
I really enjoyed this manga. Like others have said, I do think it was a bit rushed. The plot was solid and the main characters was solid. Nina kind of just went from Gilles to Roy kind of quickly though. Slow down girl. I would like to see more of the black haired guys story. I’m guessing he fell for a wolf. It’s still ongoing, but this definitely could have been stretched out to at least 30 to 40 chapters. 5/5 stars.

THIS IS FUCKING CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT! I'M LIVING. I love how they both put each other in the others shoes. Skyler saw how Yeonduk saw him and Yeonduk saw how Skyler saw him. I want moreee.
And are we just going to brush over the fact that Skyler's mom tried to kill him? We just going to pretend that didn't happen? Like she didn't grab a whole pair of scissors and try to stab his ass. All jokes aside, I hope their relationship can be somewhat mended. She needs help. She needs to go to their school counselor! You see he works miracles and shit.
Plot: It started off pretty good. Then it just got kind of cliche and corny. I do love reincarnation stories. I’m all here for it. The ending was just weak. The brother tried so hard to make the people in the shinsengumi hate Hitomi and it just fell flat. I love a good villain and he wasn’t it chief. And these people were supposed to be samurai in a past life. I wish there was a little more action and display of their skills. Is Hitomi never going to talk to her brother again? Did he even love her? Shit, where’s the sibling talk? 5/10
Characters: Pretty solid characters. None of the characters were overbearing or too annoying. The main character (Hitomi) was strong and nice. The brother was just a weak character. 7/10
Romance: I think Hitomi should’ve ended up with Oda but that’s just me. Of course, if you’re going by the standard shoujo manga storyline it makes sense for her to end up with Gokokuji. There should’ve been more buildup for the romance. 4/10
Art: BEAUTIFUL. Although I did confuse Hitomi with the other person in the shinsengumi. 10/10
Overall, I’d give this a 6/10.
1000% agree with everything in this comment.