Agathe's manga / #Interesting(417)

60 - you have to endure the super powered baby, but if you dig classical heroic fantasy, it's pretty good so far It certainly could have been better with a faster pace, and without a few useless episodes

13 . i have a very strong impression of the whole story ? Is it somewhere else or under another title ? (The novel ?) It is interesting, yet it has it flaws, for example the MC is an observer that doesn't seem to get involved, it makes things a bit bland, there’s a nice reflection about how to live wih the memory of a past life, use it, abuse it, forget it, fear it… the idea that this new life is a « game » is pretty toxic, it certainly brings some edge and knowledge, but obviously, it’s at the price of an illusion : the world is real, it can change, people have feelings and reasons outside the story, living without observing and interacting with them is a natural recipe for disaster The many reincarnated girls provide enough to see how difficult it is to live beyond what is real - people living like their are in a game are basically mentally diseased

9 - vilainess turned good, but with a malus Not too deep, but cute so far I find the anti racism comment strangely disturbing, if she's really to get a pale skin as a reward, that would be pretty disturbing, ( honestly i ad that in the novel, it happens as an accident, bt has little impact on the story, and the fact she can't stand people change of attitude toward her - yet it's a very poor choice)

24 - side character becoming important , probably because of a caring behavior So the big debate here is how much past life memories defines you, or more generally, how much can past memories shape who you are The MC remembers part of her life as an adult, but how does memory function ? Does that makes her a grown up ? She has a kid and then a teenager body, past life memories come as an addition to her present life, is it surprising she acts her body's age ? What can be added from memories? Physical memories are obviously all lost, knowledge, can only stck so far if it's not repeated, so yes, she'd keep her favorite recipes and her job, maybe her ability to remove the most common stains she met often... but emotions are driven by the instant also, maybe she has a bit more maturity and control in regular circumstances, but any adults knows control is an illusion in many situations, isn't it ? and should we believe that the little girl who was blushing in front of kids her age would suddenly become horified at "pedophiliac thoughts" because of memories from another life? There no take on that that should be more valid than the over, after all, falling in love is not a cognitive process, and basically, who can help it ?

7.5 - 3.5 - a bit different without much surprises so far

201 - not bad if you skip the battle Sadly creativity of the forger is as much as replication of our world, nothing is too riginal, but at least there's no harem

50 - 4.5 - very good mix, fast paced, partly stupid but fun characters and there's even a plot !

Complete - I don't know why i can't find it perfect as it's obviously way better than many things Mc is a great woman, both her and the ml have a great relationship The ideas are fine, the morality is strong and the plot is... Well that maybe it : the plot is strong yet, it's also very far fetched Also the emotional involvement of the characters is ... something else ? ( i meet you, i rape you and i fall in love the next day ?) then what is the point of their secrets ? Create tension artificially and flop it ? So while I'm super glad it's fluff nearly all the time, it's also very bland ? You don't really accompany them in the process of their falling in love Also i can never relate to these traumatic characters It's excellent by all means and I'm happy with the ending I. Very much appreciated- but mostly intellectually Maybe i had a hard time with the art, it's not bad, but i don't know

35 - 3.5 - somehow it's really good that the MC doesn't obsess about her game memories, so she acts spontaneously and reveals another story The plot soon becomes a succession of small stories little related together, magical " slices of life "?

18 - a bit confusing but seemingly strong plot