
I saw a comment that someone made for the "ines's agancy". I wanted to reply to that (but couldn't, so here i am) because they were saying about how people are commenting about Carcel taking away Ines's right to decide but no one is talking about Ines taking away Carcel's decision about his life in the first chapters of the manhwa.
Well i kinda don't agree with this haha. Even tho as the commenter said people are talking about taking away Ines's right to decide, it's more said in the way that Carcel is belittling himself before even saying sth to Ines without giving her the option to say sth positive. You know what i mean? Like, basically he rejects himself and people are saying no to do that since later on the both of them will be in pain.
And for the other part about Ines deciding what to do with Carcel's life-as a marriage prospect (i think they mean about this situation if not, i apologise) it's kinda not correct again, since Carcel cheated with literally every woman that glanced over him haha, so even tho it's basic manners to stay celibate in that situation-he didn't, and he took matters into his own hands. Aka meaning he did what he wanted at that moment. So he didn't lose anything then and they just waited the wedding to happen later on, whereas in this situation they will both lose and feel pain since they fell in love with each other.

And also even tho Ines chose Carcel for her plans about her future without him knowing that, that still didn't change anything in Carcel's life since he did everything he wanted without thinking the aftermath. Him falling in love with her after their first confrontation as grownups was just a plus on the both sides and also his consequence from being intrigued by her since she didn't bat her eyelashes like every other woman and was cold as stone towards him. So, logically after falling in love of course he would do everything for her. So we came again to the conclusion that it's not the same. Since he didn't lose anything but only gained but now in this situation they both would be losing.

Soo...I'm not saying that after everything she should end up with Erez even though it's nice seeing the real side of him and the reasons why it ended up so bad in their past life but it would be kinda nice, since he acts innocently, cute and has pure love for Ayana.
Personally in my opinion the best ML is Rox. He literally is her confidant, friend, admirer, colleague and could potentially be her love partner. So he has the full package. They have fun and carefree relationship and i actually love that fact (which is weird and rare cuz i'm a die hard enemies to lovers fan).
And lastly Diabel... oof idk man, i know that he probably will end up being the ML but i kinda don't like that. Sth makes me angry and icky about that relationship so i can't ship them. I get that he was her first love in the past life since he was always there near her, ready to protect and assist her with everything but honestly i'd pass on that relationship idk why. Oddly he's my least favourite.

spoilers but they probably aren’t fully accurate cause i have shitty memory
diabel is actually a W, he dies for mc’s sake but resurrects as a devil (with erez’s help I THINK) and then makes a “contract” with the mc, he asks for her everything but it was highkey a lie so that she wouldn’t get suspicious, he’s also trying to make it seem like he was faking his persona in mc’s first life but he isn’t at all (sorry if that didn’t make sense) but yah

Yea that's not a spoiler anymore it was explained here in the manhwa i think, it was when he told her what happened in the past life after she died (if i remember correctly Ayana died first while Diabel trying to save her). So nothing new here if i remember correctly lol. But sadly, even after all that my opinion about him doesn't change, so i don't want him to be the ML.

diabel and ayana are perfect for each other since they been together for so long they both know each other’s inside and out and the novel its really gut wrenching what diabel did for ayana. rox do seem healthy for ayana but ayana is possessive and obsessed with diabel and will only love him like she said in the last chapters, they are both possessed with each other and at the end ayana only sees rox as friends. i hope it didn’t come off too rude

The reason you're saying why they are perfect for each other is the reason why i don't kinda like it. I also wrote the same thing originally in my comment. There's something iffy with their relationship, something that irks me, that's getting on my nerves and even i don't know what the specific reason is hahah. But i get why you like them together... probably most of the audience like them being the end game. I knew it from the start that he's gonna be the ML, so everything else is just my wishful thinking. Also, I don't think that Erez is a bad person and also i don't think that he's the reason why she was so miserable in their past. He was the one who wanted to save her if you remember in the prison cell scene. He probably loved her in the past life too, but had to go to the war and fight against her because of the family.

girl u think erez is not a bad person?? you have pretty low standards for people ig,, he literally almost beats someone to death just because of jealousy,,and idk what ur sayin cuz he didn't offer to save her instead he offered her to surrender to him or else she could die,,why put condition if he's so determined to save her dude?? also why would ayana even surrender to someone who annihilated her whole family
I can't take this anymore. It gets more complicated by the minute. What is happening? Who is the stalker and who is helping the mother? What is even going on? Why did the murders happened in the first place? I need answers like right now!
The teacher is the mothers helper and so far it’s revealed that he’s connected to somyeongs pasted (her brothers death) and she wants to figure out why he’s helping her mother with all of this.
Okay i know that much, haha i was trying to be more dramatic. The more serious questions are about the stalker and the reason behind the murders. We know that the mother is obsessed with her daughter because she looks exactly like her but yeah... thanks anyway!
Oh lol!! You’re welcome I didn’t know that you were just being dramatic lmao