Lavender-Rose May 29, 2018 1:15 am

I’ve noticed that a lot of people are comparing these two mangas and I’ve come to a pretty sudden realization about why I like Killing Stalking but not this.
Killing Stalking is a hard read for sure but Hogu Hagyeongsu was just constant misery for nothing but misery’s sake. Kyung-soo also starts the story in a fairly okay place. He’s not over what happened to him but he’s healing which just makes what happens to him later on even more unbearable. The audience wants Kyung-soo to be happy and speaking from personal experience, I stopped reading simply because I hated watching him suffer for seemingly no reason. Kyung-soo never really felt like he had agency or freedom and to some extent I believe we all knew who he’d end up with.
The protagonist in Killing Stalking basically starts at rock bottom. He’s a twenty-something adult with no friends who’s only hobby is stalking someone he’s never even spoke to. The situation he ended up in was no doubt horrible but it was a situation he got himself into. The audience is also torn on whether or not they want Bum to escape because really, what is there for him to go back to? His uncle?
I also think this story having multiple Love interests really does not work to its advantage. I think Sangwoo is tolerable in Killing Stalking both because his actions are never justified and because we’re never given a better alternative.
In short Hogu Hagyeongsu is basically misery porn. Kyung-soo and by extension, the audience, are almost never given a break. The fact that Kyung-soo ends up with his rapist and everything is not really forgiven but drastically downplayed is another huge slap in the face.

Lavender-Rose May 28, 2018 3:31 am

There’s such a weird tonal dissonance going on with this manga. The art-style and pacing is so light-hearted and cute but the actual subject matter of this story is about as dark as it can get.
Every time I’m starting to enjoy the fluffier aspects of this manga I am reminded that the main character is literally a teenaged boy who was tricked into becoming a sexdroid and lost his human rights as a result. It creates a weird feeling of emotional whiplash that I can’t quite tell if I enjoy.
I am very interested to see where it goes.

Lavender-Rose May 28, 2018 2:55 am

It’s been too long since I’ve read anything that had a non-traditionally attractive main character. I love hotties as much as the next person but I think we can all agree that it’s more realistic when not everyone in a story looks like a super model.

    LeLepop May 28, 2018 5:34 am

    Sorry my elephant fingers pressed the wrong button it was supposed to be a like ⁄(⁄ ⁄·⁄ω⁄·⁄ ⁄)⁄

Lavender-Rose May 27, 2018 3:26 am

You know how some manga will get extras that are posted after the main story is complete? What if this updates and it’s a flash forward to Goura and Iori even further in the future. What if the extra actually shows Goura dying before Iori since it’s stated that half-beasts generally have shorter life spans.
I don’t know if this will happen but it was mentioned so it’s possible.

Lavender-Rose May 27, 2018 3:24 am

You know how some manga will get extras that are posted after the main story is complete? What if this updates and it’s a flash forward to Goura and Iori even further in the future. What if the extra actually shows Goura dying before Iori since it’s stated that half-beasts generally have shorter life spans.
I don’t know if this will happen but it was mentioned so it’s possible.

Lavender-Rose May 26, 2018 10:42 pm

I bet you that Kaneo’s half-brother is in love with Oikawa. He’s probably gonna make lie even harder for Kaneo when he finds out that Oikawa’s been hanging around him.
I bet Oikawa feels like Kaneo “stole” his dad from him or something stupid like that. There’s going to be a line where he’s like “You always steal everything from me!” And then he’s gonna punch Kaneo. I just know it.

    Mandarine May 27, 2018 9:17 am

    "There’s going to be a line where he’s like “You always steal everything from me!” And then he’s gonna punch Kaneo." That scenario had me laughing out loud! I can totally see it happen...
    Evil half brother is evil.

    Nocturne August 28, 2018 6:09 pm

    OMG I KNOW RIGHT LOL

Lavender-Rose May 26, 2018 3:36 am

I think people are forgetting that Kou is literally only treating Yukinori like this. It’s not that he’s hard to please or super strict, he simply has something against Yukinori and is making life difficult for him on purpose.
Like I get that some bosses might be hard on newbies in order to get them to improve but there’s nothing constructive about what Kou’s doing. He dislikes Yukinori and doesn’t like that he’s dating his brother so he’s being a dick.
We also have Maki as a point of comparison. He was hard on Yukinori too at first but he never reached the level of genuine malice that’s Kou has.

Lavender-Rose May 26, 2018 2:38 am

Seriously, what he did bordered on harassment and abuse of authority. He just kept on rejecting Yukinori’s blueprint while giving absolutely no feedback.
He has no professionalism whatsoever and is allowing his personal feelings to influence his work relationships and is unfairly targeting Yukinori due to a personal vendetta.
Also, what a pretentious fuckhead. He’s known Yukinori for like five days and he already thinks that he knows everything about him. Hes such a judgemental person.
I hope his brother talks some sense into him.
I feel really bad for Yukinori. Everyone expects him to be exactly like his Grandfather even though he’s a completely different person.

    Lavender-Rose May 26, 2018 2:39 am

    *father not grandfather

    Koro_Sensei May 26, 2018 2:57 am

    Nah. It's not harassment. Sometimes when you're working , you'll experience some superiors like that, telling you it's wrong but won't ahow you what. If you're working and you haven't experienced it up to this point, boii. You're lucky.

    Lavender-Rose May 26, 2018 3:26 am
    Nah. It's not harassment. Sometimes when you're working , you'll experience some superiors like that, telling you it's wrong but won't ahow you what. If you're working and you haven't experienced it up to this ... Koro_Sensei

    I know. I said it bordered on harassment. Like as in that it was shitty and unproffessional but not severe enough for any complaints to be taken seriously.
    Also I was more or less talking about his attitude in general.

    Anonymous May 26, 2018 4:15 pm
    Nah. It's not harassment. Sometimes when you're working , you'll experience some superiors like that, telling you it's wrong but won't ahow you what. If you're working and you haven't experienced it up to this ... Koro_Sensei

    But just because it happens frequently doesn't make it a right/nice thing to do...

Lavender-Rose May 25, 2018 4:45 pm

I’ve been avoiding this for a long time since frankly the art is not to my taste and I heard it’s kind of rapey but I eventually started reading this and...
Why does the Uke look like he’s ten? Like I know he’s an adult but he looks like an elementary schooler and it’s really distracting.

    Anonymous June 10, 2018 12:29 pm

    it's shota disguised as yaoi, so PEDO material. I would stay away if I were you

    Rin August 14, 2018 1:23 am
    it's shota disguised as yaoi, so PEDO material. I would stay away if I were you @Anonymous

    No its not , the uke is a university student and he's 18 , its clearly adult relathionship and there is no pedo here

Lavender-Rose May 24, 2018 10:21 pm

His heart is in the right place and all but I feel like his attempts to set the two up are going to go very wrong and possibly cause an annoying misunderstanding that goes on for like ten chapters.
I hope I’m wrong but Chanyoung feels like a character that’s gonna cause a lot of accidental drama.

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.