MangaThinker's Topics (942)

I think he has 4 currently but he has 10 in total, some must have died or been left :0

I think ha hyun-je just wanted jang seung-min
it didn't happen yet but later on he ends up finding out that ha hyun-je has so much information on him and its kinda creepy
what happen was he was at his house *after they started dating* and ha hyun-je left for work or something and he went through his computer ad he sees all of his work like collage plays and stuff
and his door lock was even the date of his first play
I didn't see what happen yet but oooooof

stalker vibes(●￣(ｴ)￣●)

Oh my... Thank you.

So he likes him for a long time and his stalking him..what is seungmin reaction?

well I don't know if he actually liked him

I'll reply this in every comment comparing the two.

Look... first of all... this is just ONE ACR of a novel. And the comic from it makes no justice to the novel. It's name is Cannon fodder records of counterattacks. Just in case you want to check it out. But you should really read the novel.
Now... let's talk about the similarities and differences between them ok?
Cmmd and Cfrc are similar in 2 points only: they are quick transmigration (qt) and are not romance (usually qt romance has one guy they meet in every world that don't keep their memory but follows the mc around the many worlds and they end up together) that's it.
That's the only similarities. Now for the differences.
Su Luxia is obviously not a "normal person" from the start, it's clear even on the side story about her 1st mission. Ning Shu is a 27yo who died after spending most of her life in a hospital bed. So... she is not OP at all... if anything she is worse than normal people. No knowledge, no relationship experience, no high stats, nothing. So in the first words she has it real hard and this arc is a challenge arc so she can be considered a normal host instead os a fricking noobie.
NS's system is not helpful AT ALL as you've saw unlike SL's bamboo rat he does nothing for her and actually expected her to not even live enough to get over being a noobie. That's how weak she starts as. No system store, no help finding the targets location, no accompanying her through the worlds. She has almost no help from him at all in almost all the worlds she goes.
Cmmd is about a OP mc abusing scum and bettering that body's life. Cfrc is about a WEAK mc getting stronger TO SURVIVE and completing the body's wishes.
Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love cheating men must die. But in regards of character development and world building Cannon fodder wins. Maybe because it's a novel with more than 4k chapters and not only a comic.
The novel is way more slow paced than cmmd... and as I said, besides those 2 points (and getting revenge on others) they are not really similar.

I also know "Quick Transmigration Cannon Fodder’s Record of Counterattacks"!

Are you saying that "I Make Scum Men Cry" is based on that novel? I didn't notice at all!
To be fair there are so many influx of this genre now.

I agree with many of your arguments. But the Ning Shu that I know did a far better job than the version in IMSMC.

There is already a manhua webtoon adaption based on it.
https://mangadex.org/title/46060/cannon-fodder-s-record-of-counterattacks

It's better than "I Make Scum Men Cry" but the overall quality of the comic isn't on the same level as CMMD and TMO.

I really like that novel. She was just a very sick hospital patient and against many odds + deities + greek gods + a very traiterous system she slowly became an invincible entity.
Personally I didn't like the gay harem arc with AIDS... That was just overkill and bad...
And there are many complaints that the author make the MC deliberately left alone since she lost companions or friends + family members left her.
Is Ning Shu now truly alone at the end?

So... yep that's the 5th arc of CFRC... the one where the Og keep living her rapey life again and again and none of the other hosts want to do it (one of them failed at it i think) and she has to accept it to be officially recognized as a host or something...
But yeah... none os these 2 comics makes the novel justice...
I also don't like the linking of being gay and having AIDS... But i didn't think it was overkill... she's not rich, not a business or acting genius... so... that was a good way to deal with them without getting caught...
I would like to see her ending with someone... but it also makes sense that she doesn't.

You seriously think that was the (Only) good way to punish them?
By giving them AIDS for being gay even when they are assholes?

Why not instead make the public think that they have HIV positive even though in truth they are not? Being exposed as gay through online leak the majority of dumb people in this conservative world will never trust these guys again and crucify them for good.

Nope. I don't think it was a good way neither that she did that as a punishment for being gay. What I said is that there was no way to prove that it was her doing. After all they were the ridiculously OP male leads kind of guys. But even if they got proof she got that kind of bloof there was no way to prove she infected him.
Besides if she outed them they could just go to other countries. By giving them a std she destroyed their relationship. All of them got it so there was no way to judge who infected who so there was also the seed of distrust.
Honestly... remember what she did with that one guy? Obesity, wasted legs, and making him dependable on others to live? Ning Shu can be pretty savage in dealing with scum... So she using a std is not surprising.
I don't like the association of Aids with being gay. It's a horrible prejudice that was fairly common in the 90's and I'm glad it lessened. But I feel she would do the same if it was a hetero harem in the same situation. (〜￣△￣)〜
It did irk me but I did understand her use of it...

Good point.
I still really wish the gay harem arc wouldn't exist.
Trope: BURY YOUR GAY + many gay/lgbt movies before 2010s ends with death by suicide, deadly accident, murder or Aids.
Yes, I understand her savage methods but that storyline was just truly insensitive.
Other annoying terrible STDs as punishment yes but please not AIDS.
Because in history AIDS has been always associated with queer people and many (white) heteronormative christian assholes took it as a perfect excuse to further shaming blaming them for anything + dehumanize/marginalize this community/minorities.

100/100 agree!
It was actually an unwritten rule... Queer could be on movies

But could never have a happy ending.
I also wish that arc didn't happen.
On the other side... fortunately we have a good number of QT BL novels... xD

Which arc was it again? I dont remember anymore(￣∇￣")

I bet you all had straight As in reading class. You have good arguments, information backed up, overall organized quite well XD

oops sorry meant to dislike cuz are u serious or just joking cuzzzzz

That is my truth.

hold on i’m sorry but what the actual fuck is wrong with you? no cuz like how could you say that about the person who raised you? and she spent 9 months of hell to birth someone like you?? she probably sacrificed so much for you and this is the thanks she gets? now let me ask you something, do you have a roof over your head? do you have clean clothes? and do you get warm meals? who the hell do you think you are to say something like that about your mom? she’s the one who gave birth to you!!!! not you to her so that means you have absolutely 0 power over her! i mean i’d understand if she was straight up just drinking life away and beating you or neglecting to take care of you and not doing anything but throw shameful words your way or didn’t even want you to begin with and sold you to someone but hasn’t anyone ever taught you to stand up for those weaker than yourself? or do you not get that and someone has to slap it into you? cuz i’d gladly hop through this screen and do it myself! if all you do is look down on people you’ll never be able recognize your own weaknesses or issues. power isn’t a tool that is used to control people, power is something you use for yourself in order to strive towards a better future.....ughhh this just ruined my mood, well i hope you actually learned something instead of just channeling all your anger on someone else and hey get a stress ball or something or go to church if you’re religious which i kind of doubt or go to any type of place you go to if you’re a different religion

From what I get from your message is that you are unwillingly to understand and believe that even any biological parent can screw you up badly regardless of their intentions and reasons...
So instead of asking me why I resent my mother you just demonize me with your absolut correct righteousness and world view.
You can judge me so easily even though you have no idea about my backstory and experiences...

Suit yourself.

how do you know that I have no idea about whatever you’re experiencing?? i said you may have your own reasons but I don’t think it’s right to preach about your so called “power” over her online. i’m only voicing my opinion on this topic but I never said that a biological parent can’t screw you up. I have a lot of experience with this if I do say so myself....thanks also for also assuming that I wasn’t going to ask you about it well actually i really wasn’t going to ask because I don’t think you’d want your business online like that

You just don't want to be in the wrong.
The one thing I learned from you is not to answer and engage with someone who just throw sarcastic remarks and insults to you.
So thanks for the lesson.

no prob and i don’t think i’m in the wrong here are you sure it isn’t yourself? thanks for the lesson as well haven’t met someone who’s just trying to blame someone like you in a while ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Oh and sorry about earlier, I assumed that you were just a spoiled person who thought they could have a little power over their parent cuz they were weaker than them and cause them physical grief cuz lately i’ve been encountering a lot of those and so I just let out a big rant on you that one was my bad but I also don’t think it’s right to say stuff like that but I guess it was just the way you phrased that, that got me kinda pissed at you

After everything you wrote/said to me, there is no way I can't take your sorry seriously or even appreciate it.
I don't know, if you were just impulsive, judgemental, feeling miserable at a moment, feeling personally attacked or afraid of being incorrected, your reaction was for me unreasonably uncomfortable, insulting and exhausting.

Personally, Your sudden change of mind seems to be too disingenuous...

I just don't care anymore... Farewell.

k thennnn take it how ever you want