Am I the only one who's absolutely heartbroken by the 'actual' Libertia's story? She never wanted to become the villainess neither did she ever try harming the people around her. She was forced to take the role of the role of the villainess ever since she was born.
"My lady,I had no one to love me even when I did nothing."
"People called me the villain ever since I was born."
She was forced to walk down the path her mother created for her; hence like a puppet she played the role of a 'Perfect villainess'. It was the predejuce that made her abandon her happiness (not like it ever existed to begin with).
A child abandoned by her father, and the ones around her. She was someone who was never loved nor befriended, making her live a life of solitude.
There was no one there who'd sympathize with the pain she was going through. Technically she was never alive to begin with, she was dead from the day she took her first breath to the last. She was never loved. She was never cared for be it her mother, father or a friend she could truly call her own. She suffered and fell to her demise, but at the cost of what? Nothing.
She died at the hands of her 'brother', even though she was going to die anyways it was surely an unfulfilling death. She knew she'd die but in the end she didn't want to die as a 'lunatic'. So she chose to play along with fate, hence letting others mold her into someone who was born from pure evil.
Even when the MC asked if she wanted her to get her revenge, she said she wanted nothing like that. Rather than living like how she once had she told the MC to live 'freely'. Sadly 'Freedom' was something Libertia never had. Be it in the palace she grew up in, or even the world outside. She was a slave of her misery, and a product of society.
Even through the memories she scattered for the MC to find, she wasn't seen smiling even once. Even in the recent chapters when she was running through the field of grass she didn't laugh, because even in that moment of freedom she knew it wouldn't last long. Rather than being joyous, she was determined.
Ever since she was a child she was treated as if unwanted. Like mannequin made of ice, she never laughed, she never smiled neither did she ever enjoy. She played her role well, as the ice princess. She was calm and collected, always well-poised. However she was accused of henious crimes that she'd never even imagined of committing.
It's a given she never spilled blood, more over never once discriminated the ones under her, yet when her life slipped through her fingers like pouring sand no one cried for her. Not even once, did anyone truly love her. All everyone did was torment her, and all she did was quietly suffer.
She was the true victim, one who suffered in the shadows of her mother, one who never received her fathers love, one who lived in isolation and one who was defamed by the society.
Ngl the aftermath of Charlotte's "death" is quiet tragic. It shows how important she was to her disciples and how her disappearance left them in shambles. All of them had great potential; one being the emperor, one was an elf and the gurdian of the forest, one was the master of a guild, while not much is revealed bout the last 2 disciples.
The goodbye she thought they'd accept without questioning drove them to the edge, leaving the children she raised broken. The emperor (Calsilion) was hell-bent on finding that he didn't care about the was that could take place between Claus and Marveil. Yurian destroyed the forest (she was guarding) in order to absorb magic, and eventually casting a spell to turn back time and bring back her master, which resulted in her memory loss. Dan lost his last place of comfort, eventually suffering from insomnia and losing stability to the point where his subordinates were forced to 'kidnap' people so that their leader could sleep properly. Though much isn't known about her last to disciples, the whereabouts of her 4th desciple is unknown (and rumoured to be dead). While Ivan (the youngest of them all) is out of control, he's believed to have colluded with the 'calamity' in order to find his master; whom he believed he'll find at all cost (to the point he stole that Valcan's heart [I'm sorry if I'm wrong with the name]).
Other than that I'm sure that Jeffery would also break if she hadn't come to him in the first place. Since we all know he loves her (and wants to protect her at all cost). He'd definitely be broken if he knew that she'd decided to 'die' and didn't even tell him, leaving him alone.
All in all, Charlotte was (and still is) well-respected among the people of both the empires (Claus and Marveil) thus not only was her 'death' unexpected to the people that held her dear to their but also for the people who truly respected her for the contribution to the world.
I want her to reveal herself to her disciples since I personally feel like it's for the best. They didn't deserve such a goodbye, at least not through a mere letter. She was an important figure to all of them to the point that her last goodbye left them empty.











buT tHE cArRoTS NoOo-