CuddleQuill December 11, 2020 1:57 am

I love this story, so don't get me wrong. I just feel like Dylan isn't thinking straight. Think about this for a sec:

The whole reason surrounding why Cedric fell in love with the "heroine" was because he was heartbroken by his beloved Emily's death and he was drinking himself to death. And then the heroine appeared, soothed his heart, and even had a similar appearance to his deceased wife. It wasn't because she was his "fated" partner, even though it was written into the story.

Now that Dylan has taken the place of Emily, the heroine wouldn't look anything like her, so how could Dylan think that the heroine was the "fated" one? There's no purpose for the heroine to interfere because Dylan will not have died, and Cedric would not have been heartbroken and drowning his sorrows in liquor.

I hope Dylan realizes that she was the sole catalyst for the "story" changing. She's so focused letting Cedric find his "true happiness" while ignoring his own feelings. She's probably going to hurt him in this process.

But whatever, I guess we'll see what happens. Like I said, I'm enjoying the story. Dylan's thought processes are just frustrating.

    MACS December 11, 2020 7:42 am

    I understand your views as I've thought that as well but in another perspective suddenly falling in love with someone even after suffering from the deaths of loved ones is actually already pretty impractical. In reality, they would all the more try to stay away from affection. As Dylan is more on the practical side, I think she believes that the strength of the predetermined fates of the story characters will prevail. Since the world she's in now is at the fictional world of a book. I don't think she truly realizes just yet that these characters are real people and that they have their own thoughts and feelings. She may care for them but she believes more strongly that the world she's in is from a "book", one where the ending is set. I'm not sure if I'm getting this across hahaha but that is just my opinion. Anyways I could be wrong as well hahahah

    cesque December 11, 2020 7:50 am

    u do have a point, however i believe dylan in the book fell in love with adelaine (idk if thats actually her name lol) for who she was. Yes, thats why his attention was brought to her but the way our mc is so pushy about him going to adelaine makes me think that in the book he rly was happy with her. So if they were both in love with eachother in the book, then theres a possibility that love will flow again in the present time. Thats why i rly cant blame our mc for being firm about falling in love (we all know she will be eating her words later on) bc she has no choice atm. if she does let herself fall, anytime of day the real heroine can come knocking at the door and sway the ml out of his feet and shed be left alone.


    HOWEVER! its a manhwa, the mc and ml are as firm as dylan's will to survive and protect her sister so obvi, theyll end up together. as they should periodt

    cesque December 11, 2020 7:51 am
    u do have a point, however i believe dylan in the book fell in love with adelaine (idk if thats actually her name lol) for who she was. Yes, thats why his attention was brought to her but the way our mc is so p... cesque

    i believe cedric*** jesus i got confused for a sec

CuddleQuill December 1, 2020 1:42 am

Although it can't be proven [as of yet], that doesn't mean it isn't the truth. To brush it off as it simply being "psychological" feels really dismissive and uncaring towards the MC's worries/feelings:

http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/a_loving_existence/uu/d_chapter-5/pg-4/

I remember a true story I heard many years ago about a young child who had a heart transplant. The little girl started to get violent nightmares of being stabbed by an unknown man every night. It got so bad that the girl's mother started to research whose heart that her little girl had received. Of course, with the patient privacy on the line, it was very difficult for the mother to get answers. But, eventually, I think it was one of the deceased's family members that decided to come forward. The heart the little girl received was a murder victim that had been stabbed to death by an unknown [male] assailant. I don't remember if the stabber had been arrested or not.

But I have heard and read of many other similar situations. Our bodies store deeply emotional and or severely traumatic memories, even after death (for a period of time). It's not impossible for the heart's former owner to have visited the MC in the dream if that was his desire—one that maybe he wished for with all his heart—to convey that his son needed love and support. But these are just my thoughts on the matter.

On the other hand, I absolutely adore this concept and I look forward to reading until the end; whenever that may be.

    Llola December 2, 2020 5:32 am

    woah that story sounds crazy, so like it could give you memories and feelings that aren't yours but the previous owner?

    CuddleQuill December 2, 2020 5:53 am
    woah that story sounds crazy, so like it could give you memories and feelings that aren't yours but the previous owner? Llola

    There have been instances of that, yes. Obviously it doesn't happen all the time or more people would be aware of that possibility. Most people tend to brush it off as fiction or "psychological" responses, but there was no denying what that little girl saw in her nightmares and their correlation with her "new" heart's former owner.

    Lulu December 2, 2020 4:43 pm
    There have been instances of that, yes. Obviously it doesn't happen all the time or more people would be aware of that possibility. Most people tend to brush it off as fiction or "psychological" responses, but ... CuddleQuill

    Oh yes I remember reading this story of a girl who got a heart transplant and after the surgery, she begin running and picking up hobbies she never did before. Turns out her former heart owner was a runner too. So I agree, the dream of his dad isn’t entirely impossible

CuddleQuill November 24, 2020 2:14 am

This guy's first body appearance in the first panel is out of whack. Huge arm/hand and weirdly wide thighs (that don't appear as skewed in the other panels).

CuddleQuill November 23, 2020 4:24 am

Wild, honestly.

CuddleQuill November 9, 2020 12:50 am

If Ebony is going to ask for the freedom of her friends from prison and or maybe a change in the laws about education.

    Erys November 9, 2020 6:52 am

    I wouldn’t exactly like that maybe something a little bit more played down I feel like It would be more gratifying if she kind of got that powered herself to do that of course by staying by his side
    After all she’s more like I am a joker dressed as a queen and specifically he wants to because he doesn’t ever want her life but she’s going to become a queen so also I don’t like that she feels more down right now maybe freeing her friends a little bit would be a good thing or making them review the laws or it would be more specific to just say I don’t want it to be illegal for this in this to happen because it’s just ridiculous there is a chance that they will agree it if they look over the laws and they will let them go because they no longer committed a crime Or give them a better life inside the prison because I don’t think they were just gonna let them all loose because she asked for it

    Erys November 9, 2020 6:53 am

    Oh my God I think I know what she’s going to ask for I think she could ask for is getting rid of all the guards just like fire all of them and let me put in place of people that I want to be there of course with set rules and you can view who they are and you can’t even judge them yourself but I get to pick them that would make a lot more sense their lives would be better with proper fairness

CuddleQuill October 8, 2020 3:42 am

Everyone is so worried about the kids being there when they ARE NOT even there. You can literally see either the present space crumbling or a new space being built where our MC is getting felt up by this new guy. I guess no one was paying attention, so here's your proof:

http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/i_was_reborn_as_the_villainess_father_and_i_need_xxx_to_survive/uu/iur_chapter-2/pg-13/

CuddleQuill October 2, 2020 2:51 am

Personally, I think the sister is kind of a representation of us as the readers. We were "spying" on Uito and Sei and we were also rooting for them, too. That's how I saw it, anyway.

    Lost October 2, 2020 3:02 am

    Was it a little weird? Yup. But I kinda see it like that too.

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.