
Ugh, Saegye, why are you so whipped omg, welp I truthfully don't like it since Jinsol still hasn't even said he even likes Saegye, he hasn't confirmed shit and says "wait for me to love you,~~," "if I end up loving you I can try having an ordinary relationship~~~~," "I'll stay with you for ambiguous reasons maybe related to my guilt for betraying you or maybe idk I'm in love with you and I always have but I am in deep denial about it who knows but maybe probably not because I haven't said shit~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~," this just means he is living for Saegye, he doesn't really love him but he doesn't really have anything to do so he's like why not stay together with that one dude who I deeply betrayed and may like but I am in complete denial about for some godforsaken reason, also I feel greatly indebted to you for that betrayal I was talking about hahahahahahaha. I don't think he is in denial though, I feel like they are just using each other, Saegye is using him to keep that feeling that made him feel alive inside him and Jinsol is using him for the reason that Saegye kind of represents hope because the dude isn't saying shit about love and he is taking an opportunity to stay with a person who loves him despite all the shit he has pulled meaning he kind of feels secure because it feels like anymore shit he pulls Saegye will stay with him unconditionally because Saegye loves the feeling of being in love. ugh why am I such a salty human, I guess if this is what Saegye chose then so be it, idk anymore, this comment of mine doesn't mean that I don't love the story though, the story is a masterpiece!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I mean that’s what annoys me a lot in this genre. It’s perfectly fine to write a story where the couple introduced don’t fall in love. But for some reason there always needs to be a happily ever after doesn’t matter the circumstances be it rape, violence, blackmail, murder, abuse etc.you don’t feel any “love” between these two characters, just more or less settling. they’re not “in love”, but there is unresolved emotions. Honestly if the author had made their relationship more ambiguous that would have fit more properly with the plot itself at this point. Authors should listen to what the characters are saying to them not just creating the story to be to the expectations of its readers. That’s the mark of a really good writer, making your readers feel the realness of your world building and characters.

Right, if they made it more ambiguous it would make more sense however them getting together is not completely out of the realm of possibility, people do make decisions other people don't understand for their own reasons, it looks like each Jinsol and Saegye do have their own reason to get together but its just irritating to me that despite everything that happened between them they still choose to do that, like Saegye man, you are always getting the short end of the stick, they both are getting something out of the relationship, basically they are both benefiting from this for their own selfish reason, ultimately I don't think it is going to end up as a healthy relationship but I could be wrong

But the guy can only lie. So he can’t say “I love you” even if he wants to.
You can argue that he could have said something like “I don’t love you” and Saegye will get it, but that’s kinda anticlimactic (lol).
Jokes aside, I do agree with you that Jinsol’s ambiguous proposal must be a result of the guilts he feels towards Saegye and the deep, deep denial that he had forced himself to believe while his feelings for Saegye were growing (because he needed to be able to lie that he loved Saegye). The situation they are in at the moment probably doesn’t allow space for a passionate confession. There’s no switch to flick over immediately. There’s still awkwardness between those two. I just hope they will find peace with time.

Can someone just sum up the complicated relationship between Sumin and Seju???? Pleeeeaseeeee??? Thanks hehehe

My opinion on Sumin & Seju love story (LONG ASS ESSAY) :
First love that ended because of a mistake (cheating) but both of them can't giving up entirely; because yeah, it is a mistake. Sumin stucked in her 'revenge' cycle till she lost touch with the real meaning of love. She thought she will never forgive Seju & keep looking for a new relationship. Unfortunately she can't find another person that she loves wholeheartedly like Seju. Sumin didn't fully moved on even when she met a good person (the lawyer one).
Meanwhile Seju kept seeking for forgiveness in her own way (stop drinking & being with Sumin no matter what) She never thought she deserves a second chance & she's grateful that Sumin came back to her (even when she already fucked few women). Seju end up settled down for less & less, as long as Sumin stays with her. Cause Seju think that she'll never love anyone else except Sumin, & she never ready to lose her.
For me they had great relationship, they truly love each other but of course there are bits of them are incompatible. Seju sometimes being too condescending towards Sumin. Sumin also being cruel & cold towards Seju after her mistake. Bitch, ignoring Seju during sex just to pick up a call? Man.. Lol
They had the understanding that Sumin never found in anyone else (before she met Sungji). For 10 years, Sumin supported Seju against her family. Seju always there for Sumin no matter how fcked up she was (drunk & wasted). Without words they still love & care about each other, always.
Sumin felt betrayed because of Seju's mistake but deep down she knew that she still love her. Within those 10 years, they actually already forgave each other but both of them never had a deep heart to heart conversation to say 'I love you'. Sumin was too ego to admit, Seju was too scared of rejection. So they wasted their chance to get back.
Until Sumin met Sungji (who is pure, bold & honest - like young Seju), she mend her heart back. Because Sungji didn't have any expectation on her, always look on the positive side of her & always gave a reply that she never thought of. That's why Sumin fell for her.
I guess Sumin & Seju story is amazing, the character background is well developed. You can't blame any of them. Seju can't be bright & sensitive as Sungji because she never had a mother. So she can't understand Sumin's lost. You can't blame Sumin because she was betrayed at the worst moment in her life (her parents' died). You can't blame both for them for going back to toxic cycle because they really had a great understanding & truly love each other. Just a bad, bad communication. They never admit that they still love each other until it's too late. They never declare anything on their relationship after got back to each other. Like Sumin said 'we can't start over. Because we're cowards who couldn't end things properly'.
I understand how hard it was to move on from your first love, especially when the person is great & the love is mutual. I also understand the feeling of betrayal that is painful & ugly. I also know that certain people deserve second chance. And I understand that staying in the new love is better than go back to your old love story. Because going back to old love is like reading the same book over & over again when you know the exact way it gonna ends.
Extra my own experience (I'm a lesbian btw) : I had a great first love, that I truly love wholeheartedly. I know that she loved me too but we're both scared of the future. So we just ignore our feelings & moved on with our life. I will never forget her, she always be my first love. After 5 years, I still can't fall in love with anyone. Then I met my gf. She has the mind & personality that I never see in anyone else. She's open, honest & bold, just like Sungji. I told her that I might not ready to love her entirely because I had my first love (I'm her first love btw) . Then she replied 'It's okay. Even if you love me 1%, I still love you 110%. Forget that bitch. I will wait till you move on'. That's how I fell in love with her. The understanding, love & sincerity.
But not long enough, she cheated on me. Lol. But take note that I'm living in religious country where homosexuality is a sin & illegal. She tried to have a 'normal relationship' with a guy. Because she thought that she need someone in order to move on from me. Lol. After 2 weeks of texting this guy, I found out her 'cheating' & I left her. But she begged to come back to me & she left that guy once she realize 'you can't use someone to move on from someone else'. That moment I learnt about second chance. I can't move on, I can't stop loving her even I felt betrayed. Because that betrayal has a reason, not that she really loved him.
Long story short, she cut ties with that guy, begged for my forgiveness & I learn to love her back. It took about a year of forgiveness & assurance for that betrayal feeling fade away. But the second chance & forgiveness that I gave, was worth it. We're already 4 years in stable relationship. Hihi.
Lesson learnt :
1. Never, ever cheat on your partner. No matter what's your sexuality. Please. If you're out of love, break up properly. No one deserves to be betrayed. It is the worst feeling.
2. Second chance sometimes worth it. Allow yourself to forgive & forget even though it hurts. Everyone deserves a second chance for their mistake.
3. Sometimes first love just doesn't work. You deserve someone that love & treat you right. You deserve the understanding & honesty. Communication is everything, if you can't be totally transparent with your partner, then they're not the right one. Don't settle for less.
4. Wait till you find the right one. Get to know them first. Not just fuck around & hoping that you met your soul mate. Lol
Soo.. That's my opinion & story. That's the reason why I think that WDTFS is a great story. I understand each character POV & I'm quite satisfied with the ending. Great job team gaji!! ε=ε=(ノ≧∇≦)ノ

Thanks for your detailed thoughts, it really helped bring all of the characters in perspective and helped me understand them all, Seju did cheat on Sumin but she was just drunk and didn't mean anything but Sumin couldn't get past that because she cheated on her at the worst possible time. They both still loved each and couldn't just end it properly, its a sad and beautiful story, thank you once again for giving your thoughts!!! It cleared up alot!!! And yaaaaay!!! I hope your relationship with your significant other remains full of love, understanding, respect, and happiness!! So glad you guys could work it out!!1

Thanks! Which couple do you guys ship?
I honestly still shipping sumin n seju (just because the flash back is so sweet & I'm a whore for sadistic storyline. Lol). But I'm a cheerleader fan Seju & Won too. I hope team gaji produce more story on them. ( ̄へ ̄)
I think this song lyrics really suits Sumin Seju relationship. ╥﹏╥
https://youtu.be/iYdVT-ODiKI
I just wanna say one thingggg, just one thing, I DONT LIKE THE FACT THAT THE STORY LED ME ON!!!! HOW DARE IT LET ME POSSIBLY THINK THAT HANSOO WAS ONE OOF THE MC's HANSOO I LOVE YOU PLEASE GET A STORY OF YOUR OWN WAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH (/TДT)/