StoryofMinglan February 8, 2024 1:14 pm

There’s no chapter this week as well. Next ch will be February 15th.

    amber February 8, 2024 1:20 pm

    is it on hiatus??

    StoryofMinglan February 8, 2024 1:21 pm
    is it on hiatus?? amber

    They took a two-week break for some reason. Story is shifting to another arc so perhaps they need to prepare more.

    amber February 9, 2024 11:11 pm
    They took a two-week break for some reason. Story is shifting to another arc so perhaps they need to prepare more. StoryofMinglan

    ah okay thanks for explaining

    Yjk x Kdj February 10, 2024 10:19 am
    They took a two-week break for some reason. Story is shifting to another arc so perhaps they need to prepare more. StoryofMinglan

    Is it anywhere near the end?

    StoryofMinglan February 10, 2024 10:59 am
    Is it anywhere near the end? Yjk x Kdj

    No. Far from it. There is a lot more to Carcel and Ines’s story. A lot of revelations about the previous timeline and about who Carcel truly is. Nothing is meets the eyes. Then there’s the crown prince that the manhwa has treated like he’s a side character. He is not. He is present in every single timeline. So, all of that needs to be addressed.

    StoryofMinglan February 10, 2024 11:03 am
    Is it anywhere near the end? Yjk x Kdj

    Well, I should clarify that crown prince is a side character like most characters in this story but he’s an important one. Ines and Carcel are truly the main characters since the story is all about them and is told from their perspective. It literally switches between Ines and Carcel’s pov.

    Yjk x Kdj February 10, 2024 11:14 am
    No. Far from it. There is a lot more to Carcel and Ines’s story. A lot of revelations about the previous timeline and about who Carcel truly is. Nothing is meets the eyes. Then there’s the crown prince that... StoryofMinglan

StoryofMinglan February 1, 2024 1:12 pm

A reminder that there’s no chapter this week.

StoryofMinglan January 19, 2024 1:44 pm

Unfortunately those rumors will lead to near deadly consequences for Cárcel. If only he knew but I don’t think he would’ve backed down anyway. After all, he’s a military man and capable of navigating the dangers of life and death.

    Sumichan January 19, 2024 3:52 pm

    what do you meaaan pls spoil me!
    Also do you know if carcel regains his memories of his past lives?

    StoryofMinglan January 19, 2024 4:24 pm
    what do you meaaan pls spoil me!Also do you know if carcel regains his memories of his past lives? Sumichan

    Spoilers ahead.











    The rumors will trigger the crown prince to send assassins after Carcel to kill him. The first assassins appear at his hunting trip with Ines but Ines doesn’t find out until much later. The second attempt occurs in his bedroom when Ines is in the capital city. He was sleeping in bed when the assassin appeared in his room. Fortunately he ended up with a bullet graze but there was blood in the bedroom to the point they had to change the carpet . The assassination attempt is what triggers Carcel’s memories of the past lives. At first it’s vague memories of the two men who were in Ines past.

    Sumichan January 20, 2024 8:52 am

    Thanksss I appreciate you!! ٩(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)۶

    I am not Michael Jackson January 27, 2024 2:21 pm
    Spoilers ahead. The rumors will trigger the crown prince to send assassins after Carcel to kill him. The first assassins appear at his hunting trip with Ines but Ines doesn’t find out until much later. The se... StoryofMinglan

    What about that guy.. the guy Ines was married to in her second life.. does he remember the past as well??

    StoryofMinglan January 27, 2024 2:38 pm
    What about that guy.. the guy Ines was married to in her second life.. does he remember the past as well?? I am not Michael Jackson

    Spoilers






    Yes, he remembers. That’s why he left behind the fake pendant that almost killed Ines. He only remembers because in the after life he asked the apostle of resurrection to let him have memories in this life to avoid Ines so he wouldn’t hurt her. He never kept to his promise because he still went and left the pendent that almost killed her (if Carcel hadn’t found her in time) and it’s the apostle of resurrection who had to stop him from interfering with Ines because this is Ines last chance to follow her fate and find true and lasting happiness.

    I am not Michael Jackson January 27, 2024 2:48 pm
    SpoilersYes, he remembers. That’s why he left behind the fake pendant that almost killed Ines. He only remembers because in the after life he asked the apostle of resurrection to let him have memories in this... StoryofMinglan

    I feel so bad for all of them.. i hope they all get the happiness they deserve.. but srsly thank you soo much .

    StoryofMinglan January 27, 2024 2:50 pm
    I feel so bad for all of them.. i hope they all get the happiness they deserve.. but srsly thank you soo much . I am not Michael Jackson

    If it helps, everyone has their own fated partner. Chances are he will meet the one he belongs with.

    StoryofMinglan January 27, 2024 2:54 pm
    I feel so bad for all of them.. i hope they all get the happiness they deserve.. but srsly thank you soo much . I am not Michael Jackson

    Also, remember Carcel lived two timelines with unrequited love for Ines. If he could do it and still be happy for Ines, all the other men who claim to love her should do the same. There is no one, I mean, absolutely no one in this story who loves Ines more than Carcel. His love is that great and he has the most beautiful and romantic lines and his actions prove in spades that he loves Ines much, much, much more than anyone. That’s why he’s the male lead.

    I am not Michael Jackson January 27, 2024 8:39 pm
    Also, remember Carcel lived two timelines with unrequited love for Ines. If he could do it and still be happy for Ines, all the other men who claim to love her should do the same. There is no one, I mean, absol... StoryofMinglan

    I love the way you put things. Yes, absolutely.. I agree with each and every word.

StoryofMinglan May 15, 2025 1:04 am

If nothing else, I’m glad the manhwa finally showed a genuine part of Ines’s character in her violent slapping. Ines is actually a woman who would beat up her spouse with that hot-blooded temper of Perez. She will beat up Carcel in a future chapter. lol Well, he allows it but she knows how to throw punches and slaps. She even broke Oscar’s body part before in the crown princess timeline. Perez people are hot-blooded and believes in revenge paid back tenfold.

StoryofMinglan May 15, 2025 1:52 am

Surprised no one wondered about that ending of her shouting out Cárcel’s name. Raul also observed that she’s pale. It’s just a cold but Ines is reacting like it’s a graver sickness.

StoryofMinglan December 17, 2023 2:36 am

There won’t be a chapter next week. The next chapter release is the last week of the year.

StoryofMinglan December 7, 2023 10:34 am

The manhwa adaptation hasn’t done a good job of explaining how things started between Ines and the men she previously chose. I see some act as though Ines loved only one man. Wrong. Ines fell for Emiliano after they were fugitives together and he was very kind to her. He treated her better than Oscar. One thing that Ines likes is guys who are kind to her. The reason she fell for Oscar is because he treated her nice and special at first. She loved Oscar during their engagement and their first years of marriage. They were married for 10 years so I would say maybe the first five or so were good years. Ines never denies this fact. She said it in ch 9 and says again later in the story.

As to Emiliano, she woke up/regressed wanting to love someone after Oscar treated her so terribly. Ines will always admit she chose love first then added the man to the equation. So, it didn’t even have to be Emiliano. It could have been just another random nice guy and she would have fallen for him. Ines also idolizes her life with Emiliano because it’s a stark contrast to her life with Oscar and Emiliano practically worshipped her (which shows they weren’t equal like partners should be). The jewelry store shop keeper hinted at this too when he finally met Ines and wasn’t as impressed with Ines’s beauty like he was told by the person who left the pendant that almost killed her.

With Carcel, she had firm walls erected against him She never intended to love him and she always tries to deny anything she feels for him. However, wouldn’t it be something that despite her walls and all the ways she talks herself out of staying with him that her heart loves him even if her mind doesn’t want to? It would be ultimate proof that she fell for him in spite of all her schemes and inspite of herself. It would also mean she met he first man she never intended to love but couldn’t help loving.

As to all three men, Carcel is by far the most suited for her. She has the most in common with him, they are equal in status and quite frankly, they get along swimmingly. The manhwa hasn’t even done justice to the relationship that is shown between Ines and Carcel since they began their marriage. All the times Ines has laughed, all the times they bicker, all the times they complement each other, etc. Hopefully the manhwa will now begin to show it as they go into the next stage of the story.

Also, if readers are basing Ines being with a guy because of a kid, then they’re building their foundation on sand because story will reveal a hidden fact about Ines’s past that makes that point moot.

    StoryofMinglan December 7, 2023 10:38 am

    Correction: she woke up/regressed wanting love from someone.

    snapplecider December 7, 2023 9:39 pm

    People who keep thinking Emiliano was the only one she love bc of the kid are just ignorant when she had 2 kids with Carcel in the rl 1st and Carcel was the 1st. They call Emiliano her 1st love but it's really Carcel too

    StoryofMinglan December 7, 2023 11:15 pm
    People who keep thinking Emiliano was the only one she love bc of the kid are just ignorant when she had 2 kids with Carcel in the rl 1st and Carcel was the 1st. They call Emiliano her 1st love but it's really ... snapplecider

    They think that because manhwa obscure the truth. Most people who think this way believes that Ines met Emiliano and fell for him. They don’t know she saw him, liked his face and decided to use him to runaway from marriage with Oscar. At least when manhwa had her sitting on him back in ep11, they don’t even realize how unmoved her face looked at first and then he started to cry, that’s when she looked surprised. She was dubconning a complete stranger whom she barely knew anything about so that she can use him for her goal.

    rei December 9, 2023 2:45 am

    very well written

    snapplecider December 9, 2023 6:33 am
    They think that because manhwa obscure the truth. Most people who think this way believes that Ines met Emiliano and fell for him. They don’t know she saw him, liked his face and decided to use him to runaway... StoryofMinglan

    Yeah, she was sitting on him emotionless. That's her loving him LOL

    rBvSUB9e4etH May 15, 2025 12:29 am
    People who keep thinking Emiliano was the only one she love bc of the kid are just ignorant when she had 2 kids with Carcel in the rl 1st and Carcel was the 1st. They call Emiliano her 1st love but it's really ... snapplecider

    All of this isn't real. These fairy tale characters. They don't exist. The level of hatred you have for a whatpad character, for something that doesn't exist, it's hilarious. You're sad

    snapplecider May 15, 2025 1:25 am
    All of this isn't real. These fairy tale characters. They don't exist. The level of hatred you have for a whatpad character, for something that doesn't exist, it's hilarious. You're sad rBvSUB9e4etH

    I don't even hate Emiliano. I don't like the rl ppl who think he's so important in the story when he's not.

    StoryofMinglan May 15, 2025 1:30 am
    I don't even hate Emiliano. I don't like the rl ppl who think he's so important in the story when he's not. snapplecider

    You’re mistaking this person as a sane person. He isn’t.

StoryofMinglan December 2, 2023 9:03 am

According to Inés, Cárcel was criticized for not being married in the CP TL. So BOTH noble men and women were expected to marry.

Novel excerpt:

Of course, if she thought about it a little more, she didn't even know that 'original' Cárcel Escalate very well. A playboy with many followers. A man who avoided duty and marriage.
Words that could've been used to devalue him were not as varied then and now. Everyone only sees the loudest aspect of others.

Not getting married was considered a major flaw, regardless of gender, and he, who was considered to be the most handsome man in the world beyond borders, was too conspicuous wherever he was.

When Cárcel did one thing, ten stories were created the next day.

    Hopeless_shipper December 2, 2023 10:46 am

    I mean... yeah?

    Otherwise who would they have expected the women to marry? Each other?

    snapplecider December 2, 2023 9:14 pm
    I mean... yeah?Otherwise who would they have expected the women to marry? Each other? Hopeless_shipper

    It's bc some people keep bringing up misogyny as an excuse as if only women got to marry so Ines got to choose someone just bc she's a woman but society also expects Carcel to marry when he didn't want to.

    rBvSUB9e4etH May 15, 2025 12:27 am
    It's bc some people keep bringing up misogyny as an excuse as if only women got to marry so Ines got to choose someone just bc she's a woman but society also expects Carcel to marry when he didn't want to. snapplecider

    And so what? You can choose to not go to these websites and have some peace. Yet you choose to go to here and not only that, you harass people and use multiple alts.

    Do you realize how pathetic that is? How pathetic you are?

    snapplecider May 15, 2025 1:26 am
    And so what? You can choose to not go to these websites and have some peace. Yet you choose to go to here and not only that, you harass people and use multiple alts.Do you realize how pathetic that is? How path... rBvSUB9e4etH

    This is my only acct so idk what you're even talking about. You're the one with multiple alts so doesn't that show how pathetic YOU are

    Hopeless_shipper May 15, 2025 2:56 am

    What's going on I don't even know what my OWN comment is talking about let alone you guys

    StoryofMinglan May 15, 2025 3:14 am
    What's going on I don't even know what my OWN comment is talking about let alone you guys Hopeless_shipper

    There is this guy who is posting psychotic rants on old and new threads. Please disregard his updates and go in peace.

StoryofMinglan May 15, 2025 1:53 am

I see all these posts trying to justify everything Inés does by her past “trauma”. Does Inés even think like you? No, she doesn’t. Inés has pretty much moved on from her past with Oscar. She even says a little later that her past with Oscar is like reading a book because the feelings about that life are so distant. Even in this dream, what the manhwa doesn’t tell the reader is that Inés Escalante was watching Inés Valenza as an observer. She even acted as though that life had nothing to do with her current self.

Furthermore, Inés needs to acknowledge when she’s wrong in order to change. Fortunately she’s not like people who think she’s always right. Since she’s not like that, she will get character development and become a self that she can love and anyone who wants the best for her would look forward to her learning to love herself. Right now she cannot love herself as she is and that’s why she has said before that Carcel deserves better.

StoryofMinglan November 25, 2023 7:31 pm

In manhwa episode 10, Inés talks about her choice of Oscar. Either readers are too busy watching the pictures or they only read one thing is the ch because Ines states that she loved Oscar and chose him herself. I suggest people re-read it before claiming Ines didn’t choose him.

This is copied and pasted directly from the manhwa pages in ch 10:

SHE COULDN'T TELL WHETHER SHE HAD DONE IT ALL TO BECOME ThE PERFECT WOMAN FOR THE CROWN PRINCE.. .OR IF SHE HAD SIMPLY USED HIM TO ACHIEVE HER PERFECT LIFE.

BUT SHE DID LOVE HIM. SHE LOVED HIM THOUGH IT HAD ONLY BEEN A FEW YEARS, AND EVEN THOUGH HE HAD MADE HER FALL FOR HIS DESPICABLE LIES, AND EVEN IF HER REASONS HAD BEEN VAIN AND IT WAS ACTUALLY THE REPUTATION AND STATUS THAT SHE LOVED...

    StoryofMinglan November 25, 2023 7:55 pm

    Here is more and it’s ep 9 not ep 10. Inés talk about her dream of becoming Oscar’s wife.

    AND MY NAIVETE AT AGE 16....WHEN I DREAMT OF BECOMING OSCAR'S WIFE..

    Noelle__ November 26, 2023 2:12 am
    Here is more and it’s ep 9 not ep 10. Inés talk about her dream of becoming Oscar’s wife. AND MY NAIVETE AT AGE 16....WHEN I DREAMT OF BECOMING OSCAR'S WIFE.. StoryofMinglan

    She was 16 and dreamt of a perfect life with him. She loved him until he showed her his true colours and when it became too much she took her life. After going through that hell if you notice in subsequent lifetimes she tries her best not to make the same mistake of going back to him.

    Noelle__ November 26, 2023 2:15 am
    She was 16 and dreamt of a perfect life with him. She loved him until he showed her his true colours and when it became too much she took her life. After going through that hell if you notice in subsequent life... Noelle__

    It’s such a sad story chile. But you’re right. She did choose him at first

    StoryofMinglan November 26, 2023 2:22 am
    It’s such a sad story chile. But you’re right. She did choose him at first Noelle__

    That’s the point I was making since comments here keep saying she didn’t choose him. She even admits she did love him in the early years of her marriage. She always chooses the men in her life herself. Nobody else makes the decision for her. That’s why she said in another manhwa chapter that she has terrible taste in men. Some even say she didn’t choose Carcel when there is a manhwa panel showing her pointing her finger at him. She later gloats to Maria in another ch that she chose Carcel so he’s her husband and not the other way around because she chose Carcel first. He didn’t choose her.

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.