as someone who claims to be “just a reader,” you should still understand basic respect and ethics. if you’re an adult, you should already know what’s right and what’s wrong. asking why it’s disrespectful for someone else to upload another group’s work only shows a lack of awareness. when a group is already committed to a project, it’s common courtesy to reach out first before reposting or continuing their work. it would’ve been perfectly fine if the person had asked whether the group had dropped it before uploading the recent chapters. that’s what proper etiquette is, respecting the effort and commitment of others.
Not when its clearly not about money or anything near that. They dont get anything out of this and if the last chapter is being left in the cold that long whats wrong if someone just adds that one. It looks good and to me it sounds more like whinning tbh we should help each other
It actually is disrespectful. Imagine the scanlation group taking their time and effort to translate the chapter, clean each page, typeset each line, and then quality assurance. Those are hours/days down the drain because someone uploaded over them.
You already said it yourself: "They don't get anything out of this."
The group is providing high-quality translations for free and sacrificing their own valuable time in the process. The least they deserve is some basic respect or for people to follow the system/code.
I think Morse_Fellow already said this in the comment below, but it IS actually a general code of honor or rule between scanlation groups (this was already a thing for manga, before webtoons were even a thing) that people should not upload over them or ATLEAST ask for permission if they could take over the project instead (and that's usually when the manga has not been updated for like several months or more than a year)
It's not considered "help" if the person who uploaded over them didn't even notify them that they were gonna do it. The group still lost all the time and effort. This is really not whining. I think you should learn more about how scanlation groups work tbh.
Imagine working so hard FOR FREE just for someone to machine translate something and upload it because they're iMpAtiEnT. A scanlation group has multiple projects, the impatient person has just one.
Also, we should appreciate scanlation groups more than ever now. People barely pick any new projects anymore, they just upload official chapters and that's it, I at least crave some stuff that is not translated officially and deserves to be read.
what are you? a child? your reply honestly proves my point. i already explained why it’s disrespectful and shows a lack of basic etiquette, yet you still choose to ignore it. the fact that you’re reducing the issue to “it’s not about money” only shows how little your brain is, and understanding about respect for other people’s work. this isn’t about profit, it’s about principle and courtesy.
What? So, if you're having a dinner with friends and you're asked to bring a cake (and ONLY you), you make a whole effort for the cake to be perfect, and then someone shows up with a supermarket cake without even telling you and everyone chooses their cake, that's ok? You wasted hours of time, effort and ingredients but it's fine because they "wanted to help you"?
Explaining in those terms because you sound like a kid.
Mangago is a illegal side. What are we talking about right now. Being disrespectful just because i have a different opinion isnt the right way to debate and leave the children outta this
what an absolute dogshit take. you’re deflecting the issue, LMFAO. you asked, and we answered. and disrespectful? bitch, please. go back to school, can't you comprehend?because that sentence isn’t it . whether the site itself is legal or not isn’t the point. it’s about basic respect for people’s work and effort. having a “different opinion” doesn’t excuse ignorance or a lack of etiquette. if you can’t tell the difference between criticism and being called out for disrespect, maybe reconsider what kind of “debate” you think you’re having.
Yeah it is.
Now thats the level i expect from a comment section under a YAOI manga. I would love to continue this lil banter under hentaiheaven and devianart u silly goose. I still stand by my opinion + as i already said im not into this whole group project thing on here but these project are not jobs and uploading this ONE chapter everyone wanted is not THAT big of a deal. Dont stone me now uhmm...BITCH! I said it
So as a only reader who has no conection to the whole translation cleanup thing with all the groups here in the background. Is it rlly that disrespectul when someone else just uploads it ? I mean arent u guys have trouble with having not enough ppl to help ? Its a free site so i think its nice if other sppl help