did she really need to be reincarnated? i feel like its such an unnecessary part of the story. like i get how it influenced her being more secretive and scared of her secret, but those aspects didnt really have a ton of influence on the story imo. unless im missing how else it contributes to the story??
As you read you come to understand its importance
im caught up
At some point, they seems to forget that this story is about an mc that can interact with ghost ╮(￣▽￣)╭
yea thats my point it would be cool if it turned out she actually couldnt be targeted by the curse because her soul isnt from their realm so its not under their jurisdiction to control, but its gone too far beuond that at this point. theres no ghosts, theres no real importance to her having a previous life, etc. i love the art and the characters, but this story is heading to solely romance and some politics
I almost forgot this was supposed to be a romance until a couple of chapters ago lol
FR!! Like im sure ghosts exists outside of the palace but with them only showing her interactions with the palace ghosts, there's rlly no point to her ability other than as a plot device. Heavy on the past life as well. Honestly hate this trope of reborn/transmigrated when it rlly doesn't serve a purpose other than to be used as a plot device for the maturity/"uniqueness" of the MC. And a lot of the times they never touch on why/how MC transmigrated bc again its only used as a plot device
are all masots nakey under there
ALSO HIS BIRTH MARKS ARE LILLY PADS <3
No. You need to wear clothes in those things.
Honestly maybe that mascot's costume is like an onsie thing? But yeah I was also surprised when he didn't wear anything under
some of the proportions are SO WEIRD idk why it isnt being talking about. like in the first chap where they get squeezed on the train, uke looks like a fucking bobblehead im sorry
the political angst and timeline does not make any sense. they shouldve killed fl when she was "silent" for years like how they killed the other siblings.
Yes, but that would make sense ╮(￣▽￣)╭ same as the eagles in the Lord of the rings xD
exactly
spoiler
not sure how this has a high rating. the plot is subpar with way too many plot holes and plot armor. FL is bland, not that im looking for a bad bitch, but give me something more than untoasted white bread and a thin layer of mayo. art is subpar, which would be excuable if the plot was worth reading.
things that dont make sense:
- i get it, they hate her, but if she's taking the role of the crown princess she needs a better foundation. if they truly cherish the madeleine name, they would at least provide better education, shut the gossip around their name, etc. whether they like it or not, she carries the highest rank in the household and therefore is the most representative of their name.
- there is barely any explaination of the world we're in. the history between the dukedom and royal family and how he became the "dog." the oath ceremony and the "rules" around that tradition. name dropping specific garments as if they have a special meaning but never explaining it.
this is the entire plot: sad girl enters mean house and saved by strong man because strong man like how nice weak girl is. the mean family and mean royal family are mad that she switched sides but there is never any explanation as to why it has to be her and why the crown prince just cant marry his lover who is the daughter of a marquis, one rank below a duke and is sufficient status to marry into the crown.
there is no strong female lead, the male leads interest is two dimensional, and the antagonism isn't logical
Everything is explained better in the novel its not at all what you're describing dont worry.
yea looking at the comments i realized the novel is much better and might move to that. the pacing and world building in this version is an absolute mess
Totally agree. This story is sooo common and female lead can't even stand up for herself without a 'man' and her personality is so bland it makes me want to pull my hair out. When the crown prince tried to slap her, ml be coming out of nowhere like he's stuck in her armpit 24/7 guarding her weakass. Like it's fine if she can't fight, but she fr doesn't have any ounce of trait that makes her interesting. ╮(￣▽￣)╭
I don't understand why no one understands what it means to be traumatized. First of all, the protagonist isn't awake, and she doesn't need a man to be strong. The thing is, she was despised for 14 years, by her family, her fiancé, and everyone around her. They hated and despised her, and especially when you're despised by your family, by those closest to you, it's horrific. Naturally, she has very little self-confidence, and Edwin was the first person to stand by her, help her, and listen to her for an extended period. Sure, he provides her with the income to boost her confidence, and she tries to rise above herself, but it would be just as positive if it were a woman instead of a man. But it‘s a Romance Story.
i recognize the trauma, i need to understand the setting the character is in. again, the world building is an absolute mess.
the antagonism of the royal family and madeleine family is basic: they're incompetant and evil. big woop. why are they incompetant? why are they evil? whats their motive? whats their goal?
okay, the FL is an affair child and things went downhill since her coming into the family. but why did a daughter of that family really need to marry into the royal family? why doesnt her family at least make her presentable? why cant the prince marry the marquis'daughter (the classes arent that far apart)?
this is over 35 chapters in and there is basically no real plot besides family evil save me
I can understand that the story is a bit loose in certain places and doesn't really explain or tell things well, and I agree with that point. What bothered me about the comment was what was said about the protagonist. I mean, if you don't like her, that's fine, but there are many stories where the protagonist has traumas, and these are usually discussed as if they have to be overcome immediately and it would be the easiest thing in the world. That just threw me off. She definitely has some weak points. I can imagine that one of the daughters has to or is supposed to marry the Crown Prince to gain power over the Duke, and because of loyalty. The Emperor said something like that, and he realizes that he's not the brightest bulb. It's obviously about power, but it's really not well explained, and I hope they'll improve it.
i think throwing the excuse of trauma around is just flimsy storytelling. there are so many ways to write about trauma reaponses and the author chose to do it poorly. theres a difference between trauma induced isolation and just a character that takes her whole life and over 30 chapters to learn her family truly doesnt care about her. but no, the author chose to write about how she keeps getting her hopes up... for what? for something to change after 20 years ?
That's how trauma really is. Especially where family is concerned. I went through this same experience myself and can tell you I was still hopeful at 30 that one day they'd treat me right. You don't get it because you never experienced this kind of life.
That's how trauma really is. Especially where family is concerned. I went through this same experience myself and can tell you I was still hopeful at 30 that one day they'd treat me right. You don't get it because you never experienced this kind of life. (●￣(ｴ)￣●)
as someone who also went through this, uou either live and you learn or you continue to burn. FL chose to burn and i just think thats poor storytelling
claiming i didnt live similar because i think using trauma as an excuse instead of a motivator in a fictional story shows your lack of nuance in trauma. you need to do some self reflection because making bold claims at 30 is a serious lack of maturity