
I was still hoping for Yana to tell us a good story with a great plot twist that we wouldn't even imagine...
Instead we have this "Oh, I already knew but didn't tell... For reasons" from Tanaka.
Are we going to have the same from Madam Red? What about the uncle and.. like... EVERYONE.
Lizzy will say: Oh, yes, they were twins but I only care for the eldest 'cause He was my fioncé, when he came and said "I'm Ciel" I totally forgot about the other brother, 'cause.... Reasons. Ah! and I totally wasn't suspicious, I can't tell the difference at all. For me they are exactly the same... But now I'm gonna betray this one and go with the real eldest, 'cause... you know, REASONS."
DON'T. FUCK. WITH. ME. TOBOSO-SAN.
I've been reading this manga for about 8 years already! You can't do this to me, YOU CAN'T, I won't accept it!
I would prefear you drop it or made it yaoi or even kill Ciel before get his revange and make Sebastian eat his soul. I don't care anymore. Everything would be better than this.
Agh.... the pain.

Actually I don't think Lizzy knew OurCiel that much when they were little, when Lizzy huged Ciel after he came back from the cult, Ciel said ''Lizzy'' but the people who were translating were suppose to translate to ''Elizabeth'' which is more formal, less familiar. Tanaka didn't say anything because OurCiel didn't say anything either. It was going to cause a LOT of drama since our Ciel wasn't the heir.

They. Were. Twins.
Maybe Toboso will show us some story about OCiel being captive in the residence and something like that, but that would be REAAAAAALLY cliché, forced and unreal.
And yeah, of course you can say "oh they knew but didn't want to say" but that just make a lame excuse for a lame plot.
I really hope a lot more from Toboso than this.

Everyone is minsunderstanding him.
He has mental issues, not only the thrauma about everybody manipulating him.. He was mentally wrong since child.
Even the author mention it, He's retarded (not in a peyorative way, but in the real way) and maybe kind of autistic.
It's not his fault at all. Even if he looks like "normal" and functional... He is not.

I don't think Suda truly loves him like your thinking. If Suda loved him then he would be willing to give him up because it would be better for Hinata. Hinata has a week mind and if he picked his twin brother and Suda went I'm not having that, I think he would just end up right back where we started in the beginning. If you truly love someone your willing to give it up for the better of that person.

Everybody have this cute image of love, but they need to know that love can be healthy or unhealthy as well. You can love wrongly, you can be sick and still love somebody. You can hurt someone you love.
It's not the correct form of love but is still love.
This guy had this kind of twisted and desperate love, but wasn't playing with him as He said. He really care for him and wanted to stay at his side.

Are you kidding? HE RAPE HIM” HE SAID NIT BUT HE CONTINUE TO FUCK HIM!!! HINSTA NEVERNLOVE HIM WAS SUDA SAYING THAT HE LOVES HIM.......ON THE CONTRARY HINATA REALLY LOVED HIS BROTHER WITHOUT HIS BROTHER SAYING SOMETHING TO HIM!!! SUDA IS A RAPIST HE KNEW HINATA SINCE HE WAS 16 !!!!! HE IS A CRIMINAL WHO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF HIM OF A SICK OERSO! THE BROTHER IS NOT LIKE THAT HE WAS FINE WITH HIM WITH A WOMAN OR IN LOVE WITH SOMEONE BUT THIS WAS NOT THE CASE HIS BROTHER WAS RAPE AND TAKE ADVANTAGE
If he only talk openly without trembling everything would be clarified, but never say anything right.
Who could blame him? That guys is a tyrant. Of course, he will be scared.
I blame him.