
I don’t care if I get thumbed down to oblivion. I came back cuz I wanted to give this story a chance that it would be become better but it’s getting cliche and so typical. Judging by the tile I thought the female character would be very different and great in her own ways, but this is very misleading.

IKR the first like 3 chapters or something, the story was interesting. From the down fall to the revenge. And when the lady asked for marriage I thought well ok, but then it was cuz she was secretly having crush with the dood! LOL and all that we look at each other eyes and blush... all of them happened to the so called empty soul duchess within the first 12-13 chapters.

I agree with the title being a clickbait, but i think the point of the FL's character is not actually being empty souled. It's just a nickname for whoever marries the ML, since he's famous for rejecting women or any sort of persuasion.
I dont think the author ever really planned for the FL to be cold. She obviously already had at least a small crush on the ML from her prev life when she was mistreated by everyone because of her ugly face, yet was taken care by him during the war.
Also the FL has it easy to breach the wall built by the Duke cause she knew him from his prev life. She knows the Duke isn't looking for love, thus doesnt take that route to approach him. And that made her different from other women.
It would be great if the title actually foreshadow the FL's character like you said but I think this webtoon is interesting anyway if you look it in different ways.

There’s a couple moments missing here, Alenjandro hugged Ibelina after pinky promise. The translator missed that page. Too bad. Read the raw here https://rawdevart.com/comic/sincerely-i-became-dukes-maid/chapter-44/

Her revenge is satisfying but honestly I’m very disappointed. I thought she would become cold and empty and the Claude dude will fight for her love but it turns out meh... She likes Claude and wanted to marry him, even to propose him while the dude is someone who is actually ‘cold’ (but not empty, he has his own reasons to not getting married). Don’t get me wrong, I’m not hating on the story, it’s just not what I’ve been looking for.

She's not in love with him.
Gaspal and Tristan aren't just going to let her go. Gaspal needs her summoning skills. Think also of how her father feels about her engagement. She cannot get out of it with her own power.
She wants to enter into a mutually beneficial arrangement with the Argentine, who's looking for a partner that doesn't love him.

ok so i just found out that the 'spoiler' thread that I read was just fan theories, and when i tried to search for novels and raws and other spoilers, turned out that <<<<<<THERE IS NO NOVEL FOR THIS STORY>>>>>>> so we dont know yet, the raw in korea just at 23 going to 24. So there is still hope for your OTP. I'm cheering for Jeffrey and Lotte.

anyone already read the novel know if Jeffrey will end up with the blue-haired girl (is she the empress?)? I feel a little bit heartbroken cuz I ship Lotte with Jeffrey but they're gonna happen T_T so i just wanna know who Jeffrey will end up with.

ok so i just found out that the 'spoiler' thread that I read was just fan theories, and when i tried to search for novels and raws and other spoilers, turned out that <<<<<<THERE IS NO NOVEL FOR THIS STORY>>>>>>> so we dont know yet, the raw in korea just at 23 going to 24. So there is still hope for your OTP.

After reading in depth spoilers, I came to conclusion that her true love is Asisi. She loved him but because of their age differences, it’s impossible to marry someone who is your dad’s age. Even though it is not really emphasised in the novel,but u get the gist of it. She got married to Ahin cuz he was very nice and loved her. But really it’s kinda sad, Ahin is a good guy but I’d rather see her end up with asisi.
I love the pace of the story, and so I hope the won’t drag the story when it’s time to reveal the truth to her disciples