Their first meeting is the New Year's Kiss. Their third meeting is when they make their deal together. When does their second meeting happen which is apparently some kind of fight or conflict which leaves a bad impression on each other? Which chapter is it?
I don't remember the exact chapter but they show that Karlyle meets Ash when he is with Nicholas (Kyle's partner). I think there was a misunderstanding between the characters because Karlyle (and also Kyle I think) find Ash and Nicholas together; that's why at first Ash thinks Karlyle has a bad opinion about him and that's also why Kyle doesn't likes Ash very much.
I'm sorry english Is not my first language but I Hope you understand my explanation :)
I liked him the best in this entire story. The most complex character too. Can't believe the narrative tried to trick me into thinking someone who slept constantly with people was somehow worse than a rapist, stalkers, groomers, and parents who turned a blind eye to their kids getting raped. Fuck his mom and his tutor, forever and ever.
First couple was boring af. 3rd couple whatever. Jinhan was my favourite in this painfully stupid webtoon.










IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN NISHINA!