
This was soo good! But there is one thing i still dont understand..
In the first TL why did he like the other sister? Im so confused. And Elzay already dead in that TL or did she never exist?

As I understood, the reason why Aseph from the book fell for Lisa because Elzay didn't exist because Primesta sent Elzay's soul to the girl who read the book. That was in order to save Zay from dying repeatedly for Aseph since Primesta is very fond of Elzay. So instead of Elzay, Aseph targeted Lissa just like what happened at the first encounter of Zay and Aseph at the garden.
And in my opinion, I think the book was just an opening to Zay's memory in her past life with Aseph dying and her protecting him. That's why she came back again and save Aseph again even though Primesta moved say to Korea.
It's like the book was the portal for Elzay to comeback again and save Aseph.
But that's just how I understood the story though (⌒▽⌒)

As I understood, the reason why Aseph from the book fell for Lisa because Elzay didn't exist because Primesta sent Elzay's soul to the girl who read the book. That was in order to save Zay from dying repeatedly for Aseph since Primesta is very fond of Elzay. So instead of Elzay, Aseph targeted Lissa just like what happened at the first encounter of Zay and Aseph at the garden.
And in my opinion, I think the book was just an opening to Zay's memory in her past life with Aseph dying and her protecting him. That's why she came back again and save Aseph again even though Primesta moved Zay to Korea.
It's like the book was the portal for Elzay to comeback again and save Aseph.
But that's just how I understood the story though (⌒▽⌒)

I'm not sure of this so take it as a grain of salt but I heard a spoiler somewhere that Elzay either didnt exist in the book because her soul is sent to Korea or she died when young before she could meet him, I'm thinking it's probably the first one. As for why he fell in love with Elissa, it's because they're twins. Similar to how the prince also mistook Elzay when he first met her as his soulmate, Azef also mistook Elissa as his soulmate(or specifically fell in love and obsessed over her), especially when in the book, Elzay, his real soulmate doesn't even exist, he turned his love towards Elissa.

Yes she did die young, and that she kept on repeatedly dying while saving Aseph. Because she saw Aseph's life in a dream. Because she has the ability to see someone's future. And to stop Elzay from dying repeatedly, Primesta sent her to somewhere far away from her original life with Aseph. That's why in the intro, she was a high school girl. But this is just how I understood the plot. This story is really good tho. I just replied to share my opinion .

Why would he want to keep it a secret that he's not the real dad? Im sorry but thats kinda selfish. The kid deserves to know the truth when he grows up. Its the same with adopted kids. Why wouldnt u tell them the truth? The truth doesnt suddenly nullify ur love for them, right? This is just my opinion tho

I was so excited while reading, but then i decided to go look for spoilers and now my interest has died down. Alas, i really liked mc in these few chapters, but the plot seems kinda boring.
Gonna look for another manhua now ╥﹏╥

So the brother is a crazy Yandere. They are not related by blood. The OG Lana loved him, but he didnt love her back.
Anyway, after getting out of prison MC will get shackled and imprisoned at home for freaking 4 years by her crazy brother. After that she meets ML again and he kidnaps her and confines her too, but with him she's more free than with the crazy brother. ML doesnt treat her bad. He's obsessive, but not as obsessive as the brother.
MC doesnt mind being held captive at all bcz she just wants an easy life and bcz ML doesnt treat her bad she stays there. I kinda liked her personality, she looked a little down to earth in these chapters, but after reading the spoilers she just seems boring tbh. She doesnt care at all and there's no action u know.
The only normal guy i guess is Renag, but he doesnt stand a chance obviously lol

But do you have spoiler about rose families?
I'm still curious about that, but the novel story is so slow and i dropped it
ML is red rose, FL is blue rose (and she's the last descendant of blue rose), brother is black rose, Renag is yellow rose, while original female lead of the novel is white rose
I think i've read the chapter where the novel told the details and the importance of this roses but i already forgot, i read the novel last year, but i still remember the feeling that i found the roses' story interesting despite i forgot what is it about

Mhmm not gonna lie. That purple haired dude she sold the estate to gave me more ml vibes than Lancelot.
Idk but i think it would be better if he appeared later on in the story. This just felt really too soon and abrupt. Also, something is kinda weird about him. Idk what yet but we will see. He better has a good reason for coming so late

I saw the next chapters just now and i can't forgive him. Piece of shit. He neglected her and instead of looking for ways to protect her and make her stronger he obeyed the father and let all that happen..
The dad and duke can die for all i care.
Also, i still dont understand why the father blamed her for what happend? Fkn idiot.
WHY DO THE MCS ALWAYS END UP WITH THE ONES THAT HURT THEM IN THE PAST? WHY? JUST GIVE HER ANOTHER LOVER PLEASE
SOMEONE SPOIL ME PLS. I read the latest chapter but i didnt understand shit. DOES HE REMEMBER EVERYTHING AGAIN?