Coco December 6, 2024 5:03 pm

it has been years but this remain my fav shoujo manga about reincarnation. only now i am thinking to randomly talk about this

- ever since beginning saeki idolized serena too much

- their romantic interaction in past life feel a bit juliet-romeo-esques, not my cup of tea since it feel less real

- in the past, man-woman interaction are limited so there's a small question to me whether they will still end up together if it's not the past. well it kinda partially proven with serizawa end game

- serena wanted to be a man so she would be able to stand side by side with saeki. if they became lover in this life, well yuuma could still be that, but with saeki's personality, yuuma would be more protected and spoiled as lover rather than someone side by side to him... serizawa was a bit different that saeki used to still see and treat her like his past best bud... although that's why i am bit disappointed that he treated her a bit like serena after they dated, but i am sure serizawa will call him out if he went overboard (this is mostly my headcanon)

- so by that, saeki and serizawa made a good and more interesting combo in shoujo manga. meanwhile saeki and yuuma would make a kinda generic pair in BL manga. yumma (the uke) being the younger bratty tsundere one with overprotective relative and saeki the lover who will kiss the ground he walked on (although honestly it will still be interesting)

- serizawa's past life as his best bud and being reincarnated as a girl made me thinking, did the past life wanted to be a girl and stay by saeki's side as a girl?? tbh i forgot a bit about this story, so was it ever mentioned? but i remember thinking or headcanoning, oh it seemed his past life liked saeki, or something... so tbh this is more BL than saeki no longer care of serena's current gender... bc nevertheless i think saeki actually liked yuuma mostly bc he used to be serena, a girl. compare it to serizawa past life as a man who want to be a girl for saeki ... this one feels more BL.... okay sorry forgive me this is my actual real reason.. anyway go read uragiri wa boku no namae o shiteru...

    Coco December 6, 2024 5:12 pm

    - saeki moving on from serena is a big character development and it is in line with the message that he have to move on from his past life. sure he could still date yuuma and said it had nothing to do with the past.. but the message would be weaker

Coco December 5, 2024 12:30 am

I didn't like it at first, he looked like a generic mob, and the big eyes looked very cartoonish or like really flashy shoujo manga
it broke the immersion when they said he'd very handsome... but after the new hairstyle he did look great. i also got around his personality after 20 chapters, at first his personality is too bubbly/positive to be real, make it hard to imagine a conflict, but fortunately the story provide enough interesting conflict which made me not focus on his personality. in fact, now it compliment the plot

Coco November 28, 2024 5:57 am

although there are a lot uncommon things here unlike in other bl, it didn't turn me off, instead it made me like this story so much.

1) ml r*aped mc, but then mc r*ped him back, an eye for an eye. i am tired of seeing bl where the mc have always to be the one suffer in the bed. ah yeah btw, they're totally SWITCH. they said it in story extra (novel). lol although both of them are reluctant when it's time to bottom and they both have complain with the other's performance. if someone has a good story with switch couple pelase rec me.l something.

2) also, BOTH had gotten married to women, and both had a son which is important because at that time period leaving a son to continue family lineage is important. in other bl, the couple usually chose not to marry opposite sex to have children, or if someone have a child, it will be the male lead again! i am happy for once that they still follow their time period custom which made me able to immerse myself, and yes that's they're really people from that time period, not a comic character with progressive mind given by the author through the fourth wall

3) they didn't have that kind of happy ever after ending. the end is kind of bitter sweet imo. i think even the author originally wanted them to not meet again in the end iirc but change her mind bc readers asked for them to meet again

4) the raise and fall of the mc and ml was kind of amazing. although i feel it's not entirely realistic but it also felt realistic. mc had reason why he wasn't punished for the treason you see, same with ml return to power, it doesn't feel like a plot armor. anyway i just really feel i had followed them for a lifetime

5) i like how both were good friend with that death friend. i feel like that person was the white moonlight for both for different reason. although i do have complain about him. but even as the emperor's ex he's not a third wheel, or have antagonistic role at all. overall all the side characters played their role impeccably. i even feel fond towards ml's son although he just showed up briefly

    Nagisa-sensei-fan November 29, 2024 12:01 am

    Can you please tell the name of the novel or where I can read it?

    Coco November 29, 2024 1:49 am
    Can you please tell the name of the novel or where I can read it? Nagisa-sensei-fan

    ah i hope you don't mind MTL ing because no one has translated this (there was once before but it stopped for unknown reason)
    https://www.jjwxc.net/onebook.php?novelid=358744

    Coco November 29, 2024 1:52 am
    Can you please tell the name of the novel or where I can read it? Nagisa-sensei-fan

    but if you want something similar like this and completely translated, you can read "the governor sickness" it's also historical with politic, you will feel like you followed both lead for a life time. unfortunately they're not switch. but the mc is a manly assassin. it was really angsty story because the world is quite dark, but both lead had really good relationship unlike in this manhua. it also got a manhua

    Nagisa-sensei-fan November 29, 2024 11:16 pm
    but if you want something similar like this and completely translated, you can read "the governor sickness" it's also historical with politic, you will feel like you followed both lead for a life time. unfortun... Coco

    Thank youuu for the link!!! I am actually reading the governor’s sickness rn and I like it sm!

Coco November 23, 2024 9:50 am

lmao i legit thought the chapter has ended when the ads "cafe mieix" showed up

Coco November 21, 2024 1:49 pm

lmao once they're together they're so embarrassing
there's no holding back at all at whispering sweet nothing
well it's embarrassing but after seeing the journey it's also warmth my heart

Coco November 19, 2024 2:44 am

i like how they didn't show MC's face when the pov is them.... does it mean MC's face actually looks different from other's perspective?

    ggggg November 19, 2024 4:22 pm

    I interpreted it as demonstrating that he’s a ‘mob character’ in everyone else’s story. Since generally authors don’t bother drawing the faces of mob characters.

    Coco November 20, 2024 1:45 am
    I interpreted it as demonstrating that he’s a ‘mob character’ in everyone else’s story. Since generally authors don’t bother drawing the faces of mob characters. ggggg

    oooh yeah that also one way to interpret it
    but he also ended up looking all mysterious lol

Coco November 19, 2024 2:43 am

he's so in love!

i can't help but to cheer on him!

so precious (*˘︶˘*).。*♡

keep this going! (ノ≧∇≦)ノ ミ ┻━┻

and no one will complain when they get together!
(っ˘з(˘⌣˘ )

Coco November 18, 2024 4:33 pm

i forgot how cassette work, so i didn't get it before.

(need confirmation from previous chapters)

for example this is RUN 3, PLAYER 1 used TAPE 1 to "record" aka saved all his current memory of RUN 1 & RUN 2 plus the memory he would have in the current RUN 3. In the next RUN 4, TAPE 1 will be automatically "turned on" and PLAYER 1 would remember the memory stored there (RUN 1, RUN 2, RUN 3)

however in RUN 4, PLAYER 1 didn't save or record anything.
this may happen:
1) PLAYER 1 continue to RUN 5, his TAPE 1 still playing. So he will have memory saved there (memory from RUN 1, 2 & 3) but he will not remember RUN 4. there will be gap in memory.
2) another player found TAPE 1 and turned it off, so in next RUN 5, PLAYER 1 will not have the data of TAPE 1 (he will forget RUN 1, RUN 2, RUN 3) basically he will forget everything and turn into an NPC in RUN 5. if he used a new tape, let's call it TAPE 2, he will have memory of RUN 5 in the next RUN 6. but as long as his TAPE 1 is still turned off, he will only remember RUN 5 and so on.

saving each run is the most important to prevent gap in memory and even if the previous tape is turned off or even erased/overrided, it won't matter since the content of the new tape will be the same as the previous tape (if it's true that the tape record all previous memory the player currently has, not only memory of the current run. so as long as the player doesn't forget anything, the tape will record everything).

it will still be safer to save with different tapes everytime to have at least "backup" although there will be gap in memory. however the tape seems to be random so it can't be controlled.

point of confusion though, there will be a lot of tape "turned on" or already used which will be very suspicious, except if everyone can recognize their previous tape and override the record. so most player probably used the same tape over and over again. or maybe if someone continue to save every run without fail, only their recent tape will be available and the previous tape will vanish?

also there are side A and side B. I don't remember whether it has come up and explained. need reread.

    macarrones33 November 18, 2024 5:54 pm

    it's so complicated but thank you

    Coco November 19, 2024 2:24 am
    it's so complicated but thank you macarrones33

    that's why the story is complicated

    i am trying hard to make it understandable.

    however what i explained probably not 100% true.

    at least in this chapter we got that "the daddy jokes dude" got back his memory when Bada "turned on" his TAPE. so i just tried to piece the "possible" explanation.

Coco November 16, 2024 1:06 am

well i mean, it's difficult to have a divorce in royal family. at this rate i don't think he will ever divorce her either if they ever survive this. i thought if shuki were going to end up with his childhood sweetheart, either she will return again before marriage or have the second prince die. i mean if she just run away with the other guy while the marriage still technically intact... um it's a bit difficult to imagine since this is a shoujo manga. it will be considered cheating right

Coco November 15, 2024 3:19 am

ooooo i feel as if the art improve a lot

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.