two notable things:
first, the way that bitch Yuzuki got confronted was satisfying but I wished he got at least punched in the stomach.
the way Haru didn't come immediately to Renji to take his hand was kinda infuriating. he looks like some bitch acting hard to get when he already knew what's the right thing to do yet still hesitated...
after re-reading it, I think this ones a 3 stars.
I also noticed how readers here are so generous to usually rate 4 & 5 stars everytime even when the book is clearly mid. by doing this it somehow made the rating system worthless.
I know that this is an old comment…
I totally agree with your first two points!! But I gotta agree to disagree with the “worthless rating system”
You claim that some readers are being overly generous by rating certain mangas 4-5 starts, but it’s not that they are being generous… it’s because in their own way, they genuinely liked the story. So where as you would rate this as a mid star manga because you didn’t enjoy it, they too can rate the things they like as 4-5 stars…
So there’s no way that this system is worthless, as it is averaging everyone’s opinions, which is what a rating system is supposed to do. I mean I genuinely hated many 4-5 rated manga/manhwas on here but what can I do if I don’t enjoy things they same way as others.. I simply just add my own ratings to the mix.
of course haru won't come immediately to renji. even if his feelings are deep, eiji literally imprinted on him. and there's a shadow abandonment on his part when renji went away. i wouldn't blame it on him.
both are stubborn.
what they fought about seems too childish for it to be this dramatic.
it was going good until they fought then it's all just patheticness & stubbornness.
what made it even more annoying is that their feelings are already mutuals and yet they have this stupid stupid viewpoint that doesn't even make sense.
and oh. the way they make up... feels empty.
this whole manga did a good job forcing itself to be dramatic even though it's not.
but proceed to choose the shitty one...
pathetic weak ukes usually do not have a choice so it's somewhat understandable they can't let go of their cruel semes but this one has a perfect, way better option.
this is infuriating beyond comprehension.
we should at the very least see the seme getting punched in the stomach.
Everything from the art, plot, settings, characters. everything is perfect.
despite it being a short one it somehow managed to pack a lot of things but with a different perspective it will look like the opposite.
wished it could have been more dramatic like it focuses more on unrequited love and there's the fiance fiasco which could've been something more of a bigger deal.
would also want more of flashback scenes where they just do what high schooler do in their beautiful countryside.
but somehow I'm glad it was a very straightforward phasing, making it easy to digest.
you'll see manhwas thats basically RAPE and abuse all through out the story with 9.0+ ratings
then proceed to criticize a manga like this and bomb rate it wtf.
this was so interesting and somewhat realistic. it was written well; realistically too, the art is good & the phasing in chapters 1-4 were perfect!
My only complain is how they reconciled, it was way too cliché!!! like..
Seme getting into a minor accident > uke getting worried to death > they make up like wtf this shit is waaay too over used asfuvk
I wished the mangaka made a more dramatic scenario for the seme & uke's reconcilation like the uke getting depressed or the uke witnessing the seme getting a girlfriend!!
the uke was quite the annoying one aint he?
he ain't even that pitiful nor his circumstances are. low fertility in women are much more common than you think. and those so called 'miracles' yes it happens a LOT. so I just can't bear to see the uke thinking about the negativity rather than trying to actually get pregnant with the seme.
i like plots with pitiful uke but this one ain't it. he's trying so hard to think of himself as worthless.
the end was abrupt too. a chapter where we could see uke's hardship as a mother would make me add one star. but no, it doesn't seem like he had that kind of hardship.
What he did was truly shit.
what I hated the most though is how he don't realize how bad what he did, yes he knew it was bad but he didn't even apologize in that bench scene when they were talking.
it was never shown he truly regret it. Nakano suffered for 10 years of heartbreak and not even ounce of regret? like boy just back off, you don't deserve Nakano.
the way he justify what he did is so annoying too, the way he explains seems like he's pushing all the blame to Nakano for fuck sake. justifying what he did was okay. then Nakano confessed and all he say was"good" like wtf?
seriously I don't get yall why yall not getting this.
it's one of the VERY few toxic shits that actually had a satisfying end.
the uke was happy at the end. no one was left behind, they we're all happy.
It's not a cliché one too so I don't really get the low rating.
it's a story about manipulation & love triangle and the mangaka delivered.
rating it low just because it's not your cup of tea.... just don't rate it at all lmao. I can understand if the story is annoying or shitty but no this not it.
i think the same lmao, but we know how mangago girlies can be.
the ending left me satisfied since i didn't expect it to end polyamorous. good stuff honestly.
I agree with both comments! Mindset more like myreadingmanga girlies here fufuh
still won't stop me from being irritated by her and calling her a bitch though