
I just feel like Ciel's reaction is odd, like I would expect him to be happy that his bro came back alive, but... you know. The real Ciel is an asshole. Like, "Hey bro, I know you've gone through severe trauma and am sad that I left, but you did a great job impersonating me, and I love you, so... I wanna play!! So I'm gonna frame you, make your life hell, I'm looking forward to what you'll do lil' bro. This is brotherly love btw~ muah oh and I now own everything you've achieved, by birth right... "
Like. If he did it in a diff way, I think they'd have a happy reunion. But no. Cause plot.
Though I find it kinda strange that our Ciel is obssesed with the title. Because... he never really owned it, he's the 2nd son, I thought he'd come to terms with that... he was impersonating the real Ciel, I mean I figured he did it to honour real Ciel's memory, but now... why does he want it back? It never belonged to "him". An obssesion for something he could never have? Something he always wished for? Recognition? The love and affection that was always given to the real Ciel that he will never have? Now all his effort is gone just like that, he has an attachment to the life he took from the real Ciel? An obssesion?
It just feels weird. He lived a life that was never his, now that it went back to the one that rightfully owns it... he doesn't want to give it back.
It feels ... petty to me. I mean I get the frustration, but what... can he do about it? Harm the very sibling he loves? Start a coup for the Earl title? Just feels...petty. really. Go start another candy factory that you've always wanted to or fight for the rights of the sweets company...? I guess.
But, even if he does that he'd still need to get revenge for the destruction to his family... so sebas-chan, what's your role in this?
To be honest I never really liked Elizabeth, even when she became "badass".
To me, she always have this self-righteous and weird imposing attitude. At the beggining she was clingy, and always pushed her way into our Ciel's life despite the way Ciel acts - borderline indifferent, unless neccesary (this includes keeping her happy)
I guess our Ciel may have deceived her of his identity, but really. I kinda hope she suffers more from her mixed feelings. I mean, she can't deny that the feelings she had for our Ciel was our Ciel's fault. I hate that she's so... urg. So, the Ciel that you always love is gone, you mistook our Ciel for his twin, but really now, you don't even care about him and act against him because he impersonated his brother? Do you not even pause to think of why he'd done that? Maybe there was a decent reason. (Maybe) ...He didn't force himself on you. You mistaken him all on your own, and now suffer from your own misjudgement. I can already imagine the way you treat our Ciel when he was younger. I feel that with Elizabeth's exagerated reaction, she must've really disliked our Ciel or maybe even bullied or isolated him when he was younger.
Though, in her defence, it must've been hard- the guilt of mistaking someone else as your own lover. She must've felt cheated and repulsed at the idea of marrying someone that wasnt her lover. (But she would've eventually, or maybe be engaged to Our Ciel, even if she knew that the real Ciel is dead-the trauma though) . But, now I'm really curious about their childhood as to why she despises our Ciel so much. Did she look down on him for being a wimp? It's unnatural, there should be some form of lingering feelings for him, and he's still her bro in law... to disregard his life like that... so harsh.
As for real Ciel. He's an asshole. At least give some proper love to our hardworking Ciel. Though, I'd really like to see his personality more. He has this wicked atmosphere around him that I like. They always say that he's more like his dad than our Ciel is... so I'm really looking forward to it. At least he smiles like Vincent does. (=・ω・=)

2 reasons why our Ciel got mad. First his brother (who he loves very much and thought was dead) was actually alive and didnt come forth. Second the only time he does come forth is to take everything our Ciel worked so very hard to achieve. Kinda like saying "oh thanks for doing all the work for me now I'll take all the credit" also 1 simple reason why I'm mad at real Ciel.... HE KILLED AGNI!!!! THAT MOTHER FUCKING JACKASS!!! ILL SHOVE MY FOOT UP HIS ASS!!

In one of the chapters Our Ciel mentions that if anything happened to the real Ciel that he is just his replacement. That's why he impersonated his brother because think about it would people have been as happy to see our Ciel if he didnt lie? Probably not since Elizabeth still would've been suffering over losing the one she loved and Madam Red had more of a connection with Ciel since he played outside a lot not like our Ciel. That's my guess

Haha I agree, he's bound to be mad. And real Ciel's a bitch.
I really love Agni as a character, and hate him for killing him.
But, at the same time I'm really curious what his motivations were? He didnt kill any of the other servants, but wanted to kill the prince of India and his servant. Was it just to make our Ciel's position worse? Place more hardship on him?
It feels like chess, the real Ciel made his move, and now our Ciel has to defeat him.
Maybe real Ciel is training (or just toying with)our Ciel to make him be more vigilant and ruthless and be more tactical in the future? (I have a feeling that real Ciel may eventually die again in the future, and let our Ciel be the true" earl of Phantomhive"? )

Yea, which is why I find it odd, he was just a "replacement" right? But now that the real Ciel is here, the only thing he should do is to step down. Why is he still pining for the position as a replacement? What is our Ciel's motivation? Reluctance to part with his achievements? The love that real Ciel has? Or is there something more?
I feel that our Ciel's reason to impersonate his big bro is decent, and I hate the way everyone around him thinks that he's a terrible person for it.
But the way the real Ciel did things was a shit move. Why did he treat our Ciel that way? Is also odd.
So, it's not only our Ciel that's acting weird.

I'm just as clueless on the situation as you. Real Ciel is a major sadist if you ask me though. You're right he played him move and bow its Our Ciel's turn but damn did he play a good move impersonating Our Ciel to kill Angi so he won't have Prince Soma to run to, he probably said something to the fat German guy too just so Our Ciel would struggle with who to trust and where he and the others could be safe. Still beyond all this commotion going on i truly wondering what Tanaka thinks about all of this, like what is going through his head at the moment?
The only thing that bothers me is when a white haired kid said "You dyed your hair didnt you"
To a brown haired kid. (Original hair colour is black).
... like. Wtf. why would dyed hair be a banned thing from schools in a mutli-hair colour manhwa??????
How would they know????