May 27, 2025 5:46 am

    Damn this thread is still going cause the hypocrite is still shoving the halal way

    chopin87 May 27, 2025 3:36 pm

    More like the nonsense way.