Luca is not possessed (no one in this manhwa is possessed for that matter). Luca is a regressor. Luca made a wish on this thingy and he wished that everyone would be happy. That wish is what him travel back in time and that's why he acts so mature. Luca brought Judith to winterland with him bc he wanted to prevent her from dying. Judith is not possessed by anyone and she is the original Judith but she isn't aware of this yet. The memories she has are from her last life but she has always been Judith. In other words, og judith and current judith are the SAME (same soul & body). Judith never truly hated Luca and she didn't hate her sister. She loved her sister very much. (not me excusing her actions...i'm only explaining) She abused luca bc of her love for her sister. she at first blamed him for her death but she later blames winterland and ruin it (hence her trying to work with franz to try to destroy it). Luca is at first very eager to leave Judith an go with rudy (i'm not writing out his actual name) but he's later disappointed when he realizes that rudy doesn't love him. rudy is only protecting him out of a sense of duty and he then realizes that his aunt didn't actually hate him. She send him the last thing that she has of her sister (i think it was a portrait but i don't remember exactly). as you know judith dies and so does rudy (and rudy's family)...even though he overcomes all of the obstacles, he wishes everyone was happy (bc literally everyone died) and that leads to the regression. Like i said, he brought judith with him in an effort to protect her and prevent her death. He is trying to keep Judith and Rudy apart bc he doesn't want Judith to get hurt because he believes that Rudy is incapable of love.
Rudy loved judith even in the original timeline (plottwist of the century). When he was fighting off those assassins he thought about luca and how he only did this bc of a sense of duty and not out of love for luca. He then thinks about judith. He at first thought he hated her but he realizes that he doesn't hate her but in fact loves her. He fell in love with her the moment they met (love at first sight) and the same happened in this timeline (though he has yet to realize his feelings). His last thoughts before his death were of reuniting with Judith in hell.
Welp, that just made me wanna drop this lmao (￣∇￣")
Thank you for the spoilers this definitely explains a lot of what I was thinking
what about it made you wanna drop this? (it's hard for me convey my tone via writing so i'm not saying this in a mean way or anything i'm just curious which part made you wanna drop it)
The last sentence get me "His last thoughts before his death were of reuniting with Judith in hell." In hell Hahahahahaha lol lol lol
right i was laughing when i found out. he has no doubts that they're both going to hell
yw <33
omigod thank you <3
yw (づ￣ ³￣)づ
Idk about her, (not maybe wanna drop it but kinda ruined it for me) the love at first sight thing. I don’t believe that stuff at all and I really hate when they make characters fall in love with a first glance. It’s so unrealistic. Especially for someone as distant to people as him, too cheesy and cliche
Idkkkk lol I guess I just give up on stories where I know whats going to happen. I had my thoughts on Luca and turns out that my theory about him was correct. I'll stick a around for a while til they get to the end though.(づ￣ ³￣)づ
That too lol. I forgot about that
yeah i get that. I would've liked it better if he liked her bc he understood her feelings due to his childhood (or something along those lines ya know) but i rlly hate the love at first sight trope. imo their feelings for each other seemed to be really shallow. I remember he asked her what she loved about him and she said his face....i-.....that mixed in with the love at first sight thing just..ick. There was also this scene towards the end where Franz and Rudy were fighting and Franz shot Judith (right before Rudy shot and killed Franz) and then she fell into a coma. Rudy tried to commit suc!cide after that and everyone had to talk him out of it. She woke up 3 days later but idk their feelings just seem really shallow. I'm still gonna read this but some things are just hella disappointing
Noo.. don't drop it. There's still lots of plot twists for u hahaha.
I knew it!! I had a feeling luca had memories since there are hints like exm. Chapter 8 page 12, ch.9 pg.61, & ch.11 pg. 24 at the end possible foreshadowing??
IN HELL?? LMAOOOO WHAAATT
i mean he's self aware. He knows that him and judith have both done some questionable things (her more than him) but it's still really funny
Ok wow that was a major spoiler but it answered all of my questions, still gonna stick around tho cuz that sounds interesting
same. some parts disappointed me but it's interesting overall so i'm going to continue reading it.
Thank you! Now im more excited to read this!!
That just seems like story is very undeveloped. It seems like author got lazy with their relationship and feelings, so they did the most cliche into an extreme and called it a good love story. I love it changes a bit in webtoon
Can you give us some spoilers about the present time lines Franz?
what in the misunderstanding is this? now she thinks that he doesn't like her and she's sad :( and he thinks that she was interested in Franz. I'm such an impatient person that I can't wait for the misunderstandings to be solved.
The thing is, does he know that he likes her???? He looks so oblivious to his own feelings
i'm not sure if he's accepted his feelings for her or not but regardless he does like her. he's liked her since they first met (i'm not going any farther than that bc i don't want to spoil it for you).
SPOIL ME! SPOIL ME! I BEG YOU TO SPOIL ME! I CANNOT WAIT!!
I wrote this in a different topic and i'm too lazy to write it out again so just bear with the copy and pasting.
Luca is not possessed (no one in this manhwa is possessed for that matter). Luca is a regressor. Luca made a wish on this thingy and he wished that everyone would be happy. That wish is what him travel back in time and that's why he acts so mature. Luca brought Judith to winterland with him bc he wanted to prevent her from dying. Judith is not possessed by anyone and she is the original Judith but she isn't aware of this yet. The memories she has are from her last life but she has always been Judith. In other words, og judith and current judith are the SAME (same soul & body). Judith never truly hated Luca and she didn't hate her sister. She loved her sister very much. (not me excusing her actions...i'm only explaining) She abused luca bc of her love for her sister. she at first blamed him for her death but she later blames winterland and ruin it (hence her trying to work with franz to try to destroy it). Luca is at first very eager to leave Judith an go with rudy (i'm not writing out his actual name) but he's later disappointed when he realizes that rudy doesn't love him. rudy is only protecting him out of a sense of duty and he then realizes that his aunt didn't actually hate him. She send him the last thing that she has of her sister (i think it was a portrait but i don't remember exactly). as you know judith dies and so does rudy (and rudy's family)...even though he overcomes all of the obstacles, he wishes everyone was happy (bc literally everyone died) and that leads to the regression. Like i said, he brought judith with him in an effort to protect her and prevent her death. He is trying to keep Judith and Rudy apart bc he doesn't want Judith to get hurt because he believes that Rudy is incapable of love.
Rudy loved judith even in the original timeline (plottwist of the century). When he was fighting off those assassins he thought about luca and how he only did this bc of a sense of duty and not out of love for luca. He then thinks about judith. He at first thought he hated her but he realizes that he doesn't hate her but in fact loves her. He fell in love with her the moment they met (love at first sight) and the same happened in this timeline (though he has yet to realize his feelings). His last thoughts before his death were of reuniting with Judith in hell.
Towards the end there is a fight with rudy and franz (franz kidnaps judith) and right before rudy shoots and kills franz, franz shot judith and she went into a comma (for 3 days). When that happened, rudy tried to commit suic!de but the ppl around him stopped him. There was a scene where rudy asked judith what she loved about him to which she responded with his face. this is just my opinion but i wish their relationship/romance was a bit more than this bc it kinda seems really shallow...like you have the love at first sight, the i like your face, and then the impulsive suic!de attempt. I'm not saying you can't like someone's face but if someone you love asks what you love about them and the only thing you say is "your face"...i-...just what? I wish there was a bit more depth to their relationship but yeah.
Ooooooooooooo thanks! And about the shallow thing, I agree with you. It’s a pity they didn’t delve deeper into their feelings (very Romeo and Juliet, like the shallowest relationship of all time) ANYWAYS! Thanks again for sharing
It has a great plot and i love the concept...if only they didn't make their relationship like that, it could've been so much better. I had the same thought about their relationship having very much romeo and juliet energy...like very shallow, immature, and impulsive.
and yw <33
I guess it so surprising because none of them strikes me as the impulsive type? Like young lover would, but oh well, they’ll get to know each other better after marriage
Next chapter is about to SLAP!! cassian is back, cassian's dad is hot, jeremy is here
for those wondering who the ML is...it's the blue haired guy
The guard? Ray?
the prince that's always in bed. the one she sneaks off to see. (other's might describe his hair as mint but light blue, mint, blue...same difference)
Oh, ok, I did thought of him at first but I also saw him described as mint colored for hair >.< thank you!
Yes idk why many say blue when it isnt remotely blue, mint hair sounds better
it's mint blue and i don't normally use mint when describing the shade of something so i'm more comfortable saying blue. plus there aren't other ml's with blue hair
Yeah, mint blue is probably the correct term to describe that hair color
I asked about Ray because he has a blakish dark blue hair color (kinda) which is why I was confused >.< (just because I usually think of the darker shades)
for me ray has black hair. when i think of dark blue hair, i think of like raphael from "the villainess is a marionette."
With colors it's actually really hard since there are sooo many shades (for me it's both dark blue but obviusly with different intensity) (づ￣ ³￣)づ
Looks like the manhwa gave Ray black hair because I see no hint of dark blue at all, they really changed the colors from how their described in the novel
I take that back, I confused Ray with another character from another manhwa, don't know why (maybe I because I read them one after another)
So my fault, sorry, he has black hair (〜￣△￣)〜
I really hate FL that act like this. At first her motives for what she did made sense because she didn't want her sister to die but now why is she acting like this. She doesn't want to change the course of the story but he already likes her and she likes him. How are you going to act like this over a relationship that hasn't even happened and won't happen? She's using excessive methods to achieve a goal without a just motive. Running away makes literally no sense and the amount of times she's done it too...i-
She's not at the point where she likes him openly and her feelings don't match his. He literally kidnapped her, of course she's trying to get away. I think Amy and her sister also have a backstop where they have to run to survive. She also has a point in saying they were only together for a little while and they have been separated for a lot longer.
bitch
Amy and Diana are run away nobles, the reason they were in the forest of night was because they were hiding.
I know, I think there will be a backstory flashback to see why they're fallen nobility soon, probably to reveal why she keeps running away. Can't wait to see them get together though, probably won't happen for a while lol
My criticism falls more towards the author than the character...however it does cause me irritation towards the character. Her feeling will never be on the same level as his because he is traumatized and she became his comfort. Because of that, his feelings will always be greater than her feelings towards him. If her main reasoning was her and her sister's situation, that would make more sense...BUT it's clear that it's not. Her main reason is that she wants him to be happy and she believes that he can only find happiness if he's with serena (forgive me if i spelled it wrong), she breaks the spell, and marries serena. She believes that because of the novel and disregards how he actually feels due to the changes that were made from the novel. On top of all that, she misses him when she's not with him, but then runs away (with excessive brute force towards others) whenever she's with him. It's lazy writing imo. There are a ton of reasons the author could've had her run away and had it make more sense. I've seen some authors do it in other work and it just gets redundant and annoying because the motive doesn't match the actions. The author could've used a much stronger motivation (that would make sense) in order for it to not seem redundant that she keeps doing this. It's like this annoying game of cat and mouse that's been going on for way longer than it should've. Also what he did is 100% wrong and I'm not saying that what he did was okay. It's clear that he hasn't healed from his trauma (his parents & the prince...then getting attached to her bc of the affection she showed him...and then getting abandoned again) and her leaving only made it worse. It would've been nice if there was more communication before she left and overall been given a better reasoning for running bc it's honestly just her obsessing with the original plot.
[ENDGAME SPOILER]
it is a reverse harem ending so she won't pick one guy. She becomes the emperor. Feel free to ask me any questions regarding spoilers. For those that don't know there are 7 male lead's (although 1 isn't including in the ending).
- Nadricka
- Eckolt (loyal black haired guy...also a virgin)
- Robia (librarian guy with blonde hair)
- Kairos (he's the purple haired guy we saw that she was supposed to meet with. crown prince from another empire)
- God (we meet him after she dies but he disappears after she goes back to the time period she was in)
- Seeger (the knight guy that's tan and super ripped lol)
- Ettsen (red headed bitch...sorry i can't forgive that bastard for the way he treated our fl)
^^ those are the male leads (if u don't know who nadricka is...reread the story im sorry lmao)
will FL gonna sleep with the virgin guy? lol this is such a weird question sorry
and I been reading spoiler myself but I'm confused about the time-traveling thing can you explain? thank you
What happens to Yuriel?
she gets shot in the heart with an arrow by eckolt (FL okays this btw)
yes she will. She sleeps with all of the ML's with the exception of God bc he was only there for like short duration and then disappeared without any mention. She's already slept with Nadricka. After that she will sleep with Robia, and then with Sieger/Seeger, and then with Ecklot, and then with Karios. She also sleeps with Ettsen but that wasn't until the 7th volume of the novel (aka the end). Technically she already slept with Ettsen in the first chapter but we didn't really see that bc it was more of an implied thing (it was explicitly said so it's not implied but you get my point).
what happens to the previous emperor?(her older brother i think)
he dies
was it because he was killed or an illness?
is there any translations of the volume or nah
HOLY COW THERES MORE MLS?! we love to see it
I’m glad she gets them all but also… I wish there was a group activity ʅ（◞‿◟）ʃ
i'm sorry to disappoint you but i don't remember how he died
the more the merrier!!...as long as they aren't as annoying as ettsen
i would love to see that too but knowing how possessive they are of her...i don't think group activity would be v effective
this is the only translation i could find of it but it only has 4 chapters of volume 1. the last update was 2 days ago so there could be more in the future.
https://www.novelupdates.com/series/it-seems-like-i-fell-into-a-reverse-harem-game/
Omg ikr ettsen is a mess. He should appreciate the authors recent glow up of him and quit being a little bitch haha.
I know Y-Y honestly. It’s so cute but sigh wishes haha
BIG NEWS!! I just checked the raws and season 2 is HERE OMG OMG OMG!! It's been a long wait but it's finally here
[NOT MY SPOILERS]
KHALID SPOILERS
"first, the kingdom that they were working to protect was already rotten to its core but MC was completely oblivious to it because Khalid fell in love with her "innocent" and "naiveness" so he prevented her from learning about the truth. But eventually, she found out after being captured by the green haired ML. She found out that the orders that she carried hurt a lot of people and wanted to repent so she decided to resign from her position and take the blame for her actions. Khalid knows that the kingdom is going to fall so he acts as a double agent for the current country that he works for. Since the kingdom was going to fall, the things she did would come to light and she would be forever branded as an evil person and would basically have to live in shame for the rest of her life (if they let her live). So he decided to kill her to try to maintain her "pure" and "righteous" reputation and have her die as a hero rather than a villain.
but this man had the audacity to kill her, cut off her head and show the king of the current kingdom to prove his loyalty. Then keep the rest of her corpse in his home because he loves her???? sick." [END SPOILER]
dude that's just creepy. to think that he's keeping her (headless) corpse in his house....at least i know i won't be getting second lead syndrome.
My problem with Khalid is that he completely ignored the MC's wishes. She was ready to take the fall but he decided it would be better to kill her then turn her body into his trophy because only his needs and wants are justifiable.
Apparently she said to the ML that she kinda wanted to die when she found out about everything but then Khalid took that and...killed her. Plus chopping her head off and then presenting it to the king...like did she really mean that little to you. Also when the killing were happening, he purposely tried to blame it on Liam despite knowing it wasn't him. It's clear that her other subordinates are still upset about her murder and not upset about the war. They aren't rebelling against the king but they're trying to avenge their commander.
The one good thing about him is the fact that I won't be getting second lead syndrome with this yandere ass mf
Kids he can't be the second ML he is clearly the villain. Like Wishtrash, or Soveshu. He is like the villainess in an otome game.
he's not the villain. i've read spoilers and he isn't. after she finds out about the truth of what happens she gives up on her plan for revenge against him. She is currently missing some memories that her brain purposely forgot because they were too painful and those memories have to do with khalid, her death, the ml, an her home country.
I see...still a villain in my brain but it is for the best she give up on revenge. Want her to have a nice second life. Though the other 2 I mentioned aren't villains either they are just shitty men who didn't deserve the amazing FL.
Now knowing that the story was written that way does make it a little bit cliche since the fact is that she gives up on her revenge because of reasons. After all, it makes it look like she just gave the finger to her true comrades' loyalty to her.
yeah i get that. after regaining her repressed memories and giving up on revenge, she begins to live her life as [*insert the name of the FL that i totally forgot*]. I don't know which manhwa the first guy you mentioned is from but yeah sovieshit ain't shit (hehe see what i did there).
i'm conflicted on my feelings towards her giving up on her revenge. On the one hand I get it because her country was the one in the wrong and she was just so oblivious to it (bc of that damned khalid who wanted to keep her "innocence" + the others that kept it from her). It's like her whole life was a lie. hating this other empire was all for nothing bc in the end, she was the one on the wrong side. after finding out she goes into despair (hence why they became repressed memories) and says that she wants to die (idk if she actually meant it or not though). On the other hand I wish she had reaped her revenge on khalid and khalid alone bc what he did is just wtf. keeping her body and also betraying his fellow troops. to this day he is still betraying them (the prime example being the situation with liam). I'm not upset at this happening but at the same time I am upset.
Nope I totally get that! You make tons of sense!
Yep, I want terrible things to happen to him but not necessarily done by our MC.
He could have just told her the truth . It would have been biyter but better for her if she knew what was going on with her kingdom. She was to take blame , responsibility and consequences for her own actions no matter what the result is . It would have been better for her to atleast die with knowing the truth instead of betrayed and served as a trophy. But no he had to make "her decisions" and pull the must protect uwu shit by stabbing her
Exaaaaaaaaaaccccttttlllyyyyyy! Sorry for the long drawn out word but I can't express just how much I agree with you here.
What the fuck
Wait I thought he was just some random asshole but he's a fucking CREEP ?!
Fr I didn't even start the story yet but that mf already make my blood boil.
I hope that she won't be nice to him or even pity him.
Glad you agreee (︶︿︶) fuck Khalid
I think my new username should be FUCastorandKhalid!
This isn't me shipping them but i want to see more of the red head guy. He seems like he'd be a fun and interesting character and it'd be interesting to see him and lesian as friends.
i honestly want to at least pull his beatiful hair like the harsh words she spoke r badass and mean he deserved it BUT LIKE MAYBE MORE???PULL HIS HAIR HE NAUGHTY AF
pls why do i feel like he'd like that and be even more interested in her if she did that
I'm currently in process of reading the novel and I've realized that this story is actually really short. I've read 61% of the entire novel and I'm at the manhwa equivalent of chapter 9 (towards the end up chapter 9. he finished telling her about his trauma and they're holding hands but they aren't at the villa yet). Chapter 12 is 78% of the novel (i'm talking about by the end of chapter 12 we've read 78% of the novel...not the beginning). I'm kinda sad that it's short but i really like this manhwa/novel so i'll just keep rereading it.
there’s an english translation for the novel? i couldn’t find it
It is english translated? Can I ask the link where I can read it?
i got this from someone else but i had to use a file converter after downloading it so that i could actually read it. you can just look up a file converter. I converted it to a pdf. The person who posted this said that they got it off a facebook grp but it was posted privately.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EoTFQtTbZL3I00SI2PGP_QhEQUxgEw-1/view
Thank you
yw <33
tytyty (づ￣ ³￣)づ
Thank you so much
cairnen get your mind out of the gutter